>MFW watching Madoka start to finishI'm never trusting /a/ ever again this show was genius>That [spoler] plot twist
:3
>I'm never trusting /a/ ever againWhy? /a/ loved it.
>spoler
>>67743764NO ANON, THAT'S A LIE. /a/ NEVER LIKED IT.
Most of /a/ thought it was pretty good, if not the best thing to come out in years.Comparison to Eva is purely based on nostalgia goggles. Eva is shit if you look at it closely. Madoka stands up to its own legs.
>>67743755>emoticons
>>67743764OP was being ironic.
>>67743764/a/ also loved TTGL, the average response now would be that it's shit
>>67743764Lay down sempai
You now realize that, as time went on, the OP became less and less fitting and the ED became more and more fitting.>SHAFT in charge of symbolism
Madoka wasnt just about symbolism, its about a story well told.
>>67743855 implying the OP wasn't secretly about pre-Meguca Homura
>>67743855shaftards in charge of over-analyzing it
>>67743884What symbolism ?
It's better the second time, OP. Go watch it again.
I didn't like Madoka. I think it helps show me who the people are with bad taste in anime.
>MFW watching Naruto start to finishI'm never trusting /a/ ever again this show was genius>That [spoler] plot twist
>>67743814>gifs^__^;;
>>67743907Shaft is well known to do that with their OP and EDs
I've been contemplating watching Madoka for a very long time. It looks so fucking bad, looks like complete moeshit, but I've heard its actually very dark. I've also heard extremely mixed views.Same with K-On! Yeah I know it's amazing I haven't watched this yet, I've watched tons of anime but K-On! Looks SO FUCKING TERRIBLE. I want to watch it just because it's popular but I can't bring myself to watch it.
>>67743913Madoka's magic bow is a metaphoric penis.
>>67743913Homura represented the despair after 9/11, Madoka represented the US Army's hesitation to help Sayaka (Iraq) in her time of need. It's really deep.
>>67743764/a/ also loved Katawa Shoujo.That doesn't mean they'll admit they love it.
0/10Try harder.
>>67743744Dude fuck off, seriously. Stop making these threads all the time acting like you'r watching Madoka for the first time.
>>67743930Grow upIf everyone had your autistic mentality then we wouldn't have a wide range of things. Nothing but cubicles everywhere
>MFW watching Sazae-san start to finishI'm never trusting /a/ ever again this show was genius>That [spoler] plot twist in episode 6260
>>67743978Mami diesSayaka diesKyoko diesMadoka becomes godHomura is a time traveler
test
>>67744026Don't be a dick.
>>67743983>Madoka's magic bow is a metaphoric penis.There's actually a lot of truth in that statement.The myriad of arrows it shoots symbolizes the sperm that started the new universe she created. The universe you and I live in.
>>67744138he deserved it
>>67744026This is the current timeline. Also Madoka doesnt become god, she becomes a bodhisattva.
>>67743978I watched Lucky Star because of its popularity, and it was pretty boring.Watched KON! for the same reason, back when every new episode meant 8 new threads flooding the front page, and it was pretty good. Just give it a chance
Madoka was a good show, probably even high tier if I were to rate it. But it's not great, it's just not memorable enough. Honestly I wouldn't have ever thought about ti again if not for /a/'s collective obsession over it. It's honestly like /a/'s mlp.
>>67745408it isn't just /a/ friendwhen things are objectively masterpieces the world tends to notice
>madoka>genius
>>67744010We can have a wide range of things while acknowledging a lot of it is not good. Like Madoka.No excuses for bad taste.
The show is fine what really bad is the fanbase here.
>>67745292Don't be a dick
It will take another 15 years for a new masterpiece like Madoka and Eva.How does this make you feel?
>>67745472but fanbases are always shit, why do you still let this bother you
>>67745481Eva wasnt a masterpiece by our standards. Eva was a masterpiece only because it evoked some christian religious symbolism.
>>67745450How can it be an objective masterpiece failing in the areas where it can be criticized objectively, like the animation?
>>67745522the christian symbolism had very little to do with why eva was good. The psychology and deep meaningful character interactions is why it's still remembered and talked about.
The best anime ever, without any doubt, is Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica. Not only is the plot amazing, it delivers important themes about society and has a lot of symbols about religion. Pisses me off that people don't understand how beautiful this anime is and I just want to punch them in the face.
