Its over-rated and amazing.

Nah it's shit

Madoka is the worst anime to ever grace the anime industry with its' presence.
babies first grim dark series.
there is nothing original about this series, its the the bottom tier of anime.
I'm going to be honest and tell you what I would rate this piece of shit on a scale of 1-10, it gets 4, shitty costumes shitty characters cliche plot, predictable ending.
the worst part about this series is the fan base, comprised of shaftfags and low powerlevels.
Do you like eating shit? did you answer no? then why do you watch Madoka? it shits in your mouth and expects you to like it, how can you sit there and take that? are you some kid of masochist? I feel sorry for anyone who thinks madoka is the top tier end of anime, you clearly haven't seen good anime.

>good

Ok, I agree with you. A little.

>People replying to copypasta

honestly, it was a good show. /a/ just hates it because other people outside of its secret club like it. remember when it was airing, and everybody was obsessing over it?

I'd give it 4/10 max

Reminds me when TTGL came out and everyone thought it was an original masterpiece. Difference is TTGL knew it wasn't, Madoka thinks it is.

It was average. Average was all it was and ever will be.

>>52927145
>getting mad over some japanese cartoon.

stay golden /a/

>>52927158

>summer

>hurr SHAFT. Best anime this season ^_^

ITT: 2 people

The samefag and I.

Now that I'm leave it'll be just 1 person.

>copypasta

This was in the OP, right? I never saw Homura helping Madoka with her aim in the show.

I think Madoka is actually a pretty good anime, on the level of Elfen Lied and Deadman Wonderland.

>>52927153

I'll reply as always:

yeah, good. Ok.

>>52927089
>I wish for a fish.

>>52927241

>Comparing Madoka to a masterpiece like Elfen Lied

Nigga u just went full retard

babies first grim dark series.
there is nothing original about this series, its the the bottom tier of anime.
I'm going to be honest and tell you what I would rate this piece of shit on a scale of 1-10, it gets 4, shitty costumes shitty characters cliche plot, predictable ending.
the worst part about this series is the fan base, comprised of shaftfags and low powerlevels.
Do you like eating shit? did you answer no? then why do you watch Madoka? it shits in your mouth and expects you to like it, how can you sit there and take that? are you some kid of masochist? I feel sorry for anyone who thinks madoka is the top tier end of anime, you clearly haven't seen good anime.
if you watched Madoka and thought it was the most amazing anime you'd ever seen then you don't belong in /a/, take your shit to gaia.

>>52927232
Nope, just fanart from long before anybody really knew what was going to happen

It's good. Overrated but good. So far, it'll most likely be Anime of the Year, which is disappointing.

I honestly think Nichijou is the most well made anime so far, but opinions, and the genre gets a lot of hate.

Over rated and glorious.

>>52927242

>FMA
>Death Note

So much true.

The build up and pay-off is great, the technical side is meh and the characters are decent, gorier stuff we put a lot of people off.

Don't agree that it is a baby's first anime though, bit too much on the head-fuck side of things.

Good? Yes, great? sure why not.
Best? has to be a sort of all things to all wo/men.

Madoka is the best anime ever.

/thread

>>52927089
No

In a nutshell, Puella Magi Madoka Magica is to the magical-girl genre as Neon Genesis Evangelion is to the mecha genre. To put it bluntly, it's a massive Deconstruction. If you liked Madoka a great deal, there's a chance you'll tear your hair out in frustration at trying to watch a bog-standard magical-girl show, like one of the Precures or Mermaid Melody.

I don't think I'd have shown Madoka to a babby. I don't think I'd show it to anyone who wants to get into anime either.

And over-rated is such a weasel word, it's meaningless unless you'll be precise about the ratings used.

>>52927242
saved

The fact that Madoka managed to create somebody who has spent the last few hours doing nothing else except constantly manually spamming and shitposting is a testament to just how much of an impact the show has had.

Madoka: DARKNESS that rivals Naruto

>>52927089
>>52927284
funny 2/10

>>52927431
Or how overblown the praise is...

Uh how and when is this shitty show violent?

Madoka is the worst anime to ever grace the anime industry with its' presence.
babies first grim dark series.
there is nothing original about this series, its the the bottom tier of anime.
I'm going to be honest and tell you what I would rate this piece of shit on a scale of 1-10, it gets 4, shitty costumes shitty characters cliche plot, predictable ending.
the worst part about this series is the fan base, comprised of shaftfags and low powerlevels.
Do you like eating shit? did you answer no? then why do you watch Madoka? it shits in your mouth and expects you to like it, how can you sit there and take that? are you some kid of masochist? I feel sorry for anyone who thinks madoka is the top tier end of anime, you clearly haven't seen good anime.
it's shit, and it takes shits, in and around your mouth, and you faggots like it.
disgusting.

