Posting mode: Reply
[Return] [Bottom]
Name
E-mail
Subject []
Comment
Verification
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • Dear Londoners: I am in your lovely rainy city for the next few days. If you'd fancy a spot of tea and dessert,
    send an e-mail to london@4chan.org with a sentence or two about yourself,
    why you aren't Jack the Ripper, and include a timestamp.
    Cheers, —mootykins

    File: 1332364045.jpg-(91 KB, 250x350, Ivu_no_Jikan_poster..jpg)
    91 KB Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:07 No.63089268  
    I'm trying to watch Eve no Jikan but robots seriously creep me the fuck out. Is it really all that it's cracked up to be or can I just drop it now?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:08 No.63089304
    >but robots seriously creep me the fuck out.
    racist
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:12 No.63089463
    Watch it. It's a short series so get it off your backlog
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:14 No.63089543
    >>63089268
    You will identify with some of the characters, that's for sure.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:15 No.63089572
    >robots seriously creep me the fuck out

    But Sammy is kawaii, nigga.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:26 No.63090052
    You are obviously not a dori-kei. It's time to join the Robot Ethic Committee, /a/non-bro.

    would you eat an electronic sheep?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:28 No.63090099
    Watch episode 4 first
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:30 No.63090196
    >>63089268
    >but robots seriously creep me the fuck out
    How?
    Anyway, you should watch it and think a little about what makes us so different to highly advanced artificial intelligence inside an android.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:36 No.63090419
    >>63090196
    The thought of a cybernetic revolt, these robots shouldn't be having emotions, fuck this anime. They should burn that cafe down
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:39 No.63090538
    >>63090419
    I assume you're done with the Animatrix series?
    >> I ♥ !Sammy.Xp42 03/21/12(Wed)17:40 No.63090603
         File: 1332366041.jpg-(19 KB, 300x300, machine heart.jpg)
    19 KB
    >creepy
    But their appearance is essentially human. Zero uncanny valley there.

    >They should burn that cafe down
    People like you will be responsible for the 2nd renaissance.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:43 No.63090702
    >>63090419
    You're a terrible human being, if you can be even considered as one.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:47 No.63090851
    >>63089268
    Eve no Jikan is overrated. Don't take it's praises too seriously.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:48 No.63090876
    >>63090702
    What, because I hate robots or because I hate the cafe?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:49 No.63090910
    >>63090876
    Because you'd kill something sentient just because you're scared of it, seriously what is this the middle ages?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:51 No.63090987
    >>63090910
    Gotta agree, really Op you're a massive faggot. It's not like they were trying to revolt anyway, the anime is about integration between humans and robots.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:51 No.63090992
    Set in the same universe as YKK, a few centuries earlier.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:52 No.63091034
         File: 1332366772.jpg-(165 KB, 500x649, 1301261343978.jpg)
    165 KB
    >>63090851

    die
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:52 No.63091035
    Yasuhiro is probably my favorite director. He should really get more work.

    Mizu no Kotoba > Eve no Jikan > Pale Cocoon

    Surprisingly, you can still see a lot of his previous works in the Kimi no Iru Machi ova.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:53 No.63091066
    >>63090419
    I had the same thoughts

    Humanity in that world is pretty much doomed, robots taking off the halo is the first step
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:54 No.63091095
         File: 1332366865.jpg-(44 KB, 640x480, evesammy1253634710320.jpg)
    44 KB
    So...
    Which one?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:55 No.63091135
    >>63091095

    Why do I have to choose?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:55 No.63091154
         File: 1332366954.jpg-(8 KB, 200x200, 304249_10150879619195313_86796(...).jpg)
    8 KB
    >>63090419
    >robots shouldn't be having emotions

    wat
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:56 No.63091159
    >>63091066
    Yeah let's go to the factories and destroy every machine! Also every computer, smart phone and everything since it could become dangerous! But of course let drunken idiots go around the streets with a gun and put idiots on the government!
    Fucking retard.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:56 No.63091175
         File: 1332366999.gif-(923 KB, 640x352, 1223257170545.gif)
    923 KB
    >>63091135
    Because life is suffering.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:58 No.63091252
    >>63091159
    Bill Joy agreed, don't bother him about it.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:58 No.63091257
         File: 1332367119.jpg-(214 KB, 1920x1080, 1301394689200.jpg)
    214 KB
    >>63090419
    >>63090987
    Seems like there will always be people like this.

    And that IS really scary.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)17:59 No.63091296
    >>63091159
    I'm pretty sure he was talking about humanoid robots, not fucking washing machines
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:00 No.63091363
    >>63091159
    >robots become sentient with emotions
    >people start looking at them as human
    >eventual replacement of humanity with robots
    >possible being set free from the three laws because lolmorals

    No
    >> Anonymous of South Jersey !Null8Koj06 03/21/12(Wed)18:01 No.63091382
    An anime about robots?

