Oh wow OP.
That is actually an amazing list. I pretty much agree with everything on there.

However, I suggest that you add Otogi: Myth of Demons to Action.

Also,
>The Darkness
>my face when.

I like the list. But I think that JC2 & BF:BC2 were fun games but nowhere near masterpieces. Also I believe there should be a spot for Kotor.

Mount n Blade Warband in RPG?

How come?

But I agree, in general.

>opinions: the thread

Take Majora's Mask off, that game blows.

>>101929751

That was quick

Put Amnesia Dark Descent in survival horror.

I would change THPS2 for Tony Hawks Underground

> dark cloud 2

I LOVE YOU.

All you need to do know is add sonic adventure 2 under pet simulator...

>>101929901
for obvious reasons

>looks at racing genre
>no Mario Kart 64
>MF

Only thing I see wrong is that Metroid Prime is in FPS. Should either be action/adventure or metroidvania (kinda)

>Halo and no Red Dead
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

>Paper Mario instead of TTYD.

Why? Is there anyone out there that preferred the original?

>Halo
>Masterpiece

other people have made faggy lists like this OP, there's an entire wiki on it

Nobody needs your shitty entry into /v/'s opinions

OP,

Cool list. However, you are missing vital games.

Where is Doom?
Where is Quake/Quake 3?
Where is UT/UT2k4?
Where is Killing Floor?
Where is Red Orchestra?
Where is X3?
Where is Metro 2033?

No 8-bit micro games? No Jet Set Willy? No Wizball - in fact, nothing from Sensible?

List is good. But incomplete.

>NOLF
>Fatal Frame 2.
YES

No megaman?

At the risk of sounding like a jerk I gotta say Megaman X3 was probably the pinacle of the series, they got everything right to make it fun yet challenging with the X/Zero Midstage swap and best of all being godly by the end if you play your cards right to have X with the golden armor + Z-saber. game was on the SNES, sega saturn, and Playstation which the later of the 2 had FMVs for the game. No other Megaman X game was as good as 3 before capcom made it a travesty and removed Zero's Buster Arms

>Barely and RTS games
>The newest is Age of Empires 2

So, did the RTS genre clusterfuck or is OP just neglecting everything. Where is the Dawn of War series, Men of War and World in Conflict

>>101930972

X1 was better.

>FPS
>no golden eye

>Shadow of the Colossus
>Good

Shitty Castlevania Lords of Shadow clone

>>101931451

Goldeneye is garbage. It might have been good if you were 12 in the late 1990's, and you never played Doom or Quake - but trust me, if you were an adult at the time, it was a pile of ugly kiddie shit.

>>101931551

Where is Deus ex?

>>101931770

Not at all. This is the truth. Goldeneye was crap.

Go play Quake II. Then play Goldeneye.

Which is better?

>survival Horror
>No Eternal Darkness
nope

¿¿??

>>101931944

are you blind.

>perfect dark
how bout no

>>101932016
I apologize for being up for way too long

Dragon Ball: Budokai Tenkaichi 3

See

>>101929238
>>101929238

>Monkey Island
>Masterpiece

Jesus christ, come on, the humor in that game was weak as fuck and it had nothing else going for it.

It might have been cool when you were 10 and only just started reading H2G2, but that shit doesn't fly today.

>FPS
>BF:BC2
>Not BF2
>No Unreal Tournament

No, no, just please fuck no.

>Bad Company 2
>No BF2

I hope your trolling.

>no SimCity 4

>>101929872
This

>MGS3 in babby's first stealth
>Riddick in Stealth

kill yourself.

i loved mount and blade don't get me wrong but it was a little narrow to be considered a masterpiece, especially for an rpg.

>>101932234

Are you insane?

M&B:W is easily one of the top three games of this generation. Absolutely incredible.

>Not a single FF in the list

Well, I suppose it's because the shitstorm would be great.
I vote for FFX.

>Puzzle
>No Portal
Eh.. Let's revise this shit, bro.

>>101932116

I always perfered the budokai games, but...

Anways, burst limit had AMAZING graphics

you have beatemups but no hacknslash category

your list is now bullshit

>no super meat boy

>Halo
That's cool but you need to add Quake.
Just about everyone on /v/ loves Quake.

