Posting mode: Reply
[Return]
Name
E-mail
Subject []
Comment
Verification
Get a new challenge Get an audio challengeGet a visual challenge Help
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • STOP SOPA BEFORE IT DESTROYS THE WEB


    File : 1324131736.jpg-(84 KB, 335x500, understandingcomics.jpg)
    84 KB Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)09:22 No.2260748  
    Can /lit suggest some good "literary" comics that aren't self indulgent autobiography or bourgeois ennui?
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)09:28 No.2260755
    Grant Morrison's early stuff. Animal Man and Doom Patrol.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)09:30 No.2260759
    prepare for the sandman
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)09:41 No.2260764
         File1324132915.gif-(357 KB, 585x767, moebius-08.gif)
    357 KB
    Asterios Polyp
    Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth
    Watchmen
    V for Vendetta
    Blacksad
    Sandman
    City of Glass (adaptation of Paul Auster book by Mazzuchelli)
    Vagabond (loose adaptation of Musashi)

    The fantasy stuff by Moebius
    Horror mangas by Junji Ito if you are into Lovecraft
    In cape comics I recommend: Batman Year One, Batman Year 100 (by Paul Pope), Superman Red Son, Lex Luthor: Man of Steel, LOKI (by Ribic, very Shakesperean), Killing Joke, Marvels, Kingdom Come.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)09:57 No.2260776
    Watchmen
    From Hell
    V for Vendetta
    Sandman
    Maus
    Fun Home
    The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is cool if you're into Victorian lit.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)09:58 No.2260777
    >>2260764

    >Asterios Polyp
    >Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth

    These are complete bourgeois ennui bullshit.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)09:59 No.2260779
         File1324133993.jpg-(27 KB, 250x350, 250px-Blackholecover.jpg)
    27 KB
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)10:16 No.2260789
    OP here, thanks for all the recommendations. Time to blow my paycheck.

    (btw, has anyone read X'ed Out yet?)
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)10:20 No.2260792
    >>2260777
    I don't know what that means. It's that a way to say "pretentious"?
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)10:23 No.2260796
    >>2260792

    I'm pretty sure "bourgeois ennui bullshit" is a way to say "I am pretentious, and can't think of any actual criticism".
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)10:39 No.2260810
    By bourgeois ennui I mean stories about middle/upper class people dissatisfied with their meaningless lives. Ghost World, American Beauty etc.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)11:17 No.2260831
    >>2260810

    your posting
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)11:29 No.2260845
    >>2260777

    Jimmy Corrigan is actually entertaining, though. In that weird indie Wes Anderson kind of way. Plus the layout is delightful.

    Asterios Polyp is remarkably forgettable, though.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)11:35 No.2260853
         File1324139701.jpg-(68 KB, 350x498, ployp3.jpg)
    68 KB
    >>2260845
    >Asterios Polyp is remarkably forgettable, though.

    What? Really? I thought it was brilliant, I never knew someone could control sequential art like this. I think it is similar to Chris Ware because of this intelligent use of the media. The story is relatable, good characters all over, it has that intellectual feel though it's anti-intellectual at the same time, all the black and white thing, the style of the different characters.

    Ah whatever, this is just my opinion and that is yours.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)11:41 No.2260866
    >>2260853

    I dunno, I did like the crispness of the art style, but the story just felt so old, you know? Middle-aged man is unsatisfied with his life, etc. etc. just really didn't do it for me.

    Except the ending though. The ending was particularly good, but it's the only part I found memorable. I've just seen the character of Asterios Polyp in so many graphic novels before it felt kind of underwhelming.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)11:49 No.2260876
    Hellblazer
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:06 No.2260915
    >>2260866
    >Middle-aged man is unsatisfied with his life, etc. etc. just really didn't do it for me.
    maybe you just can't relate? I know I used to hate it when stand up comedians made jokes about having kids but then once I did they were suddenly great

    we all relate to media through the lens of our own experiences
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:09 No.2260921
         File1324141790.jpg-(111 KB, 953x1355, maus-cover2.jpg)
    111 KB
    MAUS. Best comic ever.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:11 No.2260927
         File1324141889.gif-(40 KB, 576x502, a3dff7dd568fe0[1].gif)
    40 KB
    >>2260748
    anything and all by Chris Ware and you're good
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:11 No.2260928
    maus
    persepolis
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:18 No.2260939
         File1324142323.jpg-(2.94 MB, 5000x3907, US1.jpg)
    2.94 MB
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:19 No.2260941
    Young Lions, Blaise Larmee
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:20 No.2260942
         File1324142426.jpg-(2.96 MB, 5000x4963, Yiu 1.jpg)
    2.96 MB
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:25 No.2260955
         File1324142722.jpg-(13 KB, 300x300, What I Did.jpg)
    13 KB
    Jason. Humorous deadpan artwork combined with poignant, often sad and lonely stories. I can't get enough of his stuff. I'd recommend his collection "What I Did".
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:26 No.2260959
         File1324142777.jpg-(2.97 MB, 4815x5000, U10.jpg)
    2.97 MB
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:28 No.2260961
         File1324142898.jpg-(2.94 MB, 4815x5000, Wake02.jpg)
    2.94 MB
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:29 No.2260967
         File1324142990.jpg-(2.95 MB, 5000x4511, Crusade2.jpg)
    2.95 MB
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:33 No.2260973
    >>2260961
    that's enough mangas, dude
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:33 No.2260974
         File1324143187.jpg-(2.95 MB, 4646x5000, Seven1.jpg)
    2.95 MB
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:35 No.2260980
         File1324143326.jpg-(2.92 MB, 4620x5000, The Forests of Opal 3.jpg)
    2.92 MB
    >>2260973
    European, as is most of this.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:37 No.2260984
    >>2260779
    This. So goddamn much.
    >> Postrider !!IFhYmPq4mXS 12/17/11(Sat)12:39 No.2260985
         File1324143549.jpg-(9 KB, 174x190, 1323570435339.jpg)
    9 KB
    >Ctrl + F Maus
    >4 results

    You've done good, /lit/
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:40 No.2260986
    There's an entire forum dedicated to comic books.