    Please tell me more.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:01 No.63091393
    >>63091175

    I refuse. It's not cheating if one's human and the other's a robot.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:02 No.63091460
    >>63091296
    What humanoid? Its about intelligence, you could just as well go to the cern and destroy every supercomputer because ITS TOO DANGEROUS HERPDERP.
    Also its the hypocrisy that humans can't be evil but everything else is, fucking hell you people are the cancer of mankind.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:03 No.63091483
    this anime really good
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:03 No.63091506
         File: 1332367416.gif-(217 KB, 100x100, 1231713960474.gif)
    217 KB
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:04 No.63091528
    >>63091460
    Who says humans arent evil? I would just rather have my race survive and not be overtaken machines who look and act like man
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:04 No.63091531
    >>63091363
    >implying you would know if this has already happened or not
    >implying life would be in any way different with the exception that robot services and goods will become commonplace in the economy,
    >> I ♥ !Sammy.Xp42 03/21/12(Wed)18:05 No.63091561
         File: 1332367509.jpg-(242 KB, 1920x1080, disappointed.jpg)
    242 KB
    >>63091135
    >not being faithful
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:05 No.63091571
    >>63091363
    So what, you're fine with a thug robbing on you on the streets and stabbing you in the kidneys but would destroy a sentient being because it can be dangerous. Why don't we just kill everyone? They can be potentionally dangerous.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:05 No.63091585
         File: 1332367542.jpg-(19 KB, 336x300, edward_james_olmos.jpg)
    19 KB
    >>63091531

    No humanity, you are the cyborgs
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:05 No.63091586
    how can someone NOT like sammy?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:06 No.63091627
    >>63091528
    >my race
    You mean evolved monkeys? In that sense artifical intelligence would be the next step of human evolution. Its like shooting your kid in the head if you think he can be smarter or stronger than you.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:08 No.63091695
    >>63091627
    Well if my kid someone ended up as a alien who would eventually repopulate the world with a different species, then yes, shoot him
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:08 No.63091704
    There is a movie version of Eve no Jikan which contains all six episodes plus some extra scenes.

    It's great.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:08 No.63091711
    >>63091627
    But our children aren't going to overthrow us and enslave us
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:09 No.63091729
    >>63091561
    See:
    >>63091393
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:09 No.63091730
         File: 1332367748.jpg-(91 KB, 640x480, 1313176450821.jpg)
    91 KB
    Before reaching this >>63091363
    Japan will have to deal with the lack of young men and women to sustain the near future economy.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:10 No.63091784
         File: 1332367818.jpg-(105 KB, 400x388, too early.jpg)
    105 KB
    >>63091528
    >I would just rather have my race survive
    >and not be overtaken machines who look and act like man
    >look and act like man
    So in essence your race will survive, if not in flesh then in its intents and thoughts.

    I for one would die happily knowing that my generation has given rise to such a wonderful creation that'll carry life to the stars.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:10 No.63091792
    >>63091704
    I've seen the movie before I knew there was a lso a series. So I can ignore the series completely? I was put abit off by the lack of "real" ending of the movie.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:10 No.63091798
         File: 1332367847.jpg-(155 KB, 1280x2160, 1292950931376.jpg)
    155 KB
    >>63091695
    Oh so you're just retarded, in my opinion you should be shot.
    >>63091711
    They'll overthrow us, thats their role. But enslave jesus christ the hell are you on? You just pull shit out of your ass now.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:11 No.63091826
    >>63091730
    Literally jumped out of my seat to get a better look at that picture. I would really like to fucking visit that cafe
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:12 No.63091857
    >>63091792
    They say it was supposed to be the first of a series of movies or more OVAs, but nothing's been confirmed yet.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:12 No.63091882
    >>63091730

    but there isn't an cafe at that location, is there?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:13 No.63091908
    >>63091792
    Movie is the series+more

    >>63091798
    I guess I just cant see your point of why someone that would overtake humanity is a good thing that shouldn't be stopped
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:13 No.63091921
         File: 1332367997.jpg-(246 KB, 1920x1080, [Chaos-MII]_Eve_no_Jikan_Gekij(...).jpg)
    246 KB
    >>63091826
    Don't know if there's a real cafe in there but it would be awesome.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:13 No.63091946
    >>63091730

    Actually, that's better I think. A lacking population will lead to an increased need for automation, pushing robotics further.

    Unless of course they just go for immigrants instead of robots.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:13 No.63091957
    >>63091908
    >humans taking over humanity
    MUST BE STOPPED
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:14 No.63091976
    >>63091729
    >>63091393
    They are both people.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:14 No.63091990
    >>63091882
    But that door
    That door

    しんじたい

    Just tried to type in captcha with kana
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:14 No.63091993
    >>63089268
    It's decent, but definitely not all it's hyped up to be.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:14 No.63091994
    >>63091957
    But they are robots
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:15 No.63092029
    >robots shouldn't have emotions
    You fucktards do know that emotions are just chemical reactions inside the brain right? By that point of view a more advanced machine that can mimic emotions can be a lot more real than the real emotions.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:15 No.63092036
    >>63091990
    Kind of cool that you got exactly one word out of that.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:16 No.63092052
    >>63091976

    Don't mess with my rationalization.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:16 No.63092056
    >>63091946
    >Unless of course they just go for immigrants instead of robots.
    Hope not.

