Posting mode: Reply
[Return]
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 2048 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • Since I've been on a Q&A kick in /a/ and /r9k/ recently, I've decided to set up a formspring account for publicly answering 4chan related questions. You'll find it linked in the navbar as "?", and located here: formspring.me/4chan. Also, if you use Twitter, please follow @4chan. As always, I can be contacted via e-mail at moot@4chan.org (Despite the common misconception, I check it frequently and read every message I receive. Nobody seems to e-mail me about anything other than being banned though ;_;)
    EDIT: Site went down due to a hardware issue. Should be fixed now.

    File : 1267220338.jpg-(50 KB, 466x282, _47311959_high-res.jpg)
    50 KB Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:38:58 No.201613XXX  
    Hey, my band has been going for a couple of months now, and apart from comments on youtube, we haven't had much feedback from real artists like you.

    The youtube comments were obviously posted by some short sighted individuals who obviously have no taste in good music. They'll probably be kicking themselves when we're the #1 band in the world. lol

    We'd just like some feedback and constructive criticism about one of our songs (which we feel best represents the band and it's sound).

    Please ignore that we're scene kids, because it's all about the quality of the music than what we wear. If you just listen to the talent of the music, you will not be disappointed.

    Feel free to comment on the video too!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CrTSQPNHZQc&feature=related
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:41:50 No.201613XXX
    You know a band is great when every single negative comment is flamed by the members.

    Usually along the lines of
    "HURR STFU FAGGOT U DNT KNOW REAL MUSIC"

    "UR YOUTUB PAGE HAS NO VIDEOZ HOO R U 2 JUDGE OUR MUSIC!"

    "I WUD LAIEK 2 SEE U FAGGOTS MAKE A BETER SONG!!49"
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:44:08 No.201614XXX
    haha crabcore
    shitty tuned guitars
    doing something that looks like jumpstyle
    crying while "singing"
    -9001/10
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:44:23 No.201614XXX
    an hero. now. all of you.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:44:33 No.201614XXX
    I'm actually gonna go ahead and do what you say and ignore the fact that you're a bunch of faggots and discuss the music.

    Sucks.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:45:26 No.201614XXX
    >>201614346
    stfu. You obviously don't know good music when you hear it. And before you ask, I've bought every piece of equipment i know with my own money.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:45:50 No.201614XXX
    bump so a fuckton of /b/-tards can see this
    GET IN HERE IF YOU WANNA LAUGH YOUR ASS OFF
    /cruisecontrol
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:46:16 No.201614XXX
    >>201614469
    Go get a life and listen to some good music.
    It's not my fault all you listen to is 50 Cent and MC Hammer. Don't take it out on talented people like me and my band.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:46:58 No.201615XXX
    >>201614693
    Why the fuck would I ask that?
    also,
    >>201613806
    seems to be right
    HEY YOU GUYS WE WANNA HEAR YOUR OPINION
    WHAT, YOU THINK WE SUCK? FUCK YOU!!!
    ONLY POSITIVE COMMENTS ALLOWED
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:46:58 No.201615XXX
         File1267220818.jpg-(66 KB, 409x383, 1251075714151.jpg)
    66 KB
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TWaoAVSAUTI&feature=channel

    oh wow. i think anything over 5 seconds is nightmare mode.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:48:15 No.201615XXX
    wow i like your pre-song dance routine
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:49:50 No.201615XXX
    lol wow never play again that was awful
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:49:54 No.201615XXX
    oh god
    i'm a metalfag, and now every inch of my body hurts
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:50:11 No.201615XXX
    pretty effing good bro
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:50:25 No.201615XXX
    >>201615414
    thanks dude!

    keep on rockin' ;)
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:50:28 No.201615XXX
    you guys are ruining metal please never try a breakdown again
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:50:29 No.201615XXX
    real feedback, assuming you aren't a troll:
    generic breakdowns
    don't do crabcore shit if you want people to take you seriously
    don't infuse electronica if you want people to take you seriously
    electronica breakdown is the same as any other "crunkcore" band

    can't hear vocals so i can't determine quality

    your band is a generic hardcore band, nothing special.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:50:57 No.201616XXX
    I dont have speakers on my computer right now but even without sound you all look pretty silly. Change your routine and amp positioning
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:50:59 No.201616XXX
    >>201613123
    you should probably go and try to play a real venue. then post pics when they hear your demo.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:51:04 No.201616XXX
    krabcore fuck yeah
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:51:23 No.201616XXX
    >>201615920
    yayy! ;)

    need more contructive comments like that instead of dumb shits dissing out music.

    IF YOU DONT LIKE THE MUSIC THEN WHY ARE YOU LISTENING TO IT!
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:51:46 No.201616XXX
    awwwwww my ears are bleeding!
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:51:56 No.201616XXX
    your music is garbage. shitty shitty shitty shit.
    just gtfo you faggots. stop sullying /b/ and music with your terribad faggotry.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:52:01 No.201616XXX
    obvious troll is obvious
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:52:33 No.201616XXX
    >>201616261
    haha
    positive=constructive
    oh god, you are cracking me up, seriously
    also, for all of you who want to stop the ear-bleeding:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=28GaKoCuobU
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:52:44 No.201616XXX
    Fucking wow. I love metal, but this... this..

