but its shit

>No fractale

average madoka fan.

>>55685994
>single handedly
>Best Male Character: Rintaro Okabe
>Best Commercial: THE IDOLM@STER
>Best Male VA: Mamoru Miyano Okabe Rintarō
>Best Movie: Macross Frontier The Wings of Goodbye
you keep using that word...

I am more than okay with this.

> Ranked # 1: "☆ Madoka Magika Maho Shojo"

Thread over.

>Best Male Character
>Not Kiritsugu

>>55686088

I imagine the poll was conducted before Fate/zero was even close to airing.

>>55686050
>implying Madoka has any notable male characters to qualify for best male award
>implying Madoka required any commercial and advertisement to attract viewers
>implying Madoka is a MOVIE

>>55686088
Wow, it's been a while since I have seen someone on /a/ who actually knows how to troll.
7/10

>>55686088
Only two episodes out.
And he didn't even get to participate in this poll because Fate/Zero aired in fall.

>>55686088
Fate/zero hasn't aired yet when the award started. Maybe next year

>>55686102
fate/zero is shit.

>Best Female Character: Akemi Homura (Madoka Magica)
>not even the critics care about the titular character

I agree

>8位：「IS 〈インフィニット・ストラトス〉 」
>7位：「俺の妹がこんなに可愛いわけがない」
Outside of these 2, the top10 is pretty much accurate.

>>55686131

>Fate/zero is the shit.

Fixed that for you.

READY got fifth?
That's disappointing. Oh well.

its hard to like a popular anime

>>55686050
>Male main characters
>Madoka Magica
pick one.

>>55686106
>implying nothing that you listed just nitpicking the words 'single handedly' when other shows are mentioned

>implying Madoka required any commercial and advertisement to attract viewers
http://zepy.momotato.com/2011/04/20/madoka-full-page-advertisement-on-yomiuri/

>>55686197

QB is now male, just to fill male and mascot role.

>>55686206
Why are you being such a literal faggot.
It still dominated you fuck.

>>55686206
that was for the finale. after the earthquake. It was already popular before that.

Might as well change their name to Moeshittype and get it over with.

>>55686246
Newtype is for fujoshi.

>>55686241
Don't be MAD !

>>55686246
u mad your generic shounen shit didn't get picked?

>>55686206
The last episode was postponed because of the earthquake. They were doing the ads to announce the new date. This isnt like Nichijou where the ads are put everywhere from train to buses.

>>55686246
Why so mad?
You have your yaoibait at #10, your shitty shounen is at #9 and the harem shit is at #8.

>>55686206
Oh, I remember that one. The newspaper sold out quite fast because of the ad.

>>55685994
lol trust Kadokawa to pick shitty anime for their number one crap.

I don't give a shit, I need a link to this Homura cosplay porn.

>>55686326
BD extra episode.

>>55686326
newfags and their 3d

>>taking Kadokawa awards seriously

>Best Female Character: Akemi Homura (Madoka Magica)

Welp, there is always a next time Kurisu

>>55686326
google:
[110708] cosplay shoujo magical magic (mahou shoujo madoka magica) [tma][akb-027]

>>Best Character Design: Madoka Magica
>>Best Music: Madoka Magica
Okay, this shit is undeserved. It does not have the best music by any stretch and the anime is full of QUALITY.. Even I would admit that much.

>>55686377
How is QUALITY related to character design?

>>55686377

Character design =! Quality of animation.

>>55686377
>your opinion > others

>>55686377
Aoki Ume's character design has nothing to do with animation QUALITY. And i would choose Magia over Connect (opinion, no need to argue)

>>55686377
I thought it had a pretty good OST.
I liked it

>>55686395
>>55686402
Welcome to buttmad shits;gayte fans. They've only been here a couple of seasons, you can't expect them to learn anything.

>>55686377
I like how you manage to missunderstand the word design enough to actualy include actual presentation (the de facto animation in sceenes) into it

idk about the music tho

>>55686416
You're saying I can't blame character design if the anime looks like stick figures?

>>55686033

>>55686457
Yes, actually.
That's not what it means.

>>55686445
Stop this shit. Trolls before already tried to incite shit between these two fanbases, they failed.

>>55686457
Nice straw man.

>Best Photography: Madoka Magica
>Best Art Direction: Madoka Magica
>Best Color Design: Madoka Magica
>Best Effects: Madoka Magica

Seriously, 0/10.