    I know, they're pushing technology to have a way to survive keeping their culture after the low birth rates.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:17 No.63092122
    >>63091994
    They are made by humans, and have the same mind as humans. How is that not the same? Just because they aren't flesh and bone? Then you better jump out of the window now, after a while biological bodies will be uncapable for the human civilisation. Just as single celled bodies aren't enough now, its called evolving you retard.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:18 No.63092139
    >>63092122

    I so want an awesome robot body.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:19 No.63092164
    >>63092122
    What is a man?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:19 No.63092170
         File: 1332368363.png-(389 KB, 853x480, Eve no Jikan 6 [7352593E].mkv_(...).png)
    389 KB
    >>63091908
    >Movie is the series+more
    Except for this scene.

    I was a bit disappointed that they left it out.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:19 No.63092191
    >>63091993
    >>63090851
    Don't know what you were expecting, but it was pretty much flawless in my opinion.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:20 No.63092217
    >>63091994
    Okay, time for the old thought experiment.

    You know your brain is full of neurons, millions of them. Let's say a patient is suffering from Alzheimer's and is literally losing parts of his head. So we build a perfect copy of a neuron and replace each dying neuron with an undying one.

    When we start he has his fully normal brain except for one mechanical neuron. Then, as time goes on, we have to replace more and more of his neurons with artificial ones. Eventually his entire brain is artificial.

    When did he become a "robot"?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:20 No.63092243
    >>63092164
    A miserable pile of secrets.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:21 No.63092250
    >>63092122

    A programmed machine just isn't a human, its a machine, made to do something. If someone included in it happens to be an imitation in addition to whatever else, it doesn't make it human
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:21 No.63092273
    >>63092164
    The second evolution of Monkey.

    If by any means, you could essentially become immortal, or rather, the 'human mind', you've become more then a man.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:21 No.63092282
    >>63092250
    Humans are just computers, deal with it.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:21 No.63092291
    >>63092217
    Thats a cyborg
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:22 No.63092337
    >>63092250
    The brain is just a programmed machine too. And even now there are learning capable softwares, made by humans, can learn, thats the definition of a human.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:22 No.63092342
    >>63092291
    What's the difference in this example? Let's replace the entire body with mechanical "cells" as well, using the same process. In the end the patient is 100% artificial.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:22 No.63092345
         File: 1332368578.png-(10 KB, 180x180, 1292896136540.png)
    10 KB
    >>63091994
    >typical bioluddite
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:23 No.63092362
    >>63092217

    Locke's sock anyone?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:25 No.63092463
    >>63092342
    Who knows, I couldn't say. In the end i hope we never close to any of this with technology. Which we likely wont anyways
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:26 No.63092483
    >>63092250
    You're a collection of meat and firing neurons. By looking at the human personality using a Freudian lens, it is possible to reason that every single thought that passes through your conscious mind is resultant of an urge to reproduce.
    individual. All personalities can be replicated. You don't exist as a person

    Humans are every bit as machine as robots, ableit a tad squishier.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:26 No.63092488
         File: 1332368782.jpg-(28 KB, 382x333, consider-the-following-kumagaw(...).jpg)
    28 KB
    There'll always be a difference between robots and humans because robots are created, while humans just happened. A robot will always have a concrete answer as to what purpose it exists for, even if that purpose is just to be as much like a human as possible; something no human will ever have.

    Even if robots become as intelligent as us in every way, I think that will remain a profound spiritual difference between us. Their lives will be defined by ours for so long as we are around.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:26 No.63092490
    >>63092342
    I don't think thats their point dude, its that a consciousness created artifically is human or not. Your point proves that there's no difference in the hardware, and their origin is the same too, someone who made it. Just like you are raised by a community, an artifical intelligence is developed by other people. They're the same as humanity's childrens. Wanting to kill them is just insane idiocricy.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:27 No.63092516
    >>63092217
    Ignoring the 'robot' and 'cyborg'

    Never. Because he was originally human he never died
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:28 No.63092565
    >>63092488
    >something no human will ever have.
    Oh really? I wonder what the billions of religious people have to say about that, hell even scientists have a goal in life.
    Also human lives are defined by humans just as much, thats not an argument.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:28 No.63092567
    >>63092488
    >There'll always be a difference between robots and humans because robots are created, while humans just happened.
    What do you mean, 'humans just happened'? Do you mean, in contrast to robots, humans were created 'by accident'?
    Because that's no longer the case. So are we no longer human?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:28 No.63092569
    >>63092483

    I dont see what this has to do with it, really.

    Ok, humans are machines.

    Robots we create and develop would still be a different form of machine, and, depending on ease of making would replace the old ones with time or death
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:29 No.63092609
    >>63092362
    Considering that the human body continously replaces its own constituent materials and individual particles are interchangeable anyway you can only judge it by its emergent features.

    So the question - again - boils down to what makes you human? Is it having 46 chromosomes filled with million years worth of cruft, a carbon-based body, ...

    or maybe your mind is more important? Your memories, your personality etc.