Soul Reaver 2 is better than 1? explain!

>>101932296
again i loved the game, but i did think it was clumsily designed also really easy to break.

No Serious Sam, but Halo?

Are you FUCKING MENTAL?

Also
>Babby's first stealth

>>101928419
OP your collection is distinctly lacking something.

Add Uncharted 2, Links Awakening for adventure or portable, and Red Dead Redemption.

>>101932495

Uh, so don't break it.

Clumsily designed? Perhaps - if you consider not being able to jab your fat fingers on an Xbox controller to MAKE COOL SHIT HAPPEN, then yes. Otherwise, it's a traditional set of menus which work fine if you have an I.Q above that of a rock.

>plataformer
>no best plataformer ever
pic related, best platamormer ever

I took this list seriously until I got to the Action / Adventure section. The fact that Majora's Mask can even be pictured next to those other games is ridiculous, and putting it on a list of "masterpieces" is just insulting the reader's intelligence. If you're trolling, 3/10 for guaranteed replies. If you're not, you might want to make a separate list for "grimdark hipster trash" and consider moving it over there.

>>101932584
>Uncharted 2
>Red Dead Redemption

Hahahahaha. Good one. Now, what's your real answer?

I think Mother 2/Earthbound would go on the list.

>>101932563
And for that matter...

Rise of Nations for RTS
TIE Fighter for space sim
Metroid Prime out of FPS and into another category (action/adventure, probably)
Battlefield: Bad Company 2 removed
Just Cause 2 removed

>racing
>no Wipeout
WHY.jpg

No Jedi Knight/Jedi Knight II:JO?
No Battlefront 2?
No Operation Flashpoint?

List is horrible.

>>101932642

>this faggot again

>>101932592
i didn't say the menus were clumsily designed, mainly the bugs, scoring and difficulty systems which you could just make yourself have a higher score by changing things you don't even use. Also its stupid what you said about the controller considering that game was piss easy on 70%

>>101932751
FFFFFUCK YEAH

>>101932778
>TIE Fighter

Sure. But only if you include...

>X3:TC

Those are the rules.

Stopped reading at Devil May Cry 3. I mean, I don't LIKE Ninja Gaiden and didn't love Bayonetta but I could put up with them, but not emokidridesrockets 3.

>>101932592
and saying dont break it is not a defence, at all

I just realized that I can't samefag with a tripcode.

Shame, to lazy to remove it at the moment.

Needs Jak and Daxter and Daxter (the PSP game) in platformers.

And Wipeout HD in racers.

>>101932642
>tragic-fuminori.png
nottoday.bat

>>101932976

It is, totally. The game is nowhere near as broken as you're claiming. You're just being summer and gay.

>Bad Company 2
Hahahaha, oh wait, you're serious? I'm out.

>>101933061

No.

There are many, many more platform games that would go in before any of these titles. What are you, 15?

>>101932688

Yes, you definitely need Earthbound on there OP.

>>101932937

>Judging an action game by the story

Battlefield 1942 added please.

That is all.

Earthbound needs to be on the list

>Penumbra not under Survival Horror

List is totally invalid at this point in time.
And you better not fucking put Amnesia in that category. It's a casual version of Punumbra.

>>101932563

Definitely this.

Lucasarts made the worlds best games back in the days...

Where is the fighting game category?

OP,

How is it that you have The Darkness, Halo, Timesplitters, and Noone Lives Forever instead of Doom, Quake, UT, and Operation Flashpoint?

Explain yourself. Now.

>>101932888
I find your terms acceptable.

Might I suggest Tropico/Tropico 3 under Sims?

You can add the SimCity series under that as well.

Cave Story, OP. Under platformer or run and gun.

And even though I love Fallout 3/NV, I'm not going to complain because they honestly do lack polish. But yeah, I'm happy to see Mother 3 on that list.

Also, the Phoneix Wright games need to be on there, I don't care if you put them under Adventure. Along with 999, too. And TWEWY for JRPG.

Let me fix that FPS section for you.

RTCW
BF2
System Shock 2
CS 1.6/Source
TF2
Quake 3
Painkiller
Doom
Perfect Dark
Half Life 2
Time Splitters
CoD 2(Bit iffy on this one)

There are more popular FPS games but it doesn't make them good.

