Posting mode: Reply
[Return]
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • File : 1275698967.gif-(159 KB, 550x539, DysnSphr.gif)
    159 KB A question for you... Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:49 No.10279647  
    A hypothetical question for you gentlemen.

    Suppose an unfathomably advanced alien race were to appear to humanity, and as they often do, this race decides to present humanity with what they consider a token of good will. They will create a complete Dyson sphere with a 1AU radius around our star, so that Man need never squabble over land again. We will assume that this environment is in no way a trap or trick, and is perfectly capable of sustaining human and Terran animal life.

    Though, as these hypotheticals often do, this scenario comes with a catch. Each person may bring only three things with them, but you may choose wherever you wish to live. Naturally the sheer enormity of available land means that, if you choose to be alone, you will likely never see another human again.

    So, /tg/, what do you bring? Where do you live? Alone, living off the land? Perhaps an isolated village? Or do you head for a population hub?
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:52 No.10279712
    A knife, a first aid kit, and my dog.
    Head out to the middle of nowhere, make myself a bow and arrows, live Ranger style.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:53 No.10279716
    >1 AU around sun
    >Solar system seriously screwed up now
    >XEENOOOSS
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:53 No.10279717
    Well, here is my catch.

    I am only bringing one thing.

    Since the Dyson is complete and at 1AU, I will bring the Earth and all of it's content.

    (._. )
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)20:54 No.10279736
    A dyson sphere with what level of infrastructure present on the surface?
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:55 No.10279742
    >you will likely never see another human again

    Here's the problem. I'm not a doctor, a farmer, or a vet.
    I could build a house, but where do I get the wood? Who's going to mill it? Who's going to make my nails?

    Hell with it, I live in a commune on the far side of the sphere. Also, people will find things to fight about eventually. Even if resources were infinite, somebody would want the most.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:55 No.10279748
    Clearly this is a trap from xenos that wants to keep lesser races from advancing.
    Though if they could make something that massive like it's nothing, we wouldn't stand a chance anyway.

    >>10279717
    Ok, where are you going to put it? Oops, it jsut crashed into the surface of the sphere's interior. Rocks fall, everyone dies. Xeno sphere is unharmed.
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)20:57 No.10279783
    >>10279748
    A spherical shell exerts no net force on objects inside. The planet wouldn't hit the shell unless it started with a velocity towards it.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:58 No.10279812
    A record of all the xeno's knowledge.
    A computer which can process the knowledge and algorithms which they have in about 10 weeks.
    A generator that will never shut down.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:59 No.10279814
    Hrmmm. I'd probably choose to live in a remote village somewhere way far away.

    Though I see a slight problem with that. With such massive distances between settlements, travel between them would be essentially impossible. After a few generations, people not living is large population clusters are going to start facing complications from lack of genetic diversity.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)20:59 No.10279820
    Didn't you guys see the ST:TNG episode where they get trapped in that thing?

    STAY AWAY FROM THE SPHERE, EVERYBODY IS DEAD
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:00 No.10279836
    >>10279812
    I would also live on the external surface, in a massive forest. With cheese.
    Lots, of cheese.
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)21:00 No.10279839
    >>10279814
    Unless you're talking fewer than a dozen people... no, not really.
    >> QuestionC 06/04/10(Fri)21:02 No.10279879
    Can someone explain to me how gravity is supposed to work?
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:03 No.10279905
    I work out with a large group of people to each bring an item that will be needed to build a civilisation.
    Me one of my items will be the largest capacity external HD I can get hold of to store all of the information we'd need. Medical, scientific, construction, you name it.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:04 No.10279913
    A supercomputer with all the xeno's knowledge, all of it converted to English.

    A Generator which can power the supercomputer and a massive city, such as LA, as a minimum, with powering all of America as a maximum.

