Are Neutral Milk Hotel good and how do you rate this album

OP is a faggot

>>8743502
Neutral Milk Hotel are a good band, the correct rating of the album is 8.5-9.0/10

Protip: Greatest Hits

recommend some good headphones?

>>8743523
The post where OP lost all credibility.

>>8743523
Another professional music listener here. No way, man, that album is 7.5/10 at best!

What do you think if the artist Popof? What would you rate him /10?

>>8743541
HD595 are best value for money, I want dem HD800's tho
>>8743549
I see you know the scaruffi, scaruffi actually rates very subjective and I can assure you the real rating is at least a point higher than his

>>8743523
>correct rating of the album
oh god you are so stupid.

Rating?

>>8743557
Do understand I have around 800 7.5+ rock albums while he has only 400 or so

what periodical do you work for?

What do you think of the Lateral Jack-Offs?

>>8743551
I don't know that artist
>>8743569
8.5-9.0/10

>>8743551
>>8743551
>>8743551
Rating please?

You get paid to listen to music?

>>8743608
Unemployed

>professional music listener

How does one become a professional music listener?

>>8743618
the you're not professional

>>8743573
You almost had me rage. Bravo.
8/10

How do you rate an artist? Is it on their musical ability/abilities? Their live performance? Their ability to please crowds? How their album is compiled? How famous they are/become? Or how much you like it?

your opinion is invalid for you are a faggot

Defenders of Hate?

>>8743634
Accept your music taste is shit as it is now, work hard
>>8743650
for albums mainly the composition, also emotion, innovation, technical ability, lyrics (not so much, unless they really are amazing) Not much changed for artists...

>>8743594

You didn't rate one of the best bands ever bro.

>>8743688
3/10 bro

How do you feel about Ellegarden.

And J-punk/rock in general?

rate pitchfork out of 10.

What do you think of this recording?

>>8743734

So you don't like punk? :__(

And, if you want to troll, at least say how many CDs and vinyls do you have.

>>8743741
Don't know much j-rock aside from the experimental/drone/noise stuff. If you want some great jpop (female vocalist) you should really check out:
Shiina Ringo - Karuki Zamen Kuri no Hana
It's actually a bit experimental jazzy pop-rock

>>8743753
9.95/10
Greatest composition/musical work ever and my favorite recording of it.

>>8743798
>implying anal cunt is punk...

I have most files digital as I don't have alot of money, but i got around 100 vinyls of my favorite albums, and 400 cds.

>>8743822

Seems legit.

who do you work for? Rolling Stone Pitchfork? who pays you to listen to music, as you claim to be a "professional music listener"?

>>8743853

"professional music listener" with 400CDs.

derp derp derp.

And your "legal" virtual stuff?

>>8743822
>Greatest composition/musical work ever
What an entry-level choice, it's not even Beethoven's best work. You disappoint me.

>>8743496
What do you think of Unwound?

How do you find this piece of music?

I'd like to hear what you think about this.

>>8743899

which is your favourite scriabin piano sonata and why?

>>8743892
i download flac/vinyl copies from what.cd....
>>8743899
im not here to argue about the greatness of the ninth lol. I suggest you listen to the teaching companie's lectures on the 9th by professor Greenberg, he knows what he's talking about.

>>8743496
What do you think about Porcupine Tree, Opeth, Astra, Guapo, LTE, Blackfield and Leafhound respectively?

What do you mean by 'professional'?
What kind of work do you do?

what's the best colour?

>>8743748
http://www.theonion.com/articles/pitchfork-gives-music-68,2278/

You'll probably enjoy this, made me laugh when I read it.

Why do you think that Lady GaGa is the most important artist of our generation?

>>8743937
>im not here to argue about the greatness of the ninth lol. I suggest you listen to the teaching companie's lectures on the 9th by professor Greenberg, he knows what he's talking about.
Argument from authority, you're such a fucking joke. If you think it's Beethoven's best work and the greatest work in all of musical history you should be able to argue your point without copping out by referring me to someone else.

OP might be a faggot and a troll but so far I pretty much agree with him. Does that make me a troll?

Do you like Summer Glau?

>>8743496
Tell me about Paco de Lucia and Explosions in the sky, plox

>>8743916
/r/ link

>>8743978

>"If music has any chance of keeping our interest, it's going to have to move beyond the same palatable but predictable notes, meters, melodies, tonalities, atonalities, timbres, and harmonies."