Suikoden 2 was hailed the best jrpg. odd how its not on the list.

>>101932375

Though I like how smooth the models look in raging blast. I love the ki and lighting effects in BL, they just look 2d in all the tenkainichi games, which sucks becaus it's on a 3d map.

>Bad Company 2
>not Battlefield 2

Nope.

>>101933087
fill your entire army with knights, you win every battle even on high difficulties, you just want to be /v/ and make no arguments

>>101933451

I find your lack of Quake/Quakeworld, Quake II, and Rise Of The Triad disturbing.

Shattered Memories needs to be on this list somewhere.

But it sure as shit isn't a survival horror.

>>101928419

>Ninja Gaiden
>Bayoneta
>Devil May Cry 3
>Orcania of Time
>Majora's Mask
>Prince of Persia
>Beyond Good & Evil
>Okami
>Shadow of the Colossus
>Kirby Super Star
>Psychonauts
>JetSet Radio Future
>Sonic the Hedgehog 2
>Super Mario 64
>Super Metroid
>Fallout
>Paper Mario
>Mother3
>Dark Cloud 2
>Demon Souls
>CRASH TEAM RACING HOLY FUCK YES
>Halo Combat Evolved
>Half Life 2
>Metroid Prime
>No One Lives Forever
>Timesplitters 2
>Perfect Dark
>System shock 2
>Silent Hill 2
>Resident Evil 0
>Fatal Frame II
>Hitman
>Splinter Cell Chaos Theory
>METAL GEEEAAAR
>Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater/ Subsistence
>Tetris
>Ace Combat Zero
>RollerCoaster Tycoon2
>Just Cause 2
>GTA: San Andreas
>God Hand
>Viewtiful Joe

I am proud to have played these games.

SSX Tricky. Aggressive Inline. We Love Katamari. Ape Escape. Resident Evil 4 (in action),>>101928419

Distinct lack of fightan but okay

>nier
>bayonetta
>no final fantasy 12

this is a problem.

fucking bayonetta is a shit game, how is that shit on the list?

downloaded the demo and it reeked of the cancer that is killing video games.

No Alpha Protocol?

What, were you too busy playing Uncharted 2 at your Dad's place?

Max Payne, Max Payne 2, Timesplitters 2, Banjo Kazooie, Half Life 2, Perfect Dark, Command and Conquer, Command and Conquer Red Alert 1 & 2, Heroes MM 3, Commandos 2, Age of Empires 2

That is all. No more, no less.

Nier should not be on there at all

> MGS 1 and 3
> Babby's first stealth tier

Just because you can't appreciate a good game does not mean you have to blatantly disrespect it.

>>101933451
that line at the bottom applies to your list, right?

OP, I actually agree wholeheartedly Although I must admit I havent played some of the games on the list.

>Diablo2
>WRPG
OP get the fuck out with your shit list. if you cant tell a hack n' slash from a RPG you dont have the right to be making anything
go lurk some more faggot

yes im mad

>>101933070
>>101932820

I'm sorry your taste is so backwards that you jump to lap up whatever recycled garbage has "now with 80% more moodiness" slapped on top of it. It's The Legend of Zelda: Grimdark Hipster Bullshit, that's all it is. It was marketed to edgy tweens and emos who wanted Zelda to be less "kiddie" and more "extreme", and the only reason people still fellate it is because it's (rightfully) forgotten in the shadow of Ocarina of Time (which was actually good). It has nothing to do with the game itself, it's just because it's "obscure" and unpopular, so they seem like special unique snowflakes for preferring it. If I had one wish, it would be used to make it so Majora's Mask never existed.

Where's the classic gaming, OP? I'm looking for some Paradroid or some Cannon Fodder, but I'm NOT FUCKING SEEING IT.

>>101932192

This. Where the fuck is your head at OP? SimCity 4.

>metriod
>FPS
also no sc2, no quake...

>Racing
>CTR

I like this.

>>101933179
>Implying you shouldn't

1. dungeon keeper 1 is better than 2
2. gothic 1 is better than 2
3. you're not the white knight of gaming. spot thinking that you're liable to create a /v/ list, for you are not. get your head out of your ass. yours truly, everyone but you

>Needs to make Masterpiece list when you can just go on the /v/ recommendation wiki

>halo
>masterpiece

>>101933660
>>101933654
>hating Bayonetta
Not enough muscular men waving their dicks in your faces?