    All the people at my school living in our home city, transplanted onto the external surface of the Dyson sphere, if and only if they have made both the internal sphere, and the external sphere have atmosphere.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:04 No.10279914
    >>10279879
    Kind of like magnets.
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)21:04 No.10279915
    >>10279879
    gravity generators.

    spinning it doesn't provide any gravity over most of the surface.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:05 No.10279940
    >>10279783
    But the thing has a 1AU (~149.5M km) radius. Earth's orbit is elliptical, ranging in distance from the sun from 145M km to 152M km. So depending on when it was made, best case the Earth is either trapped within the shell or outside, either way when its orbit progresses it will impact the sphere.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:06 No.10279967
    >>10279940
    Assume the earth will be used in the construction of the Dyson sphere.

    And assume that there will be atmosphere on both the inside, and the outside, with ways to transport from either.
    >> QuestionC 06/04/10(Fri)21:06 No.10279975
         File1275700001.jpg-(19 KB, 581x326, magnets.jpg)
    19 KB
    And I don't wanna talk to a scientist
    Y'all motherfuckers lying, and getting me pissed
    >> Golden Neckbeard !!MA40nsGlj/I 06/04/10(Fri)21:06 No.10279976
         File1275700002.jpg-(22 KB, 250x250, according to this.jpg)
    22 KB
    I immediately join whatever organized attempts are made at intelligently distributing the collective three choices across the entire techno-industrial spectrum so that the most civilization possible can be preserved.

    I only donate two of my items to this cause, though. My third item is "The Library of Congress."

    I choose to live in the largest vaguely libertarian population center.
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)21:07 No.10279990
    >>10279940
    right, because they would build it that way.

    it is fun assuming a race of aliens with the technology to build a Dyson sphere wouldn't have the forethought to make sure that it isn't going to be smacked by a planet.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:07 No.10279997
    >>10279976
    Mr. Neckbeard. May I change your request for the Library of Congress, to the the whole American continent?
    >> QuestionC 06/04/10(Fri)21:07 No.10279998
    >>10279915
    > gravity generators.
    So... magic?
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)21:09 No.10280023
    >>10279998
    Something like that. You would need sufficiently advanced materials to build the sphere anyway.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:09 No.10280034
    >>10279839
    I think I read somewhere that a population consisting of 180 people is needed to ensure genetic viability for ~80 generations.
    >> Golden Neckbeard !!MA40nsGlj/I 06/04/10(Fri)21:10 No.10280057
         File1275700229.jpg-(21 KB, 250x250, innocent.jpg)
    21 KB
    >>10279997

    Now we're just getting smug!
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)21:10 No.10280059
    >>10280034
    in a non-expanding population sure. with unlimited land the population will expand.

    Explode, even.
    >> URIST "MOTHER FUCKER" TREE KILLER 06/04/10(Fri)21:11 No.10280078
         File1275700305.jpg-(59 KB, 922x382, EIRUST.jpg)
    59 KB
    >>10280057
    oh hey there
    given up have you?
    >> Golden Neckbeard !!MA40nsGlj/I 06/04/10(Fri)21:13 No.10280105
    >>10280078

    Nope, was unexpectedly gone for a week, so just missed the last two threads.

    'spect I'll start one myself the next time I have any cool ideas in that vein, or completed art.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:13 No.10280113
    >>10280034
    That assumes you're trying to maintain a static population level. In a situation like this, where you have all but unlimited natural resources and land, it's not the same.

    A starting population of as few as 15-20 people would be sufficient.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:17 No.10280189
    One thing I learnt from Iron Quest is that people can see your star go out, and that you've put a Dyson Sphere up.

    Beware of RKVs.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:17 No.10280194
         File1275700634.jpg-(555 KB, 795x1880, 1273365566357.jpg)
    555 KB
    >>10279976
    >>10280057
    pic related, it's you.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:18 No.10280215
         File1275700702.jpg-(34 KB, 512x384, 1275432573591.jpg)
    34 KB
    OP here, It seems I left a few things out, my apologies.

    --You can only take things that you personally own. So no claiming xeno-technosorcery, or libraries, or continents.
    --We will also assume that the entire leadership of Earth consented to this, and the price for its creation is the destruction of our planet, to act as a catalyst in this massive construction.