    If so, what's so bad with replacing your body with a machine if the mind remains? You would still consider yourself human, no?

    Now if we created a new entity from scratch but following similar patterns to those of a digitized human mind. Have we not created yet another mechanized human?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:30 No.63092632
    The difference only depends on what criteria you judge to be necessary to be a human.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:30 No.63092654
    >>63092609

    You created an imitation
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:31 No.63092668
         File: 1332369077.jpg-(37 KB, 493x402, 1310813708847.jpg)
    37 KB
    >>63092567
    Humans evolved, robots did not and never will.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:31 No.63092689
    >>63092654
    Just like when you raise a child, you create an imitation. So then its not a human, you have to kill it.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:32 No.63092694
    >>63092668
    I have no idea why I uploaded that image
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:32 No.63092696
    >>63092565

    You can decide to have a goal in life, but you were not built with one. It's an important difference.

    >>63092567

    Trace humanity back far enough and it's just a chemical reaction that came about for no reason at all other than the conditions being right; there was no purpose to life, it just happened, unless there was an invisible divine hand in it.

    Robots, on the other hand, will know who made them and why.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:32 No.63092714
    >>63092463
    I'm pretty sure we'll be working on artificial body parts for a long, long time. That includes brain cells....

    Besides, would it be any different if we grew a bunch of cells and assembled a human from bits of tissue? It's still an assembled "robot", right?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:32 No.63092727
    >>63092668
    Why not? If they learn, are they not evolving?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:33 No.63092743
    >>63092569
    If you were to create an A.I. on par with a human brain, with the possibility of personality, is it still an imitation of life?

    Or maybe something more recent will ring better

    Which is more valuable, a real thing, or something indistinguishable from the real thing?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:33 No.63092761
    >>63092668
    We've already invented some crude self-programming computer code. It evolves, just not very well. We're getting better at it.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:34 No.63092784
    >>63092668
    Are you retarded or something? Of course they evolved, just look at how far software development got in the last 70 years, if they reach the point of human intelligence they can do it themselves too.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:34 No.63092806
    >>63092689
    An imitation of what? A child is humanity's natural way of going on another generation. Its not at all similar to creating and producing a breed of Factory Man on the production line
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:34 No.63092809
    >>63092668
    O rly?
    http://www.cs.uvm.edu/~jbongard/Press/2011_09_NewScientist.pdf
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:36 No.63092895
    >>63092743
    The real thing, until all the fakes ruin the market
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:37 No.63092911
    What's the matter? Are you afraid of the Uncaaaanyyyyyy Vaaalleeeeeyyyy?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:37 No.63092918
    >>63090419
    OH NO, THINGS THAT ARE NOT DESIGNED FOR COMBAT, ARE EXTREMELY FUCKING EASY TO DISABLE, AND WHICH FOLLOW THE THREE LAWS OF ROBOT...

    I don't even want to finish ranting, just, fucking read some Asimov before you start talking like some jackass.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:37 No.63092927
    >>63092696
    origin != purpose

    >>63092668
    >implying they won't use genetic algorithms to design better versions of themselves
    It will be engineered evolution, but that's no different than PID or gene therapy for example.

    And evolution is really just a natural process of optimization, it can be easily substituted with an artificial one. Just like your kidney can be replaced with an engineered one.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:37 No.63092928
    >>63092696
    >You can decide to have a goal in life
    You seriously think that its the case in every possible scenario? Fucking hell in places like China or India you wouldn't have a chance to decide, and sometimes its the case on the west too. But every human have a goal in life to support mankind thats why they are born, thats what is encoded in their DNA, its the role of AI's too, how are they any different then.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:39 No.63092994
    >>63092806
    >societally looked down upon to not reproduce and raise children
    >humanity somehow not relatable to a production line
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:39 No.63092996
    >>63092784

    Software didn't "evolve," it developed as humans improved on it. Even self-altering intelligences will have their base and likely the general outline of their future lives in human design.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:40 No.63093033
    >>63092806
    An imitation of you, and the community you live in. AI is the way of evolving too, and woman womb is just a factory just a lot slower than a mechanical one. There's not much of a difference. Until nowadays, and in war times childs birth like a production line, 6-8 childbirths of a single woman.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:41 No.63093082
    >>63092996
    According to that logic it was the environment that shaped humans as we are, how is that any different?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:42 No.63093162
    >>63092918
    The point is they can revolt.
    If a robot is to learn then what limit could you possibly put on it's learning capabilities?
    Eventually it would get to the point where it doesn't need you anymore.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:44 No.63093211
    >>63093162
    So as soon as it doesn't need us anymore it decides to revolt? What is the logic in that?