>>101930503
though i would normally agree,the first halo did an amazing job with what it was trying to do. For that fact alone i would keep it on the list
thought i hate how they rehashed the game over and over again while adding little in regards of combat

OP, take out Bad Company 2 and add Battlefield 2. Then add Quake.

Add Mario Kart as well.

>>101933801

>Metroid Prime
>Not a first-person shooter

Fuck off...

>No Tales of Symphonia or Vesperia

>>101929901
Nope, you can get off the board, so it sucks. It should be THPS3

>Nier
>Not a piece of shit

Riggght.

>Bad Company 2
>Masterpiece

no. Battlefield 2, if you're going to put a battlefield game on there.

>Just Cause 2

No, no, no, no, no. A grappling hook mechanic put ontop of a shallow game does not make it a masterpiece.

>>101928419
I always thought Warcraft 3 was loved by /v/ as an RTS.

>it was before WoW

>>101933954

Explain how Halo did an 'amazing job' with anything other than taking game elements that had all been present for years on the PC, and making them accessible to the console hordes.

Go ahead. I'll wait.

>>101933179
>>101933179

babbys 1st stealth is not a genre. stop being an elitist.

not much point having a recommended list if youre guna let that influence your decisions.

if any thing by putting them under that youre recommending NOT to play them.

The original Half-Life had more of an effect on gaming and was more revolutionary than Half-Life 2. It should be on the list instead or in addition.

Two was a great game but was overly anticipated and forgotten quickly. One spawned Counter Strike, DOD and and endless list of other mods while source mods have failed across the bored. Only a handful have any following.

>No shmups

>>101933781

You.

I like you.

Put Indiana Jones: And the fate of Atlantis adventure game list. It has the intelligent story akin to beneath a steel sky and humour that is present with all of the Lucasarts adventure games. I would say it's the best Lucasarts point and click game ever made, but that is just my opinion.

>>101934054
revolutionized matchmaking for consoles.
check and mate

>Space combat
>No freelancer
areyoufuckingkiddingme.jpg

I fixed your list

>>101934106
>Half Life 2
>'forgotten'

Uh. Are you being deliberately stupid?

>>101934112

Gunstar Heroes nigger, have you heard of it?

Though on that note, why no Alien Soldier OP?

>>101932503

>ripoff of Duke Nukem 3d
>a masterpiece

>>101934224

'For consoles'.

So, in other words, it did nothing but take things that had already existed - for years - on the PC and made them accessible to console vermin.

Like I said in the original post.

Got anything else?

dude, DUDE

>>101928419
>>Sports
>>No WWF No Mercy
>>No 1080 Snowboarding
>>No Mario Golf Toadstool Tour

>>101934054
explain were you could find this arena combat before halo then and don't say quake as that is not even close

>>101932563
I was thinking the same thing, and OP put The Dig on the list too, for shame!

>>101934308
>Calls SS a ripoff of Duke 3D
>Doesn't realise that Duke 3D is a rip off of Doom, crossed with a rip off of Army Of Darkness

Yeah. You're stupid.

>Only one game in Space Combat and it's the only one that deserves to be there

Where are the space games of yesteryear?

>>101933801

SC2 is made for koreans and tourneyfags where SC1 was made for people that liked WC2, and they wanted to try something like it in space.

Would /v/ bros agree?

Please tell me you agree. If not I will be disappoint.

Series has gone downhill since this game.

WHERE IS TF2?!?!

>>101934336
if were talking "master pieces" here then your just comparing canvas size, come back to me when you have a real argument

>>101934436

Uh. Ever played Unreal Tournament, little man?

>Saint's Row 2 not in Sandbox
>Resident Evil 4 not in Third Person Shooter
>Quest for Glory series not in Adventure
>Implying MGS3's perfect run is not hard as balls

>>101934106
>across the bored

>>101934520
TF2 is a great game, but not a masterpiece compared to other games.

Where is Deus Ex?

>>101934354
Pikmin 1 was better
not that 2 wasn't a masterpiece
but 1 was better

Why do you asspies continue making gay fucking lists when we have a fucking wiki to the recommended games.