    All in all though, I like the direction of this thread. It's nice to see civil discussion.
    >> Lazarus !!s4aNsOVuwew 06/04/10(Fri)21:20 No.10280248
    >>10279990
    hyperspatial express route ring a bell anyone?
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:23 No.10280309
    >>10280215
    That's it.
    I am now certain beyond all doubt we are being placed into a massive alien zoo habitat.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:25 No.10280337
    >>10280215
    ... well fuck that.
    Do you mean own? possess? or what, as with own that basically means only shit that you made with your own two hands...
    >> Boomer !!MBwbEofHcyx 06/04/10(Fri)21:25 No.10280338
    >>10280194
    Golden Neckbeard has the coincidental "honor", if you can call it that, of having a beard on his neck that is gold. His face is quite literally /tg/ related, he is a meme incarnate. Second, he contributed the magic the gathering thing. That's more than a lot of people here do.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:26 No.10280352
         File1275701173.png-(207 KB, 500x247, Halo3_ark-and-halo-reborn.png)
    207 KB
    What's a dyson sphere? Is it sorta like a Halo?
    >> QuestionC 06/04/10(Fri)21:27 No.10280371
         File1275701239.png-(133 KB, 354x363, feels-good-head-0.png)
    133 KB
    >>10280194
    > Click reply links
    > Can't see posts due to greasemonkey

    Seriously, if someone insists on annoying narcissistic behavior, then they're doing you a favor by using a trip. It's worth the trouble to download Greasemonkey and the 4chan script.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:28 No.10280379
    >>10280352
    it encompasses a star, and collects energy.
    It is also hard shelled.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dyson_sphere
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:29 No.10280396
    >>10280371

    >hating on Golden Neckbeard

    Get the fuck out of /tg/, nigger. Why don't you get an early start on your summer reading for 10th grade. The Scarlet Letter is going to take at least three months for a fuckface like you to work through.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:30 No.10280414
    >>10280215

    Is this Dyson sphere just going to be a vast wilderness, or will they set up cities for us?

    Also, is there any way to get between the inner and outer surface? Because if not then everyone inside is trapped, FOREVER; granted it's a lot of space to tramp around in, but still. And people outside had no source of light, ETERNAL NIGHT AWAITS, presuming that enough heat is transferred from the inside to the outside that everything doesn't just freeze eventually anyway.

    Also, is it only stuff we OWN now or stuff we can theoretically own? Like we could take a horse because it would be possible to buy one but not alien tech because it's not possible to buy it (presumably).
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:30 No.10280418
    Laptop with a shitload of important documents and historical texts. A loaded gun. The recipe for Coca Cola. A city.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:30 No.10280420
    >>10280352
    Sort of, except it's far bigger and it's a sphere instead of a ring.

    >>10280337
    I'm taking it to mean things that are yours, just to prevent people from trying to take the entire library of congress or the planet because it's collectively one "thing."
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:30 No.10280425
    My computer because it's got all my shit on it, and hopefully there would be some kind of internet system set up quite quickly.

    My big TV with the appropriate cables to connect to the computer, so I can watch movies and keep myself entertained when not doing computer shit.

    A gun. I'm not a /k/razy bastard, I've never fired a gun before and I'm not too thrilled on them, but if distances ARE this vast and we're pretty much abandoning established geographical boundaries of governance, I can't imagine there will be much in the way of established government on the sphere. No established government means no one paying police and soldiers to protect my fat ass. No protection + limited initial resources = Mad Max style raiders emerging and stealing everyone's shit. Sure, my puny single gun in the hands of someone who's never shot one before won't do much to deter them, and will make them that much more dangerous when they kill me and steal it, but it'd be a nice psychological comforter.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:30 No.10280426
    >>10280352

