Posting mode: Reply
[Return] [Bottom]
Name
E-mail
Subject []
Comment
Verification
reCAPTCHA challenge image
Get a new challenge Get an audio challengeGet a visual challenge Help
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Japanese このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • File: 1335572347.jpg-(66 KB, 500x375, voss.jpg)
    66 KB Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:19 No.2597787  
    /lit/, what is your opinion on fan fiction?
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:20 No.2597794
    I don't care if you write it, but why would you read it?
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:21 No.2597801
         File: 1335572507.png-(16 KB, 367x115, fanfic.png)
    16 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:25 No.2597814
    The Ayn Rand rule is a joke right?
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:26 No.2597815
    >>2597814
    reported
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:27 No.2597819
    >>2597801
    Apologies. I'm not posting fan fiction, I'm wondering about your opinions on it.

    Is it destructive to the medium that it's taking off of? Does it have merits in its own right? Is it harmful to authors? Are the good ones good enough to be considdered literature in their own right?
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:39 No.2597845
    It's escapist fantasy and almost exclusively deals with genres and works that have no real literary/artistic importance

    I dunno brah, /tg/ churns out some good stuff once in a while. I'm not even sure whether I enjoyed Love Can Bloom ironically or unironically.
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:39 No.2597846
    >>2597819
    >Is it destructive to the medium that it's taking off of?
    Not really
    >Does it have merits in its own right?
    Not really
    >Is it harmful to authors?
    Not really
    >Are the good ones good enough to be considdered literature in their own right?
    Not really
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:52 No.2597882
    I have so much respect for fanfiction, honestly. It's getting so many young people into reading and writing, and that's probably one of the best things anything can do.
    I don't think it's destructive or degrading or anything to the original work, since the only way it would directly affect the original and people's opinions about it would be to gain more fans, which is never a bad thing.
    Merits, definitely. Say, a show's been off air for years or a book has no sequels, and you've gotten terribly attached to the characters - what can you do? Fanfiction. When it's written well, it has just the effect of the original. And that's wonderful.
    I suppose I can see why it might (probably does) offend authors, but I don't think it's very harmful to them. Like I said, what can it do besides gain more fans?
    I mean, nothing bad can really happen, mostly because fanfiction is usually an underground type thing. Or, at least it's been in my experience with it.
    I do believe the good ones can be considered literature in their own right. Creating characters is of course important in original works, but if you already have quality characters who have quality character development throughout a quality story, that's literature, don't you think?
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:54 No.2597887
    >>2597846
    >Are the good ones good enough to be considdered literature in their own right?
    The Last Ringbearer could be considered fan-fiction
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:56 No.2597893
    >>2597882

    Have you ever read the one where the other members of the Monty Python team gang-rape Eric Idle? That's a laugh and a half.
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:57 No.2597898
    Also, I'd like to add, most of Shakespeare's work was technically fanfiction. Say what you want about him being a fraud, but that crap was quality.
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)20:57 No.2597899
    >>2597898

    Hahaha, this is such pseudy bollocks.
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)21:00 No.2597906
    Fanfiction is great when it's written properly, and when it's not, that doesn't matter. Not many people will read a fanfic with terrible reputation anyway. But there are tons of factors, and to just generalize all of it into bad or good is a terrible idea.
    >> BONERJAMS '03 !!lFshYTaAW6s 04/27/12(Fri)21:02 No.2597912
    >>2597787
    >what is your opinion on fan fiction

    well, it seemed to work pretty well for Plato...
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)21:03 No.2597914
    I don't read fanfic.
    >> Anonymous 04/27/12(Fri)21:06 No.2597923
    >>2597914
    Thenwhatareyoudoinginthisthreadnigger?



    [Return] [Top]
    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]