>>67745564Eva does not have any deep meaning. The only thing thats different from any other robot show is a depressed kid and bunch of christian symbolism. Depressed kid was the projection of Anno's own self-esteem and the Christian symbolism was because the production team used it because it was unique to Japanese robot anime. I doubt you got the "deep" meaning from a depressed emo kid. And I highly doubt your "christian symbolism had very little to do with why eva was good." This is the main thing that set it apart from other japanese mecha shows. And this is the main reason WESTERNERS bought this anime. In Japan this series is not a masterpiece but rather something above average.
babby's first grimdark moeshit
>>67745790>implying there are any other grimdark moe shit
>>67745769[citation needed]
Anyone who praises it for the plot or characters is a retard.Anyone how praises it for the directing, atmosphere, art or music is a normal.
>>67745481>Madoka>masterpieceBy whose standards?
>>67745912This current generation's
>>67745564>eva>deep meaningful character interactionNo.Its character development was pretty good, but character interaction was as painful as most anime.
>>67745883Your post can be summed as:>anyone who praises this show, and isn't a glorious hipster like me, is a retard and normal.
>>67745941Your butthurt because you just realized Madoka's plot and characters were shit?
>>67745883>I dont enjoy it therefore anyone enjoying it is shit.
Madoka was moeshit with frosting smeared all over itbut i do love kyubey so i can't say it was all bad
>>67745954>plot and characters were shitDoesn't make any sense at all, i can say that any work of fiction has shit characters and/or plot, and nobody will be unable to prove me wrong since those examples are general as fuck and can be used by anyone to sound altiloquent, pedant and sesqupidelian.Are you underage by any chance? It seems like most of those who hate meguka are underage as shown by their posts.
>>67745769>In Japan this series is not a masterpiece but rather something above average.This sums up how ignorant you are. I'm nowhere near a big fan of Eva, but it is undeniably considered a classic in Japan. It is far and away the most popular anime among anime fans in Japan, and considered the standard for which all new anime are judged. There's a reason why people compared Madoka to Eva. >>67745954How was its plot shit? Its characters weren't great but its plot was high quality.
>MFW watching boku no pico start to finishI'm always trusting /a/ this show was genius>That [spoler] tower scene
>>67746047Go back to bed kid. Eva wasnt big at all when it was airing. The only reason it got popular in japan was because of westerners thinking it is deep. Japan having a western fetish bought this and continued to propagate this. All the new otakus that have watched the Eva without any influence from westerners dont see any value in it.
>>67746044>altiloquent, pedant and sesqupidelian.It's like you shamelessly went to a thesaurus and looked up the most "intelligent" looking words you could find before writing this post.
Ending killed Madoka.I WAS NOT HAPPY.I watched this show only for her.And now all those stupid retarded homu fanart, I piss me for the eternity.
>>67745939>What are teenagersMm, yes. I'm sure you were very "intelligent" and your interactions were exceedingly "normal" to any adults that viewed you when you interacted with other teenagers.
>>67745933So is Bebop or EVA. Even K-ON!
>>67746108Incorrect. Eva was well established as a success before had any relevance out West. It was by far the highest selling anime of that decade (its first run sold about 110,000 units) and hasn't been topped since then even though anime sales on average are much higher. >>67746182You're making a strawman argument. I didn't say anything about normal or intelligent. My point was that it was nothing terribly special in terms of character interaction. Its worth was in its approach to character development.
>>67746222Bebop's masterpiece is evident even in this generation. Eva is just judeo-christian culture fanatism
>>67746126You're just butthurt that you don't understand some of the simplest words out there.
Anime is just a really shitty medium. Decent movie is better than your "masterpieces".
>>67746271I wasn't even the same guy. I've spent quite a bit of time around the English language. Seeing those words, especially in succession like that, was extremely odd.
Just finished it while /a/ was downFucking glorious, an anime that will always be a master pieceDont know why /a/ is manchild about this
>>677463140/10
>>67746303Seriously why are you here then?
>>67746322Im not even trolling ? Seriously just cause you think the only good anime is naruto doesnt mean you can say this was shit
>>67746329I like anime. But it's funny when shit like Evangelion becomes a classic and a masterpiece.
>>67746360It's no worse than shit like Lord of the Flies being considered masterpieces of literature.