    No. It's built around a star to capture it's energy. It's not self powered, like Halo apparently is.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:32 No.10280453
    >>10280425 samefaggin'
    Oh, and if possible I'd live in a suburban-like area. An Urban environment isn't my style, and I'd burst out into tears if left alone in a field with a cow.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:32 No.10280457
    >>10280215
    How does the surface look like?
    Are there different climate zones?
    Is everything raw nature, or are there technical areas like maintenance areas, or fields of concrete, or some other shit?
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)21:34 No.10280495
         File1275701673.gif-(14 KB, 490x260, 1236166619_unzipping_the_inter(...).gif)
    14 KB
    >>10280215
    >>10279647
    Just how much time do we have to prepare? Batman thinks this is critical.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:35 No.10280516
    >the price for its creation is the destruction of our planet, to act as a catalyst in this massive construction.
    Where the fuck was the entire earth's biosphere in the time between earth's destruction and the finished sphere?
    >> QuestionC 06/04/10(Fri)21:37 No.10280546
    >>10280516
    Staying at a space HoJo.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:37 No.10280549
    >>10280338
    Contributions are one thing, wanting credit for your not-so-sharp wit is another.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:38 No.10280558
         File1275701910.jpg-(388 KB, 1280x1969, Return of Bruce Wayne #2 005.jpg)
    388 KB
    >>10280495
    batman's already got the complete encyclopedic knowledge of the entire universe.

    The Internet is pretty insignificant amongst his archives.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:39 No.10280578
    >>10280549
    Namefags like to stroke each others egos.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:40 No.10280596
    There will be three hiveworld sized cities created, two relatively near one another, another isolated. Groups planning to create a village or town may requisition a location with appropriate vegetation and terrain. Beyond that, it is a randomized collection of all terrains that exist on Earth.

    The environment is along the interior side of the shell. There in one enormous hatch on the "top" (relative to the earth's orbit) should man ever develop the need or desire to travel out in the stars. The idea is to give primitive races like Humanity breathing room during a difficult point in their technological development.

    >>10280414
    By own, I mean theoretically possible for a single civilian to possess, so there's no bringing along nuclear warheads, entire libraries, alien technologies, and so forth.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:40 No.10280598
    I would bring my computer, and some tools. Not sure for my third item.

    I would live on the night side (I'm pale; I hate the sun). I would try to find a relatively small satellite community, which was near a major population center. Preferably with libertarian leanings. And obviously, they are all gamers. Video games, traditional games, and outdoor games (like paintballing and shit).
    >> Lazarus !!s4aNsOVuwew 06/04/10(Fri)21:40 No.10280606
    ITT: OP forgets this is /tg/ and we need a page or two of details before we can make a choice.

    What's the surface like? Are all of our cares taken care of like food dispensaries every two miles, beautiful allergy free light wilderness with eco-friendly housing for everyone and reliable, xenos-level wireless internet hotspots everywhere, etc.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:41 No.10280612
    >>10279647
    > Each person may bring only three things with them

    Uhh... why? More destination space than we can comprehend, and the technology to build a Dyson sphere means no space constraints and probably no tonnage limits on transport.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:41 No.10280626
    >>10280596
    Hah, I'm taking over my hive asap.
    >> -|- Reichsguard -|- !!bOOhb8C7gxV 06/04/10(Fri)21:41 No.10280627
         File1275702106.jpg-(7 KB, 93x100, killy 100x.jpg)
    7 KB
    This is not going to end well. This is not going to end well at all.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:42 No.10280645
    In case you were wondering:

    The Dyson sphere has an inside (I'm going to assume that 1AU is inside radius) surface area of 6.29*10^33 km. Assuming that 6 billion people get transported, each person would have about 10*24 km of space to themselves (that's 247 million billion billion acres) or about 2*10^15 surface areas of Earth (that's 2 million billion Earths)

    Assuming it is 1 km thick (a VERY liberal estimate, and that 1AU is the outside radius) it would have the volume of about 260,000 Earths
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:44 No.10280672
    >>10280645
    All goes well until someone decides to make the sun nova.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:45 No.10280688
    Incidentally, this would mean a lull in progress for a long time. No competition would equate to...bad things.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:47 No.10280722
    >>10280645
    MATH!

    Btw: is there something that simulates night-time?
    Because no night will pretty much fuck everything over except light loving plants...
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:48 No.10280743
    >>10280688
    Which is, I suspect, their ultimate goal.
    They present all races this seemingly amazing gift for their future, and it actually causes them to revert and lose all forward progress. In short, it's a huge zoo habitat.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:48 No.10280747
    >>10280722
    even better: no daytime
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:48 No.10280754
    >>10279967

    >Assume the earth will be used in the construction of the >Dyson sphere.

