Posting mode: Reply
[Return]
Name
E-mail
Subject []
Comment
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • New boards launched! Advice, Literature, News, International, Science & Math, 3DCG.

    Also, here's an e-mail from the Sharecash admin (Edit: Also redacted for now).
    UPDATE: A response from CPALead. tl;dr: The spammers are only "incentivising" their content, and we should be "fine" with it. (Edit: Redacted for now).

    CPALead e-mailed us to say they'd be suspending spammer accounts. Let's hope they keep their word. More to come.

    Also, the site is going to be a bit slow until we work through some hardware issues. Hopefully I'll have it fixed later today/tomorrow.

    File : 1264517075.jpg-(17 KB, 406x376, gilbert-gottfried.jpg)
    17 KB Mental Reading Voice Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:44 No.41902  
    There was a thread on /sci/ about this earlier and I was curious.

    When you read, do you hear a voice in your mind sounding out each word? Whose voice is it?

    Quite a few people in the previous thread responded that they hear no voice at all and simply comprehend the text with a glance. I am jealous of such people.

    I usually hear a lower-pitched version of my own voice as I read.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:45 No.41909
    I don't hear a voice, I read much faster than a person could speak.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:46 No.41923
    >When you read, do you hear a voice in your mind sounding out each word?
    >gilbert-gottfried.jpg

    Fuck you, /lit/. You've ruined books for me. Cannot unhear the gottfried.
    >> Ben Dover 01/26/10(Tue)09:46 No.41927
    Sometimes it's like those people mentioned and other times it's mine own voice or a voice I think would be perfect reading what I am reading.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:46 No.41933
    I don't hear a voice nor do I picture anything in my head unless I force to. Kind of strange I'd imagine.
    >> !!walw6pK4Alo 01/26/10(Tue)09:47 No.41941
    Yeah I know what you're talking about OP, it's kinda like some narrator, probably in my voice. But when I get to characters, they always have different voices of their own.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:47 No.41946
    If I'm actively thinking about reading, I hear my own voice. If I'm just reading, and rather absorbed, I just get the text with no voice.

    An odd thing is that I have near photographic memory when I hear the voice in my head. I can later flip through the book to a particular sentence based on its location on the page, and what was happening around it. If I'm absorbed and just visualizing automatically, I can't do that.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:47 No.41947
    >>41923
    THIIIIIS!!!! FFFFUUUUUU-
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:48 No.41959
         File1264517309.jpg-(38 KB, 500x628, george-costanza.jpg)
    38 KB
    srsly.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:48 No.41963
    i tend to make up voices for the characters and narrator in my head, and read at normal human speech pace, because it helps me comprehend, explore and get involved with the characters and the narrative more. but if its something like and instructional or a textbook then i just look and understand. its much faster
    >> The Mighty Monarch 01/26/10(Tue)09:49 No.41976
    >>41909
    That actually sounds detrimental to the enjoyment of the book. Do you just scan the pages so fast you come off with the gist of what happened? Just doesn't sound FUN to me...

    I try to come up with voices in my head based on movies, radio, music , cartoons, and tv shows I've heard. I have a whole cast of people to fill roles in books.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:49 No.41978
    >>41902
    usually i have a voice reading, but it goes on and off based on the speed i'm reading. recently i've been reading books at a slower rate to try and really take something from them, and that narrator voice has been active because of it.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:49 No.41979
    Only if i'm repeating, revising or emphasising a sentence in my own read do a hear a very faint inclination to believe it's in my own voice.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:49 No.41982
    that depends. Usually I just read without hearing a voice, though there are occassions when I feel the need to read aloud a sentence because it feels like it needs the emphasis.

    If I do hear a voice, its usually my own. However, there have been occassions when, depending on the character, I will hear the voice of an actor or a VA speaking.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:50 No.41987
    I never hear a voice. Usually it's like you said, I just understand the words by seeing them.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:50 No.41992
    Yup, I hear my own voice. But I thought that was normal. Until a while back when I found out that it wasn't. =/
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:50 No.41997
    It depends. With things I'm required to read, like textbooks or school-required reading I don't enjoy, I can do the "comprehend at a glance" thing.