>>67746322go back to bed kid
>>67746308> I've spent quite a bit of time around the English languageI'm sure you have, butthurt-san.
I love how autist manchildren will try and defend Madoka and call it 'deep', it's funny to me for some reason.
>>67746454thats like your opinion man
>>67746454I love how normalfags try to criticism madoka with no substance
>>67746454> it's funny to me for some reasonStupid people find hilarity in the simplest of things.
So what do you pleb like about Madoka anyway? I haven't ever really seen anyone praise it for specific aspect, just "omg i luv madoka 11/10 masterpiece"
>>67746557The most mindfuck plot twist you will ever see
>>67746557Too many things. Just watch it and make your own conclusions
>>67746557I don't love Madoka, but I like it. If it excels in anything it excels in atmosphere and music.
>>67746557>calls those who like madoka plebs>fails at english
>>67746595>Strawmannin'
>>67746557This isn't MAL, we are not here to review anime for you.
>>67746615THEN WHY DO YOU REQUIRE A THREAD FOR IT IF YOU ARENT GOING TO DISCUSS IT HOLY SHIT
>>67746623HOLY SHIIIIIITTTTTTT
>>67746623discussion is not reviewing
>>67746491But normalfags are the ones who think it's the deepest shit ever, like EVA. The neckbeards just fap to the girls.
>>67746633But reviewing is part of discussion.
>>67746637>I love how autist manchildren will try and defend Madoka and call it 'deep', it's funny to me for some reason.Pretty sure autist manchildren are not normal. Normal people dont watch anime and discuss it, they simply skim over it and talk to goto cosplay conventions
>>67746623>can't recognize a shitty reverse trolling threadPlease fuck off back to /v/.
>>67746642No its not. Discussion involves all party having seen the anime, specially one thats been over for months
>>67746614If you're unable to communicate in simple english, you shouldn't be posting in an english language imageboard.
>>67746454There's hilarity in watching the true nature of the brainless fanboy rear itself.
Overrated niwaka garbage. If you are praising it then I hope you feel bad because you should.
>>67746692Wait, if they're brainless then why would they want to discuss the "deepness" of madoka? A brainless person would simply be "herp a derp madoka too boring xD me watch one piece now epic luffy"
>>67746704Lemme guess you watch some 2deep4u anime like one piece
>>67746735Wot
>>67746716>Wait, if they're brainless then why would they want to discuss the "deepness" of madoka?THEY FUCKING DONT> A brainless person would simply be "herp a derp madoka too boring xD me watch one piece now epic luffy"ITS CALLED MOB MENTALITY
Congratulations, you have shit taste.lyke omg just kidding ^_^ /a/ is sooo mean >3> you should ttly watch junjou romantica next, it's teh smeeeex [spoler] teeheee
>>67746716>>67746735>insulting another series to make Madoka look halfway decentNo surprises here.
>>67746758By your logic, all complainers are following the mob mentality too arent they? If not, what makes them more special than those that like the show?
>>67746774But its true though ?
>>67746774You mad wanpissfag?
>>67746795NOPEBECAUSE THE 'complainers' ACTUALLY BACK UP WHY THE SHOW IS OVERRATED SHIT (OF COURSE ALL THE FANBOYS IGNORE THIS)THE FANS JUST IGNORANTLY IGNORE ALL CRITICISM
>>67746885Or, maybe, they explain stuff to everyone as rational human beigns, and the ohsoglorious haters are just being ignorant on purpose.Your post is extremely ironic.
>>67746885you sound extremely mad
>>67743832But it is shit faggot gb2gaia
>>67746885Have you actually been to threads? Seriously, each and every thread that tries troll Madoka is successful. for the defenders
>>67746935>>67747115Yeah, really successful when all you have to do is make shit up to cover for the bad writing and toss as many insults as possible at the people you're arguing with. Back an apologist into the corner and he'll show no shame. This happens in many a Madoka thread.I suppose this would count as a victory in the same manner as one army showing pity to incompetent opponents who toss as many men at you as possible to wear you down by opting out of further wasting resources and materials on them, and then the opposing army claims glorious victory and puff themselves up with pride. Most would consider this pathetic but the Madokafags take in putting in so much effort with little to show.
>>67747358>ad hominemsYou were proven wrong, deal with it already, no generalizing will help your cause.