    Cheater. "They will create" does not imply "out of your home planet" (._. )
    >> Lazarus !!s4aNsOVuwew 06/04/10(Fri)21:49 No.10280759
    >>10280606
    OP also forgot to mention which type of Dyson Sphere we're talking about

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dyson_sphere#Dyson_swarm
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:49 No.10280764
    >>10280743
    eh, they're already far enough ahead of us

    they're just doing what we'd do, giving us a toy so we don't bother them later
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:50 No.10280788
    >>10279879
    >>10279915

    Uhm like it always does - Mass. You stick to the surface, on inside or out. If you look at the diagram those rings are easily 100 earth diameters.

    Hell, you better hope it is still ~1g gravity and that the escape velocity doesn't get any worse than it already is.

    (._. )
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:50 No.10280789
    >>10280722
    Assume there is a network or orbiting halos around the sun to draw power for its internal workings and provide night cycles.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:51 No.10280799
    >>10280627
    Killy Log: Been walking for 50 years since the megaconstruct incident, havent seen anyone yet.

    I wish I brought a gameboy.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:51 No.10280804
    >>10280722
    If you think about it, inhabiting the inside of a Dyson Sphere also sort of defeats the original purpose, which is too capture the energy output of the sun, and I don't think plants would be able to use enough of it to not have the surface temperature be boiling hot.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:53 No.10280839
    >>10280804
    I suspect that any sufficiently advanced race that can create a Dyson Sphere is also aware of the necessity to vent all that excess energy somewhere.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:55 No.10280882
    >>10280804
    The funny thing with a dyson sphere is that it does not matter at all what is on the inside. The star's energy can not go anywhere except into the dyson sphere. It does not really matter if it's doing this in the form of radiation, heat, or whatever.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)21:56 No.10280898
    >>10280627
    Year 92, day 276. I saw a campsite today. It looks old.

    The odds of even that much happening are astronomical.
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)22:00 No.10280989
    >>10280788
    The problem is this: no matter how massive the sphere is, on the inside, there is no net force. You can spin it, but that isn't going to provide gravity over the whole surface of the sphere, and there would be vast areas that gravity would not be perpendicular to the standing surface (barring terracing). Gravity generators of some sufficiently advanced variety are the only effective method of providing gravity to the entire surface.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:03 No.10281020
    >>10280989
    I always thought dyson spheres had the people on the outside

    but I guess artificial gravity?
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:04 No.10281049
    >>10280645

    human population grows exponentially

    within a few thousand years humans would be all over the place
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:04 No.10281058
    1) 1 Barrett M82A1 with 100 rounds
    2) 1 Camo Cloak
    3) A book of all edible and/or useful plants for the terrain I will be living in.

    I choose an isolated, large-ish non-urban settlement, and begin hunting. After I systemically eliminate all the men, I wait roughly a year, then enter as a traveler from another city.

    Then I enjoy my own personal harem.
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)22:05 No.10281074
    >>10281020
    Could be either. For reference.. the gravity on the exterior would be... dependent on the average density of the sphere. Bleh.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:08 No.10281138
    >>10281058
    >Barrett m82
    >to kill people.

    A bit overkill there, sir.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:08 No.10281148
    >>10281049
    That's a lot of time. People breed when they're in close quarters. How many people would choose to be alone to begin with? How many people would die because no one decided to bring medicine or medical knowledge, or couldn't get to someone who did, because everyone's so far apart?
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:17 No.10281324
    >>10281049
    If we are to assume that the population growth rate is the same, it would take about 3300 years to get a density of population over the surface on the Sphere equal to that on Earth.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:23 No.10281411
    The aliens are actually using the 1 AU radius sphere as a shipyard were we are all forced to build the 1 AU long ship from a few months back.
    >> Anonymous 06/04/10(Fri)22:30 No.10281533
    >>10281324
    but there's no oceans, either

    and population growth wouldn't remain the same
    at all
    >> Anomynous 06/04/10(Fri)22:32 No.10281558
    >>10281533
    Why wouldn't you include oceans?



    [Return]
    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]