>Babby's First
>cute magical girls in a seinen
0/10 You'd probably say Lucky Star is entry level, too.

>over-rated
If you're rating things on a 1-10 scale, and never actually give out 10's, the scale is broken.

Replying despite obvious trolling because haters gonna hate.

>>52927582
You're only perpetuating it.

madoka is my favorite show.

tell me, from an objective standpoint, why i shouldn't like it.

all subjective points will be discarded.

I only watched Madoka three days ago, and I can honestly say that I loved each minute of it. I love most animu that /a/ hates, because /a/ hates good animu. If it gets a fanbase, if even a single soul that's not a part of /a/ shows interest, /a/ disregards it as shit.


Madoka had an impression on everyone that watched it, though. It had a plethora of emotions attached to each episode. You guys say it was predictable to the end? The Puella Magi Wiki would disagree with you, since it still has all of /a/'s speculation throughout the series.

In the end, its greatest strength is what gave it such hatred. It was good, so people enjoyed it. People enjoyed it, so it spread outside of /a/. It spread outside of /a/, so now /a/ hates it. /a/ is like the jilted ex seeking revenge.

SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT MADOKA ALREADY!!!!
SOME PEOPLE LIKE IT SOME PEOPLE DON'T!!!
I don't mind if people want to talk about a series, just keep it in one fucking thread ok?
And all you trolling them shut the fuck up, they'll just make a new thread.
Seriously when you see like 6 fucking threads in 2 hours on the same anime something is wrong.
Especially considering said anime ended months ago.
Keep it in one thread.
If that gets trolled, ignore it.
Stay in the thread.

>>52927684
and now you know why I started spamming. these cunts are as bad as the bleach fags yesterday.

Madoka is the worst anime to ever grace the anime industry with its' presence.
babies first grim dark series.
there is nothing original about this series, its the the bottom tier of anime.
I'm going to be honest and tell you what I would rate this piece of shit on a scale of 1-10, it gets 4, shitty costumes shitty characters cliche plot, predictable ending.
the worst part about this series is the fan base, comprised of shaftfags and low powerlevels.
Do you like eating shit? did you answer no? then why do you watch Madoka? it shits in your mouth and expects you to like it, how can you sit there and take that? are you some kid of masochist? I feel sorry for anyone who thinks madoka is the top tier end of anime, you clearly haven't seen good anime.

>>52927684
>Seriously when you see like 6 fucking threads in 2 hours on the same anime something is wrong.
Holy shit, you're new as fuck.

>>52927684
It's the trolls that are making new threads.
Daytime /a/ is shit.

>>52927187
I consider both a masterpiece, they are just the kind of shows that generate a lot of fans but also hate and backlash

refer to the /a/ hipster pattern pic

>>52927714
>and now you know why I started spamming. these cunts are as bad as the bleach fags yesterday.
Pretending YOU aren't the CANCER doing the SPAMMING.

I only watched Elfen Lied three days ago, and I can honestly say that I loved each minute of it. I love most animu that /a/ hates, because /a/ hates good animu. If it gets a fanbase, if even a single soul that's not a part of /a/ shows interest, /a/ disregards it as shit.


Elfen Lied had an impression on everyone that watched it, though. It had a plethora of emotions attached to each episode. You guys say it was predictable to the end? The Fanbase would disagree with you, since it still has all of /a/'s speculation throughout the series.

In the end, its greatest strength is what gave it such hatred. It was good, so people enjoyed it. People enjoyed it, so it spread outside of /a/. It spread outside of /a/, so now /a/ hates it. /a/ is like the jilted ex seeking revenge.

>>52927627

>/a/
>jilted ex

more like deranged 40 year old pedophile who is now trying to kill the beautiful girl who he stalked for 5 months after he found out that she liked guys who weren't creepers.

>>52927759
I didn't start until I had to hide 6 fucking threads.

>>52927759
That's how cancer spreads, isn't it?

>>52927788
>>52927810


>claims to hate threads
>spams them so they remain on the front page

you funny guy.

>>52927849
You're the one bumping this shit faggot not us.

