Posting mode: Reply
[Return]
Name
E-mail
Subject []
Comment
Verification
Get a new challenge Get an audio challengeGet a visual challenge Help
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • File : 1284333280.jpg-(70 KB, 439x300, literature.jpg)
    70 KB Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)19:14 No.1122114  
    What makes a book literature?

    Why makes Tolstoy's works literature but not Stephenie Meyers'?

    inb4 >implying such and such write literature.

    You get my fucking point.

    tl;dr define literature
    >> Truman Capote !kwxizAOFlk 09/12/10(Sun)19:16 No.1122119
         File1284333407.jpg-(347 KB, 1680x1050, godisdead.jpg)
    347 KB
    It's all subjective, really.

    As long as you can see art within a piece of writing, then it's literature.
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)19:17 No.1122121
    writings that reflect on a symbolic and emotional level.
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)19:17 No.1122124
    Literature is the written word in the most general sense possible, and has nothing to do with quality.
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)19:20 No.1122131
    It is literature if it reflects the values and ideals of a given society in a way that calls attention to those values.

    Or so Terry Eagleton says.
    >> Deep&Edgy !pSkjEcB9sQ 09/12/10(Sun)19:23 No.1122137
    The best you're going to get is family resemblance. I used to make these threads before I lost all hope in /lit/.
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)19:29 No.1122163
    >>1122137
    Buck up, old chum! There's always hope for--

    eh fuck you're right.
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)20:41 No.1122393
    >>1122124

    No, this guy's right. Hell, this post is literature.
    >> Deep&Edgy !pSkjEcB9sQ 09/12/10(Sun)20:42 No.1122397
    >>1122393
    Cool bro I've always felt that stop signs are literature

    kill yourself you fucking degenerate
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)20:45 No.1122405
    Stephenie Meyer is literature

    its just not good literature, that's all.

    All novels and short stories are literature. Does poetry count too? I think so (poetry is taught in most of my lit classes).
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)20:47 No.1122413
    literature is writing that really stands the test of time
    >> TyBrax !WvWWh.l.CE 09/12/10(Sun)20:48 No.1122414
         File1284338881.jpg-(26 KB, 370x467, 1276819932173.jpg)
    26 KB
    Deep&Edgy, do you have any friends?
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)20:49 No.1122417
         File1284338961.jpg-(9 KB, 480x360, demoman.jpg)
    9 KB
    >What makes a book literature?
    If it weren't literature, I wouldn't be sittin' hea DISCUSSIN' it with ya, now WOUD EYE?
    >> Deep&Edgy !pSkjEcB9sQ 09/12/10(Sun)20:56 No.1122430
    >>1122414
    How old are you TyBrax?
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)20:57 No.1122431
    >>1122414

    I don't think he does. I find his heavy-hitting arguments, myopic subhuman talk pretty entertaining to read, but behind this facade I see a lonely young boy, yearning for acceptance.
    >> TyBrax !WvWWh.l.CE 09/12/10(Sun)21:02 No.1122441
    >>1122430
    I'm 18. I've said so before I think. You won't tell me.

    I'll also tell you that I have no friends, will you tell me if you do or not?
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)21:03 No.1122444
    Literature is writing with meaning, not simply for entertainment.

    That's not at all to detract from writing for entertainment however.
    >> Deep&Edgy !pSkjEcB9sQ 09/12/10(Sun)21:10 No.1122456
    >>1122441
    >will you tell me if you do or not?
    Probably not, I have one or two people who refer to me as such but as far as I'm concerned they've stretched the concept too thinly for it to be in any way meaningful
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)21:13 No.1122462
    >>1122456

    Yeah, mum and dad are a pretty thinly stretched definition of friends.
    >> TyBrax !WvWWh.l.CE 09/12/10(Sun)21:17 No.1122469
    >>1122456
    Unfortunately this is of no use to me without an age estimate.

    I am going to try & make meaningful friends next month /lit/ <3
    >> Mogwai !!YOt9Y28V773 09/12/10(Sun)21:24 No.1122478
    >>1122469
    He`s 22
    >> Anonymous 09/12/10(Sun)21:31 No.1122492
    I really hate these terms that have a pretense for objectivity when they're actually completely dependent on very personal opinion. It will depend on how good you think it is/how deep, intricate a plot you believe it has. And I'd rather use those terms instead, they're less vague.

    Same goes for "art" in its contemporary form. Or "hipster"; you can call that to anything and god knows what the fuck you actually meant or thought about it. IT'S CONSISTENTLY AND OUTRAGEOUSLY PARADIGMATIC AND SHAPED LIKE ITSELF



    [Return]
    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]
    Watched Threads
    PosterThread Title
    [V][X]Anonymous
    [V][X]Quentin!!p3mpBqBwOeY
    [V][X]Anonymous