Umm... I actually agree with that

I want OP's opinion on Soft Machine
pic related: their best release imo

What about "Twilight Time" by Stratovarius?

>>8744029
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=XLB7Y0E3

>>8743905
Good band, Leaves turn inside you get's all the attention but they are very consistant and you should definitely check their first 2 albums if you haven't.
>>8743911
Not listened to, seems to be pretty shit.
>>8743916
I have listened to that one only 1 time but of course it's great. It's probably a 9.0/10

>>8744085
See
>>8743954
Please
Thanks

>Mingus
>professional music listener
10/10 would rage again. for newfags: this guy knows jack shit about all genres

>>8744066
>>8744066
I love you.

>>8743931
heaven't hear d athing by him
>>8743954
>Porcupine Tree
Average but pretentious
> Opeth
Good band, very solid, most of their works arearound 7.0-7.5/10 Post blackwater park get's kinda boring tho.
>Guapo
7/10 for black suns
>LTE
6-/10 for the second cd, dream theater got shit after the first few cd's
>Blackfield
6-/10
>Leafhound
I have never heard this, they seem to be quite popular tho..

>>8744051
first and second are very good, third is a masterpiece 9.0/10 at least.


Im gonna go to the store now

>>8744162 Here
>>8744066
>359.62 MB
Is this in FLAC already?

>>8744188
v0

>>8743573
what would you rate this?

>>8744176
Alright. I'll check them out

Are these ok?

>>8744192
>>8744192
Thanks a lot, buddy.

What do you think of gorillaz

Serious opinion on Dark Tranquillity. I've personally fallen in love them recently.

>>8744224
>>8744224
>>8744224
I love them.
Their latest album sucks though.
Let's wait for OP's comment.

>>8743997
Supreme composition and purest & greatest emotion I've ever listened to (this goes for the 4rth movement mostly...) Greenberg is one of the best lecturers on classical music for sure, he does have the authority. He has a 6 part lecture on the 9th, each around 45 minutes, explaining the complete composition and it's brilliance.
>>8744193
3/10, Other people might rate it higher but to me it's just annoying music for 13 year old teenage girls. But it's not good work of art in any way for sure

>>8744202
If that's the EP 630 sure, they didn't fit in my ears very well but that has to do with my ears i guess.

>>8744224
I have hear the gallery but stopped there, 6/10. Seemed very boring and uninspired to me, I don't listen to this kind of metal often but I don't dislike metal in general.

St.Anger?

>>8744477
3/10

This kind of metal requires you to be into the genre i guess... but do you like this?

Kings Of Leon?

>>8744501
>>8744501
>>8744501
1/10
they're a bunch of faggots with instruments

how do you like interpol, OP?

What do you think of Greens Days first album?

azriel

>>8744485
I have listen to all of converge albums and in my opinion Jane doe is a masterpiece of metalcore/mathcore, I tend to rate it higher than other people at 8.5/10, also got better at each relisten. Their other albums aren't so amazing but consistand at around 6/10-6.5/10 with the 2009 album being around 6.5/10, It's just getting kinda old.

>>8744509
>>8744509
>>8744509
THIS IS NOT ME WATCH THE TRIP!!!!
Kings of leon are suck-mediocre 4/10 band, it's just music for children and i can't take this serious.

>>8744514
Why not dookie, that album is actually pretty decent (a few years ago at least) Haven't listened to this, green day are a shit band now anyway.

>>8743618

professional:
"following an occupation as a means of livelihood or for gain: a professional builder."

>>8744512
Turn on the bright lights had a great atmosphere and good melodies, gave it 7.5/10, was really hot stuff back then :P

>implying kings of leon aren't god tier southern rock.
i don't even care what you guys think, they're awesome. i just hope that you don't consider the strokes any higher than 2/10 if you rate KOL 4/10

rate this ?

What about the album that everyone thinks is the greatest?

What's your opinion on Kayo Dot OP?

And all their albums.

>>8744613
Interesting album, most people will say enter the wu tang is alot better but the atmosphere and lyrics on this album are just incredible so 8.5+/10 for this one and 9/10 for enter the wu tang. Also 8.5/10 for illmatic if anyone wonders, the technical skills of nas are unequaled (Flow, voice, writing, vocabulary, delivery)
and it has 4 of my top 10 hip hop songs, but as an ALBUM it's not as great as the others. It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back get's 8.5+/10 (second greatest hip hop album imo) and The Low End Theory 8+-8.5/10. But I am sure many people can judge these albums better than me.