God you guys are fucking abysmal losers.

>Mother 3
>Not Mother 1 and Mother 2

The Sims 1 and/or 2 and SimCity 4 in general sim.

>>101934436

EVERY other old school FPS with a multiplayer mode

>>101934629
Under WRPG?

Master of Orion II - the best space 4x game to date
Red Alert 2 - the C&C series should definitely be in
and you should have something from Quake/UT

can someone tell what the shoot-em-ups are? way too tiny

>>101934600
Pretty much everyone on /v/ loves it

Not OP, but working on a revised version. but It is a great list.

Haters gonna hate, but I'm:

Exchanging Half Life 1 with Half Life 2.

Adding Resident Evil 4 under Action/Adventure. Because that's what it's more like.

Adding Paper Mario and The World Ends With You

Adding Elite Beat Agents under music.

Exchanging BC2 with Battlefield 2.

Adding Cave Story to Platformer, just for the sake of simplicity.

Feel free to call me a faggot or disagree with what I have.

>>101933660
That's because you just played the demo. The full game, on hard? Son, you better bring a bottle of Jack and some extra self-esteem, because on normal, this game is a hell of a challenge, on Hard, it'll rape you. And you'll like it. Not because of the sexy main character, not because of the insane plot; no you'll like it because it puts a strong emphasis on gameplay over everything else. I love it for the same reason I love Demon's Souls. It's a challenge that can truly be enjoyed.

>>101933592

I 2nd SSX Tricky.

>>101933691

I 2nd Timesplitters 2, Commandos 2 + CnC Red Alert 1+2 (different enough to both belong on the list).

Also i would add NBA Street 2 + NFL Street 2. Both very fun games, I havnt played 3 for either of these but 2 for both of these series were prety perfect.

>NOT RISE OF NATIONS IN RTS

NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS
NO RISE OF NATIONS


What a mistake. /v/ loves RoN.

Needed additions:

>Sports
NFL 2K5, NBA 2K11, Tecmo Bowl

>Beat em Up
The Warriors, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World

>>101934737
>Exchanging Half Life 1 for Half Life 2

You're a faggot. They should both be included, for different reasons.

>>101934730
Liking a game doesn't make it a masterpiece.

i thought everybody loved Chrono Trigger?

>>101934054

How about playing the game first, asshat. It was incredibly incredibly atmospheric for its time, had great art direction and AI design.

Also, regen shields, which was a refreshing change before it got copypasted into every other game.

Best 2.5D platformer.

>>101934600

Name a game very similar to TF2, but better.

TF Classic doesn't fucking count

>>101934336

I don't believe any shooter had a vast back story with an entire canon before halo.

Hell, the first book came about before CE!

I nominate:

-Assassin's Creed II for adventure or action adventure (or if you really want to put it there, stealth but I don't think it's really stealth)
-Resident Evil 4 as a Third Person shooter (it really doesn't qualify as survival horror, but if you want to put it there fine).
-Super Mario Galaxy or Super Mario Galaxy 2, or both for platformer
-Super Mario World for platformer
-Turtles in Time (the original) for beat em up
-Mega Man X for platformer or action/adventure (where's an action platformer genre?)
-Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals for JRPG

I like the look of this list as a whole but can someone justify the darkness being on there?

A Shin Megami Tense game should be in the JRPGs. Nocturne is the most unanimous choice round here.

>>101934864

Marathon, motherfucker, have you heard of it?

>>101934864
>I don't believe any shooter had a vast back story with an entire canon before halo.

lulwut.

>>101934766
I can't even play other games similar to it now.
I got GoW3 the other day and every time I'm about to play it I just think to myself 'why play this when bayonetta has better gameplay/combat' and end up playing that

I preffer gen 2, but anyways...

can
someone
tell
what the shoot-em-ups
are?
way too tiny

thx

Why no Killer 7?

That game may not be flawless, but damn, it's the closest thing I've played besides FFT.

Where is Call of Duty United Offensive?

>>101934864

You're joking, right?

You could probably put an Ace Attorney game on here. Either 1 or 3.

Maybe I'm just a tard, but I think UT 2k4 belongs on that list. Such polish, great maps, satisfying weapons and excellent mod support is why I still pop open UT 2k4 w/ Ballistic Weapons every few weeks and just go fucking nuts. Permanent blood splatter, brass, gibs, and bullet holes.