    What would they have to gain by revolting?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:44 No.63093224
    >being so beta that you see nothing wrong in being replaced by robots

    how horrifying
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:44 No.63093239
    >>63091704
    I need to watch it. I've only seen the individual episodes.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:45 No.63093269
    >>63093162
    Fucking hell you are retarded. Revolt? You're scared of robots revolting, ahh just kill yourself this Earth can't bear this much autism.
    Your kid will reach a point where he doesn't need you anymore, and can kill you if he wants to. So you'll never have a child or kill him after being born? Good job you saved mankind, fucking retard.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:45 No.63093280
    I have only watched the movie and loved it -
    so my question is,
    should I watch the individual episodes, too,

    or won't I gain "anything" by watching the series?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:46 No.63093310
    >>63093224
    >being so beta that you are scared by being replaced by superior versions
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:46 No.63093311
    >>63093162
    If they are based on the three laws, revolt is pretty much impossible so much as it's possible that any human is hurt.

    then, they would be limited by the technological impairments of man. since self evolving programs are even more conceptually impossible then robots with human personality, they'll learn at the rate of humans

    lastly, any sufficiently advanced species prioritizes their existence above all else. it would be much easier to exist alongside, rather then war with, historically violent species.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:46 No.63093316
    >>63093280
    Read the thread
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:46 No.63093317
    >>63093211
    Revolt was a poor choice of words
    But when something created to assist humans no longer feels the need to assist humans
    then what purpose does it have?
    In the end it becomes extra clutter
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:46 No.63093326
    >>63093224
    This is the same shit as the whole
    >kill all commies or they'll take over!
    >enslave all blacks or they'll take over!
    >stop the gays or they'll take over!

    The film is about integration, INTEGRATION, it's a really really obvious theme all throughout.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:47 No.63093347
         File: 1332370041.jpg-(47 KB, 600x428, gynoid.jpg)
    47 KB
    >>63092911
    Japan is working on it. It's still a bit jarring when they talk, but the newer models also got better facial micromovements.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:48 No.63093383
         File: 1332370092.jpg-(150 KB, 959x994, 1241781005713.jpg)
    150 KB
    So does the movie leave anything out or is it all the episodes + some?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:48 No.63093392
    >>63093317
    What purpose does a freed slave have

    inb4 niggers are cluster
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:48 No.63093399
    >>63093280
    Not really, the movie got some extra scenes but other than that its completely identical.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:48 No.63093409
    >>63093383
    READ
    THE
    FUCKING
    THREAD
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:50 No.63093496
    >>63093326
    commies, blacks and gays are all human
    robots are not
    once they realize they don't need they will proceed to wipe out the earth
    thus they must be stopped before reaching intelligence

    >>63093310
    >not taking proper steps to defend your race against berserk husks that think they are alive
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:51 No.63093539
    >>63093383
    >>63093399
    see >>63092170
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:51 No.63093552
    >>63093392
    Slaves are humans
    Humans were not created for your convenience
    Slaves were humans who were forced to serve you
    Robots were CREATED for your convenience. That's their sole purpose.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:51 No.63093563
    >>63093317
    Being human? If they are on the same level as humans, and humans can improve their capabilities too. Both in the same league then what is the difference? Where is the difference?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:53 No.63093622
    I just want to say this is the best EnJ thread I've seen on /a/ in a long time.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:53 No.63093630
    >>63093496
    Thinfoil hat much, I say they're humans and you're a potential murderer for wanting to kill them.
    >>63093552
    >Humans were not created for your convenience
    They were if they're slaves. Thats what it means.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:53 No.63093631
    >>63093552
    >Robots were CREATED for your convenience
    You were created for the convenience of your parents, that is for passing on their genes and because of sentimental values they might hold.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:54 No.63093653
    >>63093552
    Slaves were born and raised for your convenience. They're no different from something programmed to do so. The only difference being that one is made out of metal
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:54 No.63093659
    >>63093552
    >normal robots
    That's fine. We're already using them after all

    >sentient ones
    That's just another form of slavery and thus most likely illegal. Or at the very least unethical.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:55 No.63093695
    >>63093653
    What if its made of flesh instead of metal? Is it more human than a metal one?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:55 No.63093698
    >>63093326
    Revolt is the right term - archetype robot stories have the slavery theme built into them.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:55 No.63093733
    >>63093630
    >I say they are humans
    well brah, you sure got me there, I don't know what to say, I'm stumped

    oh wait
    they aren't
    and no amount of philosophising is gonna change that
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:56 No.63093744
    >>63093552
    If sentient, mechanical beings that understood emotion, pain, and reason were created would you automatically annihilate them because they weren't human?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:57 No.63093779
    >>63093695
    I believe every sentient being on par with a human is entitled to what I am entitled to.

    I take fault with the term human, more then questioning whether or not something is or is not.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:57 No.63093784
    >>63093733
    They are, no matter what kind of, uhh nothing? you bring up since you haven't did at all, will change that fact.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:57 No.63093792
    >>63091363
    OH NO, instead of dying and being replaced by something that is not you but shares similar properties, you have to die and be replaced by something that is not you but shares similar properties. Poor baby.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:57 No.63093802
         File: 1332370645.jpg-(114 KB, 459x650, 74128b36ba7f4bb50d1dab734e4ec7(...).jpg)
    114 KB
    >>63092928
    >thats what is encoded in their DNA

    Not really, or people couldn't turn away from it when they want; serial killers, tyrants, suicides, the average dude, only care about who they decide to care about. Friends, lovers, family, even ourselves, nothing's too sacred to be thrown away. What's encoded in our DNA are the triggers for growing into what we are, and a lot of useless junk that's built up over the eons. There's instincts there, but humans above all other creatures are flexible in their life plan; flexibility being the entire advantage of intelligence.