>>55686457
Yes.

>>55686457

>the anime looks like stick figures

pic related it's madoka

>>55686475
Who else would give that much of a shit about madoka having good character design? Only people who thought another animu was better, and only a moron would interpret animation as design. The newest fanbase on /a/ is shits;gayte fanboys, as evidenced by the lmao dr pepper XD shit.

>>55686377
The OST is full of emotion that is entirely appropriate for the Mahou Shoujo genre.
Seriously, some of the songs define the anime as much as the characters.

When replaying the OST, I swear I had tears well up during one of the songs, because I LISTENED to it. But that was some time ago and I haven't revisited the music.

>>55686487
I would put Hanasaku Iroha in all of those before I would Madoka. Effects? Not really sure who I would put forward

The whole award is a gigantic ass licking to that certain fanbase anyway. Fuck that shit.

>◆作品賞
>10位：「夏目友人帳」
>9位：「銀魂」
>8位：「IS 〈インフィニット・ストラトス〉 」
>7位：「俺の妹がこんなに可愛いわけがない」
>6位：「輪るピングドラム」
>5位：「STAR DRIVER 輝きのタクト」
>4位：「アイドルマスター」
>3位：「TIGER&BUNNY」
>2位：「あの日見た花の名前をまだ僕は知らない」
>1位：「魔法少女まどか☆マギカ」
AOTY
1: Madoka
2: AnoHana
3: T&B
4: Im@s
5: Star Driver
6: Penguindrum
7: OreImo
8: IS
9: Gintama
10: Natsume

>Best Art Direction: Madoka Magica
>not Penguindrum

>Best Color Design: Madoka Magica
>not Penguindrum

>Best Effects: Madoka Magica
>not Nichijou

>no Best Animation award
>Madoka chosen as stock response in categories where it was weak compared to other, less popular shows of this year

This is what happens when people who know nothing about anime pretend to know a thing or two about anime.

>>55686581

> ANIME EXPERT over 400 animes watched

>>55686581
>liking penguindrum and nichijou
Oh, the hypocrisy.

>>55686559
>other animes are you even trying

inb4 RAAAAGE plural is anime RAAAAGE

>>55686532
>Iroha
>Interesting art
>Good colors
Hilarious/10

>>55686377
>It does not have the best music by any stretch
There's more than the OP and ED you know. Brb, suiciding over decretum, again.

Incoming 300+ posts troll shitstorm

>>55686620
>suiciding over decretum, again.
>again
You suck at suiciding anon.

Male Character
1: Okarin
2: Kotetsu
3: Jintan
4: Touma
5: Kyosuke

Female Character
1: Homura
2: Madoka
3: Kuroneko
4: Menma
5: Ika-chan

Mascot
1: QB
2: Penguin 2
3: Sakamoto-san
4: Kuro (Ao no Exorcist)

>>55686732
>Madoka
>good character
hilarious/10

>2011
>Liking Penguindrum

Leaving before this inevitably turns into a troll thread.(it was from the beggining anyways)

>>55686841
>not adding to the shitstorm that this thread will be
>2011

>>55686732
>kyousuke
I hope you are joking.
Christina where?

>>55685994
Thank you based madoka.jpg

>>55686988
>christina
>generic tsundere
Hahaha, trying to be funny?

I loved Madoka, but wtf @ best effects and the like...

It'd be nice if they gave the awards some actual consideration instead of giving them to the most popular anime. Well, at least violin boy isn't the best male character and VA.

>>55687207
I'm sure critics and art students orgasm all over the inu curry witch scenes.

>>55687207

Yeah, i'm glad that Kyouske wasn't best male.

He's fifth.

>>55687416
Tha's Kyousuke from Ore no Imouto.
Pic related.

>>55687441
that's a shoop btw.

>>55686206
you do know that ad was bought by fans, right? It's not an official advert.

>>55686732
>5: Kyosuke

>>55685994
I guess it is understandable as to why Madoka Magica was chosen for so many different awards. Nothing else this year came close to being interesting anyway. That's not saying too much though.

Madoka Magica did nothing for me in terms of being entertaining. The idea and the connections among the witches, magical girls, and grief seeds was intriguing, but everything else was just a mess.

Look carefully at OP's pic, at Hamura's hair. It looks like a nigger face.