>>101934336
>console vermin
A little harsh, don't you think?

>>101934877

>where's an action platformer genre?

This, put Rondo of Blood there as well.

>>101935061

>thinking star wars is a video game IP

>>101934831

So, again, it did nothing new. It was 'extremely atmospheric'? So was System Shock, asshole.

Stop defending your low-rent trash just because you like it.

Put Mega Man 2 in there under platformer.

>>101935138
Ikaruga
Radiant Silvergun

I'm surprised that Raiden 2/Raiden Fighters Jet isn't on there.

>>101934532
loled k we got ourselves a troll im outta here

>>101934886

The Darkness's voice acting, the interesting approach to gunplay, the feeling of being a horror movie monster, the plot punching you in the gut like three times, a weird as hell World War I sequence that's still somehow kinda fun.

>>101934978
Ironically made by the same studio as Halo.

They predated their own title.

Why is mario world not on here? Even Miyamoto himself said it was the game he wanted mario 3 to be.

>>101935257

Good idea. Fuck off. You don't know anything about games, and you have no place in this thread.

>Ctrl+F BF2
Ok, /v/ isn't completely hopeless
>Ctrl+F BF2142
>No BF2142
Fuck you /v/. You guys have let me down.

>>101935138

Ikaruga and Radiant Silvergun, which are both awesome I agree.

>>101935249
Damn right man, there is a disturbing lack of Mega Man on this list.

>>101935262
Not to say that it wasn't a good game but considering how few have actually made this list it's just not that impressive.

>>101935253

ty sir

the darkness

Pffft ahahahahahah

the main character in that game walks like he's taking a leisurly stroll in the park when he's got fucking dark matter snakes coming out of his back! what the fuck! plus none of the guns have an effective range to compensate the cra- i mean walk speed run out of ammo in like 30 seconds of combat. all in all it was utter shit

I nominate Red Orchestra for the First Person Shooter category

Fallout 2 instead of Fallout 1. Meh opinions.

At least Deus Ex was on there...
And thank god for Soul Reaver, although the first was arguably the better game for the time.

>Halo
>masterpiece

This is the worst list ever

>>101934260

Based on the steam player statistics the number of people playing Half Life in both single player and multiplayer far outweigh the number playing Half Life 2 if comparing the statistics when both games had been out an equal legnth of time.

In fact I was excited to start playing HL2:DM but when it was finally released it died instantly. Servers were dropping left and right and thousands less played each day.

Right now there are 581 players in HL2:DM and 1024 in single player. At this point in for Half-Life at the seven year mark in 2006 there were tens of thousands of people online in multiplayer in thousands of servers.

>>101935241

Read the entire post, instead of just the first half of the first line, then reply to me again.

>>101935351
Megaman 2 at the very least had better get on there

>>101935334
That is what Battlefield can do when it isn't confined by "realism".

Basically, Battlefield can do amazing. Pure, unfiltered, uncensored amazing.

>No bioshock in FPS

No castlevania 4 or Rondo of blood?

No Spyro the Dragon? Why's that?

<101933811

where is that hotness from?

>>101928419

Damn, that's good.

I'd like to suggest Saints Row 2 under Sandbox, though. Amazing game alone, even better with a bro.

And Wild ARMs 3 for JRPG, but that's just because I fucking love the Wild West and it's everywhere in that game.

Run & Gun
>Contra

First-Person Shooter
>Team Fortress 2 (/v/ hates the hats, but loves the game)
>Golden-eye

JRPG
>Final Fantasy VI (It's at least the most respected FF game on /v/)

Real-Time Strategy
>Warcraft 3

MMOs
>World of Warcraft (Vanilla)

Puzzle
>Portal (/v/ just hates the fanbase)

>Babby's First Stealth
Is this really necessary?

Puzzle Platformer?
>Ico

Fighter
>Street Fighter IV
>Super Smash Bros. Melee

Racing
>Mario Kart 64

Survival Horror
>Amnesia: The Dark Descent

Beat-em-up
>River City Ransom

Platformer
>Megaman 2

That's all I can think of right now.
The only game on that list I find questionable is Bayonetta. I thought /v/ hated it for all the QTEs and blatant sexual innuendos.
Also, did anyone else love Machinarium?