    >>>/co/
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:41 No.2260987
         File1324143673.jpg-(2.9 MB, 5000x4250, Soil 01.jpg)
    2.9 MB
    What about Whatshisface, he draws great comics...and half an hours' digging the internet might just prove me right.

    Or, proper taster pics.

    And now for some real manga.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:42 No.2260990
    >>2260986

    there's an entire forum dedicated to your posting

    >>>/y/
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:42 No.2260991
    Preacher and The Boys by Garth Ennis are pretty cool. Hilarious and over the top violent.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:46 No.2260996
    >>2260986
    >>2260990
    >>>/y/1856144
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:50 No.2261004
         File1324144251.jpg-(2.95 MB, 4602x5000, A Rose for Ecclesiastes.jpg)
    2.95 MB
    >>2260986
    Ah! Excellent! Someone who knows where to post things.
    So tell us...where does this one go?
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)12:58 No.2261014
         File1324144708.jpg-(2.2 MB, 2770x3690, America_a_Prophecy_copy_a_plat(...).jpg)
    2.2 MB
    >>2261004
    And even more importantly, this one.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:07 No.2261024
    >>2260939
    oh hey this is pretty g-
    >JFK conspiracy
    oh never mind
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:10 No.2261027
         File1324145457.jpg-(2.99 MB, 5000x3965, US2.jpg)
    2.99 MB
    >>2261024
    Here's the rest of it.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:12 No.2261029
    >>2261004
    >>2261014
    uh, here.

    seriously though, the judgement implicit in this thread being posted here is so obnoxious, ironic since OP seemed so explicit in eschewing pretension.

    /co/ would have given every example posted and probably more
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:13 No.2261030
    >>2261027
    no thanks, I stopped reading after I found out the author is an idiot
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:22 No.2261043
    IS PERSEOPPOLOLIS ANY GOOD?
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:22 No.2261045
    >>2261043
    yeah, sure
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:25 No.2261047
         File1324146306.jpg-(2.99 MB, 4931x5000, More Than Human.jpg)
    2.99 MB
    >>2261030
    What the author wrote is laden with quotes of others of fame and power. The work has nothing to do with conspiracy theories.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:26 No.2261050
    >>2261047
    um, that's pretty clearly an illustrated novel, NOT a comic book, Anon
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:30 No.2261057
         File1324146604.jpg-(2.97 MB, 5000x5000, AF-tGN.jpg)
    2.97 MB
    >>2261050
    aaand this...?
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:30 No.2261058
    >>2261050
    yeah, I agree. I'm a /co/mrade so this isn't like a value judgement or anything but those really aren't comics, and yeah I know the book in OPs image would contradict that but scott mccloud is a bit of a windbag anyway
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:32 No.2261060
    >>2261057
    a comic.

    it's not even ambiguous.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:34 No.2261062
    homosuck
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:35 No.2261064
         File1324146908.jpg-(2.9 MB, 5000x4932, Appleseed v3i16.jpg)
    2.9 MB
    So...something with lots of words, but still in a comic format.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:37 No.2261066
         File1324147057.jpg-(2.92 MB, 5000x4308, tCAiW2.jpg)
    2.92 MB
    >>2261060
    But, word for word with some words missing, it's the original novel...so /lit/?
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:38 No.2261067
    >>2261064
    this is a comic.

    the two things you posted were literally stories that had had illustrations added above them. you could take the illustrations away and the story would still be understandable.

    there is ambiguity in what is and isn't comics but you havent shown that at all here.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:38 No.2261069
    >>2261066
    Nope. Comic.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:41 No.2261077
    Lone Wolf and Cub
    Sanctuary
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:43 No.2261080
         File1324147399.jpg-(2.97 MB, 5000x4175, Cerebus #93-94.jpg)
    2.97 MB
    >>2261069
    >>2261067
    So if a story is incorporated into standard comic book layout - it's a comic. So how non-standard can the layout get before it's an illustrated story?
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:49 No.2261095
    >>2261080
    It's like you're trying to mete out all these tiny distinctions to show... what? that there's ambiguity in what constitutes a comic? But it's not like there's just two realms, comic and written literature, we have have all kinds of nice categories to describe what you're talking about. At least 2 people identified what you'd posted as illustrated stories. 3 if you count me.

    Cerebus is a comic, btw. you've posted a lot of comics while implying that they're somehow different. Maybe it's you that has a problem with rigid definitions.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:49 No.2261096
         File1324147791.jpg-(49 KB, 474x573, mccloudA.jpg)
    49 KB
    Fucking casuals, there are many ways to make a comic book.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:50 No.2261097
         File1324147826.jpg-(33 KB, 474x444, mccloudB.jpg)
    33 KB
    >>2261096
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:51 No.2261101
         File1324147903.jpg-(2.94 MB, 5000x5000, LS01.jpg)
    2.94 MB
    >>2261077
    I the vein of LW&C.
    >> Anonymous 12/17/11(Sat)13:58 No.2261106
         File1324148286.jpg-(2.93 MB, 5000x5000, Coo's W 1.jpg)
    2.93 MB
    >>2261095
    I don't have a problem with rigid definitions having posted these in both /co/ & /lit/ b4. But someanon requested a move of comic materials to /co/, leaving behind...? I posted two illustrated stories so that something would, rather than in answer to Op's opening bid.



    [Return]
    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]