    You can decide to have a purpose, someone else can decide you have a purpose, but trace yourself far enough back, through the ancestors that shaped both you and society, and down the chain of evolution and you'll find there was no purpose at the beginning; the whole long chain that ended in you happened for no apparent reason at all. The purpose you give yourself, that others can give you, has no more weight than you give it.

    This will be a distinct difference, because a robot won't have to look billions of years into the past to find its origin; its origin is RoboCorp, and it's a Walmart greeter. Facts. A human is an accident, but a robot is a tool, and purpose is something that only things like tools have; a rock exists for no reason, a hammer is created by something with a will, for a purpose.

    >>63092927

    Origin is important in discerning whether something can have a purpose or not.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:57 No.63093805
    >>63093744
    yes, they are too dangerous
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:57 No.63093809
    >>63093563
    >If they are on the same level as humans
    But they're not
    This isn't a case of "we need them and they need us" but more like "They need us".
    How can you possibly say that a being that can't even open it's eyes unless we allow it to is equal to us?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:57 No.63093832
    >>63093733
    Depending on their design (accurately modeling a human brain in software for example) you might or might make an argument whether they are human or not.

    What you cannot deny is that a sentient, self-aware being should be granted personhood status and equivalent rights.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:58 No.63093861
    >>63093805
    Why should people get to live? Haven't they proven how dangerous they are?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:59 No.63093901
    >>63093784
    I don't need to bring up nothing. It's a simple fact. They. Are. Not. Human. Get it?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)18:59 No.63093924
    >>63093802
    >serial killers, tyrants, suicides
    Those can be considered malfunctions, just as a program can malfunction. Reproduction and surviving is encoded in the DNA.
    A human is an accident, what? Are you serious? Your parents deliberately gave birth and raised you, its not an accident by any stretch of the imagination.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:00 No.63093943
    >>63093805
    People are too dangerous, kill them all.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:00 No.63093947
    >Peope defending robots

    Enjoy your Manhacks and Metalgears raping everything you ever loved you faggots.


    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SSbZrQp-HOk

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3lHy1UvIrE
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:00 No.63093966
    >>63093802
    >Origin is important in discerning whether something can have a purpose or not.
    Life begets life. So you could same they ultimately share the same origin.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:01 No.63093976
    >>63092895
    Both are of equal value as Oshino would say.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:01 No.63093978
    >>63093901
    They are human though, if you can't back up your opinion then its defunct and I'm automatically right.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:02 No.63094041
    >>63093901
    Human is a cheap word. Murderers aren't human, rapists aren't human, pedophiles aren't human.

    Though yes, biology does in fact, trump ideology. But then the fact turns to, becuase something is not a homo sapien and is capable of intelligent thought, you reason that it must be destroyed.

    Destruction of a sentient existence is essentially murder.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:02 No.63094053
    >>63093947
    Oh look, it's the source of all this faggotry: people who just play some games and watch some movies, then think they know everything.

    Think about what it means to be human. That's the point of all this.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:03 No.63094080
    >>63093947
    >my sci-fi is fact!
    Autism at its best.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:03 No.63094111
    >>63093924
    What he's saying is that the origin of all life on earth, single celled organisms, just happened by chance to continually evolve down the line into what humanity is today.

    That is the "accident"
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:04 No.63094121
    >>63094041
    Its the removal of threats to the race

    Just as the Neanderthals(maybe?) got removed, so should sentient man robots if they ever get that
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:04 No.63094155
         File: 1332371098.jpg-(22 KB, 600x256, Terminator-thumbs-up.jpg)
    22 KB
    >>63093947
    And science marches on: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2D71CveQwo
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:05 No.63094164
    >>63094080


    Those videos are both identical to what are in those sci-fi works though. That manhack thing would literally be identical if they attached a buzzsaw to it and that proto dog is like a metalgear baby.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:05 No.63094174
    >>63094111
    But that accident lead into the existence of AI too by that point of view...
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:05 No.63094187
    >>63094121
    Most neanderthals were integrated into humanity.

    Those that didn't mix with us just died out.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:06 No.63094204
    >>63093978
    You are quite stupid aren't you?

    >>63094041
    it's murder, yes, but it's for the purpose of survival

    when the robot rebellion starts I'll bet they'll keep you as pets, don't worry
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:06 No.63094223
    >>63094111
    and robots descend from that line too.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:06 No.63094236
    >>63094121
    The greatest threat to the race's existence now is war, so we should kill everyone because they're potential threats. What can't you see how twisted your logic is.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:07 No.63094250
    >>63094121
    New evidence indicates we fucked Neanderthals until they merged with our species.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaic_human_admixture_with_modern_Homo_sapiens

    BETTER GET STARTED ON FUCKING ROBOTS!
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:07 No.63094268
    >>63094204
    So what are they gonna kill their engineers for?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:07 No.63094277
    >>63094223
    Yes, I know.