Who else thinks Rome: Total War belongs in turn based strategy? Picked it up from the Steam Sale, not far into it but so far it's awesome.

>>101935421

I second that nomination of Red Orchestra

>>101935469

No problem! I'll even QUOTE the post and go through it line by line. How's that?

>How about playing the game first, asshat. It was incredibly incredibly atmospheric for its time, had great art direction and AI design.

These are all debatable, and they don't make the game 'a masterpiece'. Halo had great art direction? So have hundreds of other games in the genre. If 'great art design' and 'great AI design' are going to be our measures of 'masterpieces', we're going to have a lot of fucking masterpieces.

>Also, regen shields, which was a refreshing change before it got copypasted into every other game.

A refreshing change? You mean, the FPS genre was made easier for people like you.

That doesn't make Halo a masterpiece. On the contrary, it makes it a game that contributed to the ruin of the mainstream FPS.

You're a moron, you know nothing about gaming, and you are an embarrassment. Now, respond to my points or fuck off.

>>101935705
Seconding this, RTW is a great game

>Turn-based strategy
>No Fire Emblem

>>101935421
Here here!

>>101935466
>Everyone is getting mad about Halo
Fair enough but wait...
>These are the same people that didn't play Marathon
If you haven't played Marathon, you don't jack shit about FPS.

>>101935421
>>101935721
>>101935783

+1 to Red Orchestra nomination.

>>101935683

>The only game on that list I find questionable is Bayonetta. I thought /v/ hated it for all the QTEs and blatant sexual innuendos.

Those are just the people that based their opinion of the game on Yahtzee's review.

Here we go, faggots. Using a trip for now, so people can hate me more effectively.

>>101935683

>Machinarium

Forgot about that. Should definitely belong on the list.

>>101935809

I nominate Marathon Infinity for inclusion in the list

>OOT
>Strangers Wrath
>Okami
>Psychonauts
>SMB3
>DKC2
>BK
>Paper Mario
>Dark Cloud 2
>CTR
>Halo CE

So happy to see some of my favorites on there. I'd think that Pikmin would be on there for RTS, but I don't really care that it isn't up there, wasn't too popular.

>>101934224

You do realize that saying a game "revolutionized something for consoles" is like saying a chef that just shits on a plate is "revolutionizing corn for shit-eaters"?

>>101935930

List is still shit.

Why aren't you listening?

Wow... I've actually taken something from all this, I actually like alot of games, like a whole lot, hell that there's so many games that could be considered this good is in itself impressive, had a hard enough time coming up with a top 10 already.

No Age of Mythology? I am disappoint.

>>101935930
>turn-based strategy
>still no Fire Emblem

OP I suggest you put in Battlefront for TPS and Republic Commando for FPS.

>>101934978

I have.

Are YOU aware that Marathon was made by the same people as Halo, and Halo is more or less a retelling of Marathon?

Hm?

Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney should be there.

Who doesn't like that game?

>>101935334
I've actually have BF2 and 2142 & expansion packs included laying on my desk for several years (got them free at some summer tech camp) but haven't gotten around to installing them. Would it be too late to go at them now?

>>101935930
>BC2 still there
>Red Orchestra, Arma 2, and BF2 still aren't

>Battlefield BC2

Are... are you guys serious about that? Gotta be a trollin'.

>>101936054
Halo is the prequel to Marathon.

>>101935930

>No Mega Man or Classicvania

Are you even trying,

>Resident Evil 4 in Third Person Shooter or Survival horror.
> Mario Kart 64 or Double Dash because it's way better in Racing.
> Batman: AA...somewhere.
> Also, no Mass Effect?

We should probably include Red Dead Redemption in the Open World category

>>101936054

Way to prove his point.

>mario 64
>OoT

Paper Mario should be replaced with Thousand Year Door.
Majora's Mask, while great, should be replaced with Wind Waker.
Add Tomba and Cave Story to platformers.

Megaman 2/3/X needs to be on there somewhere.

>>101935930
still no crash badicoot warped or pikman

Just needs some Gabriel Knight in the adventure category to be truly perfect.

Pikmin 2 should be there. Perfected 1 in every way.