Madoka is the worst anime to ever grace the anime industry with its' presence.
babies first grim dark series.
there is nothing original about this series, its the the bottom tier of anime.
I'm going to be honest and tell you what I would rate this piece of shit on a scale of 1-10, it gets 4, shitty costumes shitty characters cliche plot, predictable ending.
the worst part about this series is the fan base, comprised of shaftfags and low powerlevels.
Do you like eating shit? did you answer no? then why do you watch Madoka? it shits in your mouth and expects you to like it, how can you sit there and take that? are you some kid of masochist? I feel sorry for anyone who thinks madoka is the top tier end of anime, you clearly haven't seen good anime.

Tell you what, most new animefag can't even stand Shaft's animation, and you still insist using that "babby's first anime"?

>>52927788
>I had to hide 6 fucking threads.
Cry me a river. Don't like /a/ ? GTFO. There is plenty of other boards.
Also the troll will get bored sooner or later and return to licking his anus or whatever he does when not spamming /a/.

>>52927886
I don't sage, because, if anything, your own embarrassing idiocy and hypocrisy deserves to be in full view of everyone.

>>>52927886
>us
Just because you can hear voices in your head you don't have to write 'us'.

>>52927089
yea its a solid 7.5/10.

>>52927886

i'm bumping this thread because i love madoka.

typical /a/ being hipstar faggots. Madoka is popular because it's a fantastic anime. deal with it

nope

>>52927605
Still better than having bored trolls ruining threads for the current season's shows.

>just keep it in one fucking thread ok?
Remember when that used to happen, and then people complained about the fact that things were kept in one thread? And the mods deleted the single threads?

If you don't like 6 threads about the same thing, go to a forum like animesuki.

>>52928106
that was because we had a constant general thread with huge copy pasta everyday for k-on.
it's the same thing. there isn't a difference. Madoka fans are just proving they're as bad as the k-on fans.

>>52928106
I love how the justification for that was something ridiculous like "enforcing board culture" or some nonsense. I'm all for clamping down on shitposting but their execution on the matter was laughable.

I love Madoka, and neither the fanbase nor the haters will ever change my mind. However, I kind of agree with the spammer here; this may be a bit too much. Also, just by looking at the last few posts you can see how poorly some "fans" type.

>>52928196
>somebody posts about banned generals
faggot replies:
>Madoka fans are just proving they're as bad as the k-on fans.
You are trying too hard pup.

>>52928314
Trolls trolling reverse trolls trolling troll troll troll

>>52928106
FYI after the general crackdown, and when the finale aired, the most lively discussions happened outside the generals, half of which were image dumps.

you know what the real irony is, here?

the only people who perpetuate madoka "shit posting" are the ones who rage at madoka.

honestly, if they just ignored us madoka fans, threads would come and go, and the "mention madoka and start a shit storm" thing wouldn't even exist. people wouldn't still be talking about it quite as much, because they wouldn't be trying to troll or whatever.

but hey, i love madoka. i enjoy seeing threads about it on the front page every day. so by all means, continue to respond with your hate and criticism. you only add fuel to the fire.

the easiest, best, and only way to stop trolling is not to respond at all.

but that's impossible for you, right /a/nons?

>>52927582
>If you're rating things on a 1-10 scale, and never actually give out 10's, the scale is broken.
No. If you're rating something, you don't move the scale to fit your experiences. Doing that makes numbering it at all meaningless.

so... some butthurt summer kids raging because /a/ likes an anime that i hate. Keep wasting your time.

>>52928373
>lively discussions
>image dumps
Stop that

>>52928314
>I kind of agree with the spammer here; this may be a bit too much.
You agree with the SPAMMER who does most of the shitposting that 6 threads of shitposting are too much ?

> Also, just by looking at the last few posts you can see how poorly some "fans" type.
>fans
I'd like to see your magical anon detector which can differentiate between normal posters, summer children, trolls, revers trolls and just plain stupid faggots.

>>52928414
Eh I meant the generals were mostly made up of image dumps.

>>52928373
After the general crackdown, discussion happened outside the generals? What a surprise.

In other news, after you empty a box, most of the contents will be outside the box.

Also, you're calling theads "image dumps" when they hardly ever hit the image limit before the bump limit.

>>52928444
Eh, they were half and half.

Which is to say, nothing really changed afterwards.

>>52928466

image dumps?

on an image board?

holy fucking shit. someone needs to put a stop to this.

we should only be allowed to post lengthy, verbose messages with no pictures. i think that's what 4chan was really created to be in the first place, right?