    With novels I'm reading for my own enjoyment, I usually hear my own voice as the narrator, with the voice changing for the dialogue of different characters.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:51 No.42004
    Depends, if I study or read something really fast with not much interest I just gather information.
    If I read I hear Stephen Fry.
    You are now jealous.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:52 No.42013
    Usually I glance at blocks of text and allow the meaning to soak in, basically the gestalt approach...

    UNLESS I've just seen a movie depicting the book, in which case I unfortunately begin seeing the actors and hearing the voices as I read... slowing me down a bit (best example would be LOTR)
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:52 No.42014
    It depends on what it is. Things like street signs I just see. Anything I really need to look at and think about I tend to hear in my own voice.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:53 No.42027
    There's two ways to read much like there are two ways to write. One is for the ear (writing/reading as if it's being spoken,) the other for the eyes (writing/reading on more of a "grokking" method.)

    For me, it changes depending on the work. I've even caught myself trying one or the other to see how it read better.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:53 No.42032
    I read in my own voice. Is that normal?

    Different characters have different voices, obviously.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:54 No.42045
    I hear Morgan Freeman.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:55 No.42060
    I don't hear a voice at all.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:55 No.42061
    >>41997

    Actually, for the books where I hear things in my own voice, it's not usually direct reading from the text. It's kind of like:

    Original text: "Startled by the noise, he jumped up from the chair and nervously glanced around."

    How I hear it: "Startled... jumped from chair... glanced."

    I comprehend the rest of the words, I just don't hear them.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:55 No.42064
    >>42045
    I often imagine him narrating moments in my life.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:55 No.42066
         File1264517755.jpg-(34 KB, 395x450, morganfreeman1234916184.jpg)
    34 KB
    >>42045
    Dude, now I want that.
    >> DeepFriedPikachu 01/26/10(Tue)09:59 No.42101
    Patrick Stewart
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:59 No.42104
    OP here.

    I have never read anything without hearing a voice. I cannot even imagine what it would be like (though it seems like it would be very convenient and fast for studying).

    I just tried scanning a page of a book and 'absorbing' it like a few of you have said, and I don't remember anything I read. I think I need to hear the sounds of the words in order to understand them.

    I always wondered how some of my classmates managed to read enormous books in such a short amount of time. I suppose they could read without a voice.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:59 No.42108
    I mostly listen to AudioBooks, and when the narrator is british, I will spend the rest of the day thinking with a british accent.

    This is extra weird for me, since my first lanuage is Spanish.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)09:59 No.42112
         File1264517988.jpg-(18 KB, 299x276, 1248449553263.jpg)
    18 KB
    I read in the voice of gordon freeman.
    >> !!walw6pK4Alo 01/26/10(Tue)09:59 No.42114
    >>42045

    As much as I love Morgan Freeman, he would be too slow to be my narrator.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:01 No.42128
    I hear a voice, but it doesn't sound like anyone. It's just some kind of pseudo-audiobook that I hear in my head, but no one's reading. Alternatively, if I can imagine a voice, I can read anything with it. Keith David much? His voice is awesome.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:01 No.42138
    >>42045
    you now hear Morgan Freeman reading lesbian porn for you
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:01 No.42144
    >>42104
    Do you read a lot? I read quickly and without a voice but I don't do it that way because I choose to and use some kind of skim/scan technique, because that shit just doesn't work. Read a lot of books, use IRC/messenger programs/wikipedia and you'll get faster.
    >> The Mighty Monarch 01/26/10(Tue)10:02 No.42147
         File1264518127.jpg-(24 KB, 640x480, Futurama_Fry_Looking_Squint.jpg)
    24 KB
    >>42112
    I see what you did there
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:03 No.42170
    >>42032
    That is exactly what happens to me...
    It just feels natural to have characters speak in "normal speed"
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:04 No.42186
         File1264518288.jpg-(156 KB, 300x410, morgan freeman.jpg)
    156 KB
    >>42138
    "Brittany slowly rubbed her finger along Jessica's panties. Like the dampness seeping through the cotton, the smell permeated her olfactory system."
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:05 No.42195
    >>42186
    FFFFUUUUUUU
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:05 No.42200
    >>41927
    This. Doesn't happens always though.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:06 No.42214
    >>42186