    The drummer is HORRIBLE, his cymbals are cheap, his snare sounds like a bucket.

    The guitarists have some NASTY fucking feedback, which means their gear is shit and/or they cant mute strings properly.

    The music itself is simple as fuck.

    You are more concerned about how you look playing your guitars than actually learning to play them and pulling them up off of your knees (protip: that looks fucking retarded, and its obvious youre struggling to reach comfortably)
    Needs moar stage prescence.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:53:16 No.201616XXX
    >>201616572
    iron maiden sucks compared to this band of sheer talent.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:53:17 No.201616XXX
    why ask for opinions if you don't want them. you need to learn how to play your instruments before you can make music. it is that simple. concentrate less on your faggy dancing and what I can only describe as guitar tea-bagging and learn how to play.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:53:44 No.201616XXX
    >>201616614
    this
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:54:04 No.201617XXX
    HEY GUISE! I HAVE A GREAT IDEA! LETS POST GOOD COMMENTS AND RATINGS TO TROLL OTHER TROLLS!!!!!!!

    FOR GREAT JUSTICCCEEE!
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:54:24 No.201617XXX
         File1267221264.jpg-(46 KB, 600x348, bucket.jpg)
    46 KB
    >>201616614
    >like a bucket
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:54:50 No.201617XXX
    >>201613123
    >>201617011
    samefag
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:55:17 No.201617XXX
    >>201617011
    I'm sorry dude, giving this band good ratings isn't even worth it for the sake of elaborate trolling.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:56:55 No.201617XXX
    >>201616572
    worst vocals ever, not even trolling, shit what a faggot he is.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O_fJ5SSV_Vo
    tube related; true metal vocals
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:57:08 No.201617XXX
    >>201616771
    like to see you make anything better.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:58:36 No.201618XXX
    potential... but not my favorite.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:58:39 No.201618XXX
    >>201617833
    typical butthurt faggot reply.
    we could have a downie pass out on a guitar and it would sound better.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)16:59:17 No.201618XXX
    >>201617833

    god damn this pissed me off to no end before i played in a band.

    Now i can safely say that I can and HAVE written many songs much much better than that, not to mention I have played at places besides someones garage.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:00:07 No.201618XXX
    >>201617833
    I love people who dismiss criticism based on the fact that YOU DONT MAKE BETTER MUSIC LOLOL
    do you think every movie critic has to make at least one perfect movie to criticize every other one? fucker
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:01:42 No.201619XXX
    whats funnier is that good music is EASY to write and CHEAP to record.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:01:42 No.201619XXX
    >>201618393

    i doubt you've made better songs than this. i don't think many people ever have apart from attack attack.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:02:10 No.201619XXX
    >>201613123
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5cjoNdLfdr4&feature=related
    Superiority.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:02:53 No.201619XXX
         File1267221773.jpg-(9 KB, 278x282, 1266877585612.jpg)
    9 KB
    >>201619023

    God damn i almost replied with links until I read the second sentence.

    10/10
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:03:27 No.201619XXX
    >>201619145
    If you are a troll, you are pretty good.
    If not, I'll cry laughing now.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:03:34 No.201619XXX
    OP is presumably a troll, and if so, has been very successful
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:04:25 No.201619XXX
    AW YEAH, I KNOW AN AWESOME BAND
    http://www.myspace.com/barbstits HO HO HO FUCK
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:06:17 No.201620XXX
    trolling advice: slightly more subtle next time
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:07:16 No.201620XXX
    >>201620234

    it was debatable until you mentioned attack attack. if you would have just left out that sentence it would still be going hard
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:07:46 No.201620XXX
    >>201619510
    Hey, at least they can uphold their tempo. Hmm. Well, all of the members were born in the year 1990 and it's avant garde... so uh... yeah. Unfortunately, the song's an instumental one. The ones with the vocals are much more... consonant. And the singer's simply good. You can find 'em on Myspace.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:08:15 No.201620XXX
    In my oppinion, it's not that bad.
    I really think the timing could be a bit better, so try to work on that. Also, the vocals need to be able to be heard over the instruments, that's a HUGE thing. The vocals don't need to be rediculously loud, but loud enough to where we can hear them. All in all, not too shabby, keep up the work.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:08:44 No.201620XXX
    10/10 man i falled for it
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:08:55 No.201620XXX
    >>201620627
    And I must admit that I used the word "superiority" for the... agitation.
    >> SHIT Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:09:00 No.201620XXX
    Sweet choreography faggots. Btw the music sucks, so get your crabcore douchebaggery out of my /b/ and stop killing hardcore
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:10:17 No.201621XXX
    >>201620627
    >>201620913
    This just in, nobody gives a damn about your explanations.
    Attack attack fucking suck, it's a well-known fact.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:11:04 No.201621XXX
    >>201621275
    I explain only to please myself.
    >> Muse !t5j0oblcKE 02/26/10(Fri)17:14:06 No.201622XXX
    I bet with proper recording equipment, they wouldn't be that terrible.
    >> Anonymous 02/26/10(Fri)17:15:22 No.201622XXX
    >>201622188

    well its a cam so it sounds like shit.

    BUT.

    if a cam makes it sound like shit... and its already shit..

    /divideby0



    [Return]
    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]