>>
07/21/09(Tue)19:48 No. 1982852 >>1982710 Looking
at it from a judge's perspective, I see what was so great about the
skit. I've seen Baccano! and it's fresh in my mind, so the skit was
even more enjoyable for me. Basically, the skit embodied the
anime. It was pretty much just a condensed summary of the events that
happen on one "segment" of the anime (the Flying Pussyfoot incident).
In Baccano!, there's always something happening. The skit used music
from the anime that played throughout the entire thing, even when
characters were conversing--which is what is also done in the anime.
Everyone was spot on with characterization, the voice acting and
dialogue was in character, and the costumes were passable for accuracy,
which is something that's pretty rare with most skit cosplays. When
it comes to the dancing, Baccano! is about movement. The fight scenes
are choreographed in such a way that they look just like dancing.
Baccano! has swing music because of the era it's set in and doing a
dance to that music is better and more accurate than any other choice.
Some of the "technical" flips and things like that are difficult to
execute, especially in the costumes chosen, and as far as I saw there
were no major errors. Basically, from the perspective of
someone looking to critique a skit, it succeeded from the point of view
of it being a full-blooded skit. It had a beginning, a middle, and an
end, a plot and characters, action, spectacle, entertainment, etc. etc.
In saying that, I personally enjoyed the Baccano! Thriller skit from
another con even more, but that's just my personal opinion. The
Baccano! group was also pretty courteous backstage. They clapped for
every skit and every contestant, even the Narutard skit with Tobi and
whatever. So yeah, in my opinion, it was a wise choice for Best in Show. There wasn't anything else that even came close to their level. And they really fucking *love* Baccano!.