    OH GOD MORGAN DON'T STOP
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:07 No.42221
    When I'm reading, I usually hear my own voice in my head as the narrator.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:07 No.42227
    It's my own, but it's usually slightly higher pitched than my actual tone.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:08 No.42231
    >>42144
    I spend most of my day reading. Books, textbooks, articles on the internet, etc. I'm not an exceptionally slow reader, but I can only read as fast as my mental voice can speak (and it has to sound coherent or I don't understand it).
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:08 No.42246
    >>42227
    I have to ask; are you a woman?

    I ask because, as a guy, I think my imagined voice is a lower pitch than my real one.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:08 No.42247
    God damn it OP, I actually do sometimes read in Gottfried's voice, against my own will. It detracts from the reading experience ten-fold.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:09 No.42253
    >>42231
    Eh, then its not all bad. Being a fast reader/typer means you spend at least some of your time raging waiting for other people.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:12 No.42294
    It depends on which book I'm reading. Right now I'm reading The Souls of Black Folk, so Samuel L. Jackson seems fitting.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:13 No.42305
    >>42247
    I use Gilbert Gottfried's voice when I'm reading a textbook I'm not interested in. Then everything becomes hilarious and I remember more of it. I only run into problems when I'm taking an exam and start giggling because I'm hearing Gottfried yell equations and definitions at me.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:15 No.42330
    >>42294
    Hey! My town, Albany, Georgia, is mentioned in that!

    ... Interesting read, too.
    >> Kaos Machina !xSZBqZMT.M 01/26/10(Tue)10:15 No.42340
    Yes. Sometimes I read and hear it in my own voice, other times I just comprehend the text.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:19 No.42401
    I generally do not hear a voice, absorbing it as some have said. A couple of times, though, I've gotten really in the zone and just gone straight from looking at the text to visualizing whats going on in my head. It was strange, like just looking at the words was enough to... decode it into what is actually happening in the story visually. It was strange.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:21 No.42421
    usually there is not voice, however if i have listened to audiobooks i tend to read in the narrators voice and the characters how he narrates them.

    i don't know why this happens, it just does
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:33 No.42580
    Usually my own voice, or the voice I imagine the character speaking would have.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:35 No.42615
    I don't hear any voices. I'm much faster than that.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:36 No.42623
    I try to imagine how the characters would speak the dialogue. For the narrator I hear my own voice.
    I also extensively picture every scene in my mind, not just "comprehend" it.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:36 No.42630
    y'all on some strong drugz yo
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:38 No.42659
    >>42630
    And you're just a word muncher. Books are much more fun if you use your imagination.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:39 No.42668
         File1264520374.jpg-(35 KB, 400x583, getcarter.jpg)
    35 KB
    this man, most of the time.
    >> DeadFool !!djQDVFvIHTA 01/26/10(Tue)10:42 No.42707
         File1264520542.jpg-(34 KB, 290x325, 2343477.jpg)
    34 KB
    I dont hear voices either, same with comic books, makes me kinda jealous of other people who do.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:43 No.42731
    i ''leave'' the book/text i'm reading and see it all infront of me, or like i'm the main character. I imagine the voices and the scenery. I'm in a totally in the book i'm reading.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:49 No.42846
    >>42731
    This is the best way to read books.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:51 No.42875
    >>42846
    it's annoying if people talk to you or touch you, it's harder to get into the same state of mind etc
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:51 No.42880
    The voices never even occur to me. If I'm missing out on it, I'm not aware of it.

    My biggest problem is that I can't see faces when I read. I have to fight to imagine a face, and even then, I can't make it stay. Everyone I read about is a faceless blur.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:52 No.42892
    Seriously WTF'd at this thread.
    I didn't know that so many people can't read properly.
    No wonder many people find reading tiring.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:53 No.42896
    I find I understand the content a lot better if I don't use the narrative voice for some reason - like I'm using my concentration on sounding out the voice in my head instead of comprehending the text.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:53 No.42902
    >>42186
    Don't know if that's hot or what. He's just above that. Above vagina smells.