    They would be a direct consequence of humanities cognitive evolution.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:08 No.63094301
    >>63094204
    >I have no argument just spouting unreasonable shit
    >calling someone else an idiot
    That irony.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:08 No.63094305
         File: 1332371292.jpg-(46 KB, 600x595, sip.jpg)
    46 KB
    >>63094250
    Don't touch my waifu
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:09 No.63094334
    >>63094121
    Evolution did that. Any sentience above simple instinct would understand war is detrimental to existence. Thus, assuming robots had intelligence to be a threat to humanity, they must either

    a) be sentient enough to realize war would damage them as equally as it would us

    b) be inherently more powerful then us in all ways imaginable, and we would be unable to rid ourselves of them in that case.

    In the latter case, we can just chalk it up to evolution as well
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:09 No.63094338
    >>63093978
    >>63093901
    >>63094041

    So the question is in the end:

    Can something which wasn't "naturally born" as a human gain the right to be called "human"

    which furthermore leads to the thought

    Can someone who was "naturally born" as a human lose his right to be treated like one,
    because he committed for example unforgivable inhuman crimes?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:09 No.63094339
    >>63094164
    >if they attached a buzzsaw to it and that proto dog is like a metalgear baby
    That was a good laugh, but now gb2youtube, thats the only community I can think of that is this retarded.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:09 No.63094365
    >>63094268
    But you see it's this exact point that will forever make them obedient to us.
    They can't live without us because we keep their hardware in check.
    What's the point of them developing sentience if at the end of the day they are subject to our will or else they die.
    And when we wither away and die then so will they.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:10 No.63094390
         File: 1332371432.jpg-(259 KB, 640x720, 19685448.jpg)
    259 KB
    All of my HHHHHNNNNNNNGGGGGGGHHHHHH
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:10 No.63094407
    >>63094250
    Integrating robots and humans together is the next step in the evolution of mankind.

    Who says there needs to be a war? Mind uploading and coexistence with artificial intelligence will be the best possible outcome down the line.

    "Natural" humans with enhancements in cognitive function working together with advanced AI would benefit everyone.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:11 No.63094415
    >>63094365
    Not likely, if they reach the level of human intelligence.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:11 No.63094442
    >>63094407
    Transhumanism: why leave the future of humanity to chance?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:11 No.63094444
         File: 1332371507.jpg-(1.06 MB, 2000x992, End of Mass Effect.jpg)
    1.06 MB
    > Still debating human-robot relations

    > not realizing humans and all other biological lifeforms will eventually merge with robotic life
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:11 No.63094446
    >>63094338
    I think the real question is:

    Do creatures that are of human intelligence, but not human deserve the same rights as human beings
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:11 No.63094447
    >>63089268
    >but robots seriously creep me the fuck out
    This show is made for you.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:11 No.63094449
    >>63094301
    >unreasonable shit
    >believes robots can be human
    no this is irony
    >>63094268
    engineers will be kept around until they have the proper knowledge to maintain themselves forever
    then they will be killed of because their existence will remind of the fact they were created by them and therefore are inferior
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:12 No.63094461
    >>63094365
    They can keep their own hardware in check if they learn how to check each other's hardware. It's the same as how we check each others health at the doctors office.

    They can also learn how to build more of themselves among other things.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:12 No.63094472
    >>63094407
    Thats what will probably happen, closed minded idiots can't hold back evolution forever.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:13 No.63094495
         File: 1332371600.jpg-(110 KB, 719x932, sammy_shy.jpg)
    110 KB
    >>63094390
    I hope you won't mind if I add that to my collection.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:13 No.63094517
    Too bad if robots ever got out of line the government would only need to detonate a few emps and every single one of them would be roasted.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:14 No.63094524
    >>63094449
    Thats just a shitty science fiction, not even a theory or a fact. Dolphins will evolve into intelligent beings and will enslave humanity with sea otter-dog halfbreds, see? I can make up shit too.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:14 No.63094531
    >>63094472

    but isn't evolution by definition a process which occurs naturally by chance?
    >> (ノ´_ゝ`)ノ !MoeMoe/nYc 03/21/12(Wed)19:14 No.63094545
    Why would you even mass produce true AIs and give them bodies?
    Nobody would be allowed to buy such a thing and few would desire it.