>>8744607

I agree, first 2 albums were just bad ass. 3th one deffo had some good tracks and well, lets just forget the 4th one. Although they have some good tracks to fuck to

Rate and rank the 4 Hold Steady albums

>>8744707
8.5/10
It are just 'songs' and nothing more, but great songs. second side of the album is actually not so great at all (even filler..).
>>8744722
8+/10 for Choirs of the eye, the album is amazing... Every song is a good composition, can listen to this album forever. Second album 7/10, third album 6.5/10 (Toby wanted this album to not rely on the typical post rock inventory like crescendo faggotry , I appreciate this (most people tend to dislike this album...))
Can't wait for coyote, recently pre-ordered it from the KD side where you get the live cd as extra.

>>8744832
Haven't listened to this band cos pitchfork faps on it while pretty much anyone whose taste i respect thinks it's shit.

Obligatory

>>8744849

Same with the preorder bro. First two albums are 9.5/10 and 10/10, with BLD lagging slightly at 8/10 for me. Really can't wait for Coyote!

>>8744901
I don't judge this music at all before i 'velistened to it, just saying I'm not going to.

>>8744911
Kayo Dot are a great band.Toby Driver seems to be a very cool person and I have much respect for him. Coyote is supposed to be a goth like album, really hopes he pulls it off.

your thoughts on Muse, OP?

what do u think of incubus overall?

>>8744909
Judging from poker face and just dance it's kiddie music, 4/10

opinions on conor oberst?

Isis - Panopticon?

>>8744957
rock the shit out of me till SIENCE, then just couple of songs here and there..
all in all great band, solid as shit..
i love them.

>>8744901
How can P4K liking a band contribute to you not listening to them, that's pretty shallow and naive.

THS are a band who are universally liked by the critics and musical press, liking the Hold Steady isn't just a Pitchfork exclusive thing.

If you have any interest in listening to a band with universal praise then check out this.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZngQ4pXq_cg

I still find it amazing that some people will take P4K liking a band as a sign that you should stay away from the band.

>>8744955
4/10
Muse are one of the least original bands I've ever heard, for someone who can just listen to this music without realising that it's ok I guess.

the moon & antarctica or the lonesome crowded west?
pic unrelated

>>8743710
emotion is subjective

What is Arab Strap's best album? I have the Red Thread and Elephant Shoe, and I'd like to know if I've hit the peak or if there are greater things in store.

What does OP think of Meshuggah?

What are OP's thoughts on Have Heart?

>>8744984
7.5/10
All about the atmosphere and texture, not really mind blowing or original but never let's me down. I think I would like an instrumental version more.

from what I've seen so far, I assume that you're a hipster faggot, OP.

Here OP, rate this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuV-dqKZaic

how much of a faggot are you OP?

>>8745112
can you see us? are we there?

always upon you, gaze never ceases


dude, turner's delivery of the awesome lyrics are so key to this album's greatness

>>8745018
I'll check it out later, there's just so much music I need to make choices you know.
>>8745037
Have only listened to both albums once but they're a very good rock band. Probably both around 7.5.
>>8745105
Zappa made many great/brilliant works and this might be the best.
9/10
>>8745063
Very good band, their best work is actually the around 20 minute ep I (8/10), really great complext composition. But chaosphere is also 7.5/10 and DEI 7/10. On a related note, Dillinger Espace Plan - Calculating infinity (similar album with crazy time signatures) get's 8/10

proffessional music listener?

you mean casual music listener with an ego right?

>>8745234
>Zappa made many great/brilliant works and this might be the best.
>9/10

yourealright.png

What are your other favourite Zappa albums?

>>8745272
The first 3 albums and uncle meat.

test

>>8745316
It worked!

>>8743496
Marilyn Manson, OP.
Any answer that involves calling them mallgoth or shockrock will show that you have no valid opinion of music.

>>8745330
Just one of the many artists whose first album actually is kinda original, but then just turns into a sell out joke with no artistic credibility at all

4/10 for the artist

Give me a 10/10 album OP

>>8745434
I don't give any album a 10, but beethovens ninth is my favorite classical work,
My favorite jazz album:
Charles Mingus - The black saint and the sinner lady
Rock:
The velvet underground and nico

>>8745434
His highest is Beethoven's 9th and it's 9.95. See
>>8743822

Come on OP

>>8745121