    But then again, he did the Bucket List. So. I don't know.
    >> The Mighty Monarch 01/26/10(Tue)10:54 No.42930
    >>42892
    >read properly

    Oh lawdy. Tell us, massa, we too dumd ta undastand da wordds on da paypah.

    How do I red book?
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)10:58 No.43002
    Mind is blown... just read this whole thread, heard the voices in my head.... but have no idea whose voice that is. wtf.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:03 No.43076
    hearing a mental voice while reading is identical to actually speaking the text out loud as far as the brain is concerned.

    it's slow.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:05 No.43112
    >>42930
    Why so butthurt?
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:09 No.43190
         File1264522162.jpg-(26 KB, 450x326, dro.jpg)
    26 KB
    I've been reading a lot of poetry lately where the sound of the words is important.

    Picture related.
    >> Armond !W/cqxtVaAo 01/26/10(Tue)11:12 No.43239
    When i read after 20 pages or so i stop noticing that i am flipping pages and see a movie playing out in my head
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:16 No.43293
    I hear a voice, but it doesn't sound like mine. I don't know who the fuck it is.

    Sometimes just for kicks though I try to make it sound like Morgan Freeman.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:17 No.43312
    Always just a generic male voice, which is a bit odd since I'm female. Unless the book is told first person with a female protagonist, I can't imagine a female narrator, which makes trying to listen to audiobooks hard at times.
    >> Armond !W/cqxtVaAo 01/26/10(Tue)11:17 No.43317
    >>43239this is what i was trying to say in this >>42731 but, Anon put it better
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:18 No.43321
    My friends always make fun of me for reading slow, but now that I've read through all the posts saying they read at a speaking pace I'm starting to think that's why I read "slow". I can't really comprehend things if I don't read it at a normal pace, otherwise it's all just a bunch of words on a page that I remember at one time reading but I have no idea what it means.

    As for what voice I hear, it's my own, usually just a little lower. Sometimes I'll give a voice to a character depending on the character's behavior and who I relate it to in real life. However, whenever I read stupid comments on websites I always read them in a ditzy girl's voice, because it just seems to fit perfectly.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:18 No.43327
    it is like my voice but its not my voice it is my mind voice
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:19 No.43344
    >>41909
    This. I only hear a voice when i slow down. Otherwise its a sort of absorption of the words directly. Hard to describe.

    The voice i hear is simply my reading voice, but quieter.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:21 No.43378
    I don't really hear a voice, only when I'm concentrating on the "voice" I hear one, so that means it's only there when I think about it. The words are pronounced in my head, but soundless. Sort of a whispering, I think, with an edge of male/female, whoever is talking.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:23 No.43402
         File1264523007.gif-(66 KB, 310x432, orson-welles.gif)
    66 KB
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:24 No.43413
    don't hear a voice at all, just read the words...
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:25 No.43424
    It's kinda hard to explain, but no, I don't hear voices.
    However, I sometimes hear accents. If a Frenchman is talking in the book, I read in a French accent, though without any voice. Never really thought about it, though.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:32 No.43577
    I can't comprehend what I read if I don't subvocalize.

    I really wish I could read faster.
    >> Anonymous of College Park,MD 01/26/10(Tue)11:38 No.43662
    I do hear a voice when I'm reading, in most cases it's a character from a tv show, anime, or movie, if the book is related to the any of them in a way

    >>41959
    >>42066
    >>42147
    >>42186

    WHY AM I READING THESE REPLIES IN THEIR RESPECTIVE VOICES!
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:46 No.43783
    >>43662
    Mindfuck is something amazing, isn't it
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:47 No.43812
    This is nothing new to me, it plays out in my head like a movie, all the characters have their own voices in my head, the narrator has no voice unless it's written from a first person POV.
    >> Anonymous 01/26/10(Tue)11:48 No.43824
    there's no other voice except for the fact it is not my native language i'm reading.. in this case there is my own voice reading..



    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]
    Watched Threads
    PosterThread Title
    [V][X]AnonymousMental Reading ...
    [V][X]AnonymousA tutor's cry f...
    [V][X]Anonymous