    It's a pipe dream.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:14 No.63094561
    >>63094517
    >implying there isnt hulling to proect from emps
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:15 No.63094566
    No getting around it. Misanthropes are to robot stories as lolicons are to little girl moeblobs animes.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:15 No.63094580
    >>63094531
    No, thats mutation. Evolution is the improvement of a race.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:15 No.63094590
    >>63094524
    Oh shit, I better go practice my harpooning.
    >> (ノ´_ゝ`)ノ !MoeMoe/nYc 03/21/12(Wed)19:16 No.63094617
         File: 1332371781.jpg-(71 KB, 300x356, 1329743208755.jpg)
    71 KB
    >>63094580
    >Evolution is the improvement of a race.
    That's wrong.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:18 No.63094682
         File: 1332371885.jpg-(585 KB, 1024x740, 07a938d798d16444f16d4e5d594f1f(...).jpg)
    585 KB
    >>63094461
    Or they could just repair themselves.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:18 No.63094683
    >>63094461
    But there would have to be imposed regulations
    We as humans have a biological limit to how many children we can have at a time.
    There's nothing stopping a robot from making as many friends as he wants.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:18 No.63094693
    Fact is, humanized robots will never be put into full production. People are already concerned enough as it is over growing population and dwindling resources, there's no need to contribute to either of these problems. If functional robots ever get made they'll likely all be used to take care of menial/dangerous jobs and they likely won't be given a personality.

    Why would they develop a personality for a robot that's only intended use is to work? What would be an easier sell, a mindless robot who will do any task given to it or a robot with a personality who will bitch about doing boring/dangerous things like a normal person would and who will demand pay?

    If sentient robots are ever developed they will be a novelty and few in numbers.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:19 No.63094710
    >>63094617
    >The term evolution (from its literal meaning of "unfolding" of something into its true or explicit form) carries a connotation of gradual improvement or directionality from a beginning to an end point.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:19 No.63094737
    >>63094683
    >There's nothing stopping a robot from making as many friends as he wants.
    There are, the capabilities of factories and resources, same as humans.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:19 No.63094738
    >>63094683
    Earth's dwindling resources of precious metals
    >> (ノ´_ゝ`)ノ !MoeMoe/nYc 03/21/12(Wed)19:20 No.63094766
    >>63094693
    You might be able to buy VI equipped robots, but never real AIs.

    Basically, you can have a bodied anime character, but no real girl.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:20 No.63094767
    I think you're all focusing on the word human too much. Sentient beings, be they human or any other form, should be treated equally. Imagine an isolated divergent species being discovered in some rainforest or deep wilderness that humanity has yet to encroach upon. They have their own language and social structure, completely and obviously sentient, but they aren't human. Do we kill them? Lock them up in cages? Or treat them equally and coexist? What if it wasn't a primitive race, but a more advanced one. Aliens land, the mean no harm, but they're definitely sentient beings. Kill them out of fear? Try to capture them? Or welcome them to the party? Same scenario as before but the roles are reversed. I hope your answer didn't change. Now take that last situation and reveal that these aliens were really robots, created by an alien race, but otherwise indistinguishable from the original. You're still dealing with an intelligent sentient being, but now you find it's been artificially created. How do you handle them now? If any different, why?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:21 No.63094815
    >>63094693
    >they will be a novelty and few in numbers
    Just like computers were in 70's?
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:22 No.63094842
    >>63094545
    >buy supercomputer-in-a-box
    >add AI powder
    >stir carefully
    >teach it for a few years
    >buy a body for it on it's 5th bootday.
    Just like raising children. Just better.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:22 No.63094847
    >>63094334
    >evolution
    fuck I'm a retard, I meant survival of the fittest
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:22 No.63094855
    >>63094738
    This. No more batteries and large television displays for you, either, unless there's some sort of breakthrough.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:23 No.63094879
    >>63094847
    "Natural selection"
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:23 No.63094882
         File: 1332372212.jpg-(260 KB, 761x833, fappinghand.jpg)
    260 KB
    Robots have to have emotions in order to be sentient. There are many judgements that call for an emotional evaluation in order to be made. In the absence of these emotions, robots would be paralyzed and unable to act. It's basic cognition. This study goes into this in more detail: cogprints.org/705/2/Aaron.Sloman_why_robot_emotions.ps
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:23 No.63094911
         File: 1332372234.jpg-(49 KB, 480x300, turna_moonlight1.jpg)
    49 KB
    If robots ever got out of line, all we need to do is send in Turn A Gundam
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:24 No.63094927
    >>63094815


    That's a strawman and you know it. There's no benefit to making a robot with fully functioning AI over a souless robot.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:24 No.63094951
    >>63094879
    I would actually use the term survival of the fittest for more rhetorical reasons. Or at least for the bit in closing
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:24 No.63094961
    >>63094882
    With sufficiently advanced science, people will be able to copy the limbic system so robots can have emotions too.
    >> (ノ´_ゝ`)ノ !MoeMoe/nYc 03/21/12(Wed)19:25 No.63094979
         File: 1332372321.jpg-(57 KB, 586x587, 1332078919571.jpg)
    57 KB
    >>63094815
    There's no reason why you would give a machine sentience.
    Using them as slaves would certainly be illegal in virtually all countries.
    There'd probably be a few for research purposes, but that's it.

    I'm not saying AIs will never be used, just that they won't walk around looking like humans and be sold to regular people.
    >> Anonymous 03/21/12(Wed)19:25 No.63094993
    >>63094927
    There's no reason to raise a child with a personality over a mindless slave.



    [Return] [Top]
    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]