>>52928378
"The only winning move to win is not to play"
but anon is too dumb/ragefilled for that.

>>52928571

correct.

thus, 4chan in its current state.

we look down on posting lots of images, we worship those who would throw off anonymity for tripcodes and an internet identity, and our biggest threads are not those with the most images, but with the most flaming and trolling.

moot, please destroy this website and start over.

>>52928559
Indeed. This board is for paragraph-length or longer text posts, and /anime/ is for linking to images hosted elsewhere.

In the odd case that one wishes to post both an image and text in conjunction, such as when discussing an element in a screenshot, the text should be posted on /a/ with a link to a /anime/ post that contains a link to an image on mediafire, which the user can then download.

>>52928559
protip: /a/ isn't /c/ or /u/. There are boards made for image dumping. /a/ is for discussion.

>>52928559
I seem to recall that very old futaba code didn't have the option to reply with an image, only to start a thread with one. I might be wrong about that though.

>>52928733
Not that it matters, the initial premise (that the generals were image dumps) was faulty anyway.

>>52928733
>>52928760


>>>/anime/

really, though. if you want to have discussions without the fear of images, go to the board that was made for, you said it, discussions without the fear of images.

also, /a/ is for general anime and manga image posting and such

/c/ and /u/ are just more specialized boards. they aren't image dump boards in nature.

but hey, disagree with me all you want. it doesn't really matter. /a/ is still going to be full of flaming, trolling, and spamming in the next 5 minutes, as well as the 5 minutes after that. and so on and so forth.

>>52927089
I watched the series last week. I wanted to know what all the ruckus was about.

First few episodes = meh okay, some forced drama about Mami wishing to live, then all of a sudden "HOLY SHIT DID HER HEAD GOT BITTEN OFF" did not see that coming.

The rest of the show was okay, it certainly kept me intrigued. I expected the ending to be Madoka wishing everyone back alive to fight the powerful witch, and not her becoming a god.

>>52928923
don't like the way this place is then get out, there's plenty of other places on the internet to discuss anime.
I watched the mod 404 15 of parks threads for image spamming.

I always lean on /a/'s opinions because /a/ is always right and loves anime.

>>52929055

well done. i laughed.

i'll post an anime image because i'm going to start working against the problem that is /a/.

>>52928923
Image dumps tend to fall into two categories. Either they're used to prolong the life of a thread that no one wants to post in, but a person doesn't want to give up, or they're image dumps from the start, with next to no conversation because people don't have anything to say about a show, they're just lonely. The first is a bad practice, and the second doesn't belong here.

>>52928425
Yes, six threads of shitposting is too much. And I said "fans" with quotation marks because you can never really be sure, but look at these, for instance
>>52928059
>>52928559
>>52927158

>>52927701
>>52927866
>>52927579
>>52927371
>>52927089
>5 Gorespammer threads out
>>52925354
>Gorespammer spammed and trolled in here

>>52925644
>Gorespammer trolled in here

>>52929131
I don't really see what the issue with the former is. I mean, they'd just be posting "bump" or something equally worthless instead if they couldn't, right? At least I'm getting something nice to look at out of it

But I do agree after a certain point when it's clear no one wants to bother it becomes rather pointless and they ought to give up.

>>52929055

>not dyson fan

Son...

>>52929131

hm. i'm going to have to disagree with you on that one, anon. the majority of image dumps that i see have some semblance of a discussion going on within them.

also, like i said before, if what you want is just pure discussion, go to >>>/anime/


hint: you won't, because /a/ doesn't want discussion. it wants to troll, flame, mock, etc.

>>52929279
And people get angry with me for spamming the threads.
FUCK YOU /a/.

>>52929380
Because you're an idiot doing exactly what the spammer wants you to do.

Madoka is the best anime this year hands down. There has been nothing else that has made an impact in 2011.

>>52929276

check your grammar and punctuation when you post, anon.

i am assuming that you are trying to insult me because of my shitty posting style.

fire away. i assure you that i won't care at all.

>>52929481
Fuck off madoshit shipper.

>>52929280
If no one is posting in a thread, it can just die. If you want an ever present topic, head to a forum. If you can't find something you want that isn't on the front page, look for it.
>>52929347
Now discount the circlejerking and limit it to on topic discussion. Most "discussion" is people talking about how wonderful taste each other have because they enjoy the same things.

>>52929481
That's not true.

Fractale also made a huge impact, but showing us all just how terrible something can be.

>>52929481
>>52929502
>Same troll/hater