>>55687520
[citation needed]

japan confirmed for shit taste

>Best Song: Madoka Magica "Connect"

WHY
WHY DO THE JAPS ALWAYS LIKE THE FUCKING INTRO SONGS THAT ALL SOUND VAGUELY THE SAME AND NOT SOMETHING AWESOME LIKE ALMOST ANY OTHER FUCKING TRACK IN THE SOUNDTRACK

>>55687561
The fuck?

>>55687520
Why would fans (who knew exactly when rest will air because they were FANS) spend multiple million yen to advertise last two episodes to general public ?
Do you have some link to confirm ?

>>55685994
>Best Art Direction: Madoka Magica

Haaaaaahahah

>>55687618
I agree that connect wasn't exactly the best piece, but the OST was golden anyway. Baka elevens.

>anime in general is shit
>above average shit gets awards

Well, shit.

>>55687680

Ladies and gentlemen, the most positive comment in the thread.

>>55687520
>you do know that ad was bought by fans, right?
wrong

>Madoka
Plot - 5/10
Animation - 4/10
Music - 6/10
Character Development - 4/10

Overall - 3/10

>>55687618
It's the chord progression in the chorus

>>55687835
How do you math?

>>55687835
>Madoka
Plot - 10/10
Animation - 10/10
Music - 10/10
Character Development - 10/10

Overall - 10/10

>>55687835
You suck at maths.

>>55687835
>1FRT
laughing_magical_girls.flv

>>55687863
>>55687835
Samefag

>Best Character Design: Madoka Magica
>Best Song: Madoka Magica "Conect"
>Best Color Design: Madoka Magica

hahahaohwow.jpg

>Best Effects: Madoka Magica
>Best Art Direction: Madoka Magica

Up for debate

>>55687883
>2011
>doesn't know how to detect samefags

Nichijou should have gotten the effects award.

Just saiyan'.

>>55687904
>>55687863
>>55687835
samefag

>>55686575

STAR DRIVER 5th???

>>55687904
shut up Moot rest of us don't see the ips

>2011
>not loving ume aoki character designs
i seriously hope you guys don't do this

>>55687919
>>55687904
>>55687883
samefag
............
samefag

Madoka doesn't deserve half of those awards, and only got them because it was popular in other areas.

>>55687854
That's fair I guess.

>Best Male Character: Rintaro Okabe
>Best Male VA: Mamoru Miyano Okabe Rintarō

well at least they got something right
thought 2/19 is still pretty bad

I'm being trolled... right guys?

you know they would have given the rest of the awards to Madoka too if they could
too bad it doesn't have a male character to force the award on

>>55688164
What about violin-kun?

>>55688189
he's a plot point and not a main character

>>55688144
Nope, the elevens were hard gay for madoka. All of them.

>>55686153
Titular? Madoka is completely flat from what I remember.

>Best Male Supporting VA: Keiji Fujiwara

and he got that from doing what?

I love all animu.

>>55688309
actually she isn't a badly developed character, it's just that Homura's much more interesting.

>>55686361 understimate awards that dont choose your favourite shit.

>>55688381
he probably meant flatchested

>>55686575

Thats just unfair,Penguindrum hasnt even ended yet..

>Best Male Supporting VA: Keiji Fujiwara
You said who all the rest were, but the one guy I don't recognise you don't explain? Who did he play?

>>55688400
>titular
>flat chested
GOD DAMMIT

>>55688509

Keiji Fujiwara is none other than Ladd Russo, Ali Al-Saachez, etc.

>>55687950
You have to make a really convincing argument that the winner of an award whose entire purpose is to represent the choices of the of people voting on it doesn't actually "deserve" it.

The entire point of the award is merely to show what the majority of respondents chose; there were never any objective criteria.

>>55688832
inb4 popular != good, twilight is also popular

All i got from that was Okabe Rintaro confirmed for awesome.

>>55688865
In this case, Madoka is both good and popular.
Might not be masterpiece material but compare to the other shit out there, I am not surprised seeing in coming out on top.
You have stuff like IS, T&B and Star Driver in the top 10 man.

>>55691535
>madoka
>good
HAHAHAHA NO

Japan has terrible taste in anime.

>>55691562
>http://anime.biglobe.ne.jp/userranking/title/22584/
Yup not good, just so great that it was voted the #2 on the list of anime that revolutionize the industry.

>>55692234
0/10