And some random things that popped up yesterday.

I found this one a while back, it is horribly worded.

Seeing what good will come of it - /m/ thread at
>>>/m/4981286 .

>>34377490
"Creatures blocking or blocked by CARDNAME get +1/+1." Don't bother with Bushido, it's just inefficient. If you want to make it fit a flavor...it'd be hard to make it actually work because of Bushido's trigger timing.

Bumping.

No interest, /a/?

Last bump or two before letting it fade.

>>34378063
Working on figuring out how to use this editor...

>>34377314

I was the OP From yesterday, I'll be dumping my completed cards, if you can give them a once over Legacy, and maybe a balance check for formats other than Standard (I got bashed because Kazumi is OP in legacy format)

>>34378435

>>34378465

>>34378481

>>34378495

>>34378521

>>34378539

Death Note - 4
Legendary Artifact
T: Destroy target creature. That creature's controller gains control of Death Note.
"Just according to keikkaku"

>>34378554

>>34377828

She's going to be in 3rd expansion of Zendikar, guarantee it.

>>34378563

Get me a good picture of just a death note on a dark background.

>>34378577

>>34378614

>>34378640

I made several wording and change suggestions in the last thread that I'd recommend looking at, since they pretty much still stand:

http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/a/thread/34330924

>>34378481
Tbqh, I personally (though biased) prefer the mono-black Evangeline.

>>34378521
Not sure if it's strong (it probably is very in legacy/vintage), but it confusing and definitely is templated wrong. Not sure what to make of it.

>>34378495
If this thing survives a turn, you should win since it'll just be spitting out ninjas. Crazy strong, but expensive (though it's in green). I'd definitely run it as a finisher. Second ability should read "COST: Exile target permanent you control until the beginning of your next upkeep."

>>34378664

That is it for completed Negima cards, i'll post more when i finish them.

Here are some more i completed over the passe 2 days.

>>34378721
Ridiculously strong if you can discard it early, by the way. I don't really remember Battle Angel Alita well enough to make suggestion for changes.

>>34378714

I was told that in legacy (That is what max CMC of 3 right?) she his broken in half, something about tutoring any card you wanted into your hand.

>>34378799

I could drop her P/T a bit maybe down to 5/6 might be a bit better.

>>34378721

>>34378815
In legacy and in vintage, if you combine her with card draw you end up with a great chance (since most cards have CMC between 0 and 3) of getting:

Hit a land and you pick up any 0-cost, including the land of your choice or, for vintage, a lotus or any of the moxen. 1 - 3 are pretty self-explanatory.

>>34378865

>>34378911

>>34378961

>>34378982

>>34379007

>>34379027

>>34379058

No Dark Schneider?
I am disappoint

>>34379303

Make it yourself. It's isn't terribly hard.


One of the favorites from the last thread.

>>34379424

Still wordy but less OP i think.

Oh, and for the record - "Fading N" has been obsoleted, it's now "Vanishing K" where K = N+1. So Fading 2 is now Vanishing 3. Vanishing is a bit easier to understand (sac when last counter is removed rather than when you can't remove a counter).

>>34379551

Alright, i'll update them, i just used fading because i remember it from when i played a lot.

Do I win the overpowered card of the century award?

>>34379603
>doesn't know about Contract from below
>thinks lotus is better than ancestral recall
no.

>>34379603
>>34379674

Lotus isn't necessarily the most overpowered card because it's a one-shot deal and what makes it so ridiculous is the amount of things that it works with. Contract From Below, though, is the most overpowered card in the game. Though, if you're REALLY good, perhaps Chaos Confetti could get that.

>>34379517

Posting reworded and rebalanced card for review.

>>34379995

>>34380020

>>34379995

I'm not sure that really makes sense. Evangeline doesn't have the ability to make people disappear just by doing something big, and she's not immune to magic. Just really strong.

Second ability is also a pain in the ass to work with, not sure how to template it off the top of my head.

>>34380048

>>34380079

She doesn't freeze people solid in giant Blocks of ice every time she shows up?

>>34379995
The exile ability should read "Whenever you play a spell with converted mana cost 6 or more, exile target creature and put three time counters on it. If it doesn't have suspend, it gains suspend."

>>34380165

Alright reworking

>>34380180

Hopefully her final version.

I took your protection scheme Legacy, since you are right she isn't immune to spell (Wouldn't be stuck in Shcool if she was)

>>34380412
Well, the details are up to you. I figured it made more sense to have her just not affected by weak things.

Constructs still need to have a color declared.


For anyone following this - what series should be next after Negima! ?

>>34380541

Artifacts have a color?

>>34380574
Then say "colorless". Future Sight / Alara made it so you could have colored artifacts (Sarcomite Myr iirc in FS, then the Esper stuff in Alara).

Chao should be red, not blue.

>>34380541

I had planned on getting into some of the mainstream Battle Shonen since they have a pretty good cast of characters abilities and spells to work off of.

>>34378911
I would like to point out that your keyword insanity doesn't work under current magic rules. Ignoring that "summoner" is a meaningless term, a creature cannot attack its controller.

Something similar that would get the point across would be to have the creature with insanity tap and deal damage equal to its power to its controller.

Also, a card cannot be "enchanted" by an ability. That term only applies to auras. You also need to provide timing for when ilya's ability triggers. Something like "during your upkeep, target creature gains insanity" would be correct templating.

>>34380699

Ummmmm why? She is Logic and Technology based, red is the oppisite.

>>34380574
They can. Esper is all artifacts pretty much, White, Blue, and Black colors.

>>34380765

Color is based on where abilities fall on the color pie, not flavor.

The abilities of the one in this thread sure aren't Blue, though I think I'd call it more White than Red.

>>34380761

Yeah i should have reworded it to

"At the beginning of you Upkeep place an Insanity counter on target creature, any time a creature with an insanity counter on it would deal damage, deal that damage instead to its controller then remove an Insanity counter from that creature."

I want my Rozen Maiden cards!

>>34380869


Seems blue to me.

>>34380869
See: Unstable Mutation

It's fine for it to be in blue. And no, colors -are- from flavor. It's just that characters tend to get in-color abilities.

>>34380079
perhaps it would work if her ability was "Whenever you cast a spell with converted mana cost {6} or greater, exile target creature. It gains suspend 3."

Chao uses fire based magic.

>>34380904

It's a big creature. That's White or Green; not Red, as has more Toughness than Attack.

It has Flying. That's White or Blue.

Damage protection, that's White.

The activated ability is either White, Red, or Black.

>>34380904
Accurate model for voting in the UK election

>>34381002
All the colors get big creatures, though they're most common in green and least common in white.

Flying is white/blue unless for a specific flavor (demons / dragons).

Damage prevention moves into blue just fine (the Azorius had it).

The ability is hard to place. As I mentioned earlier, it does work in blue - unstable mutation got timeshifted.

>>34380967
The template on the card is taken directly from delay. And an rfg'd card with suspend is useless unless there are time counters on it.

>>34381095

This, and if her ability looks Black, that is because it it Dark Magic.

Aizen plz, anyone?

>>34381186

Get me a picture of just him in Color, may or may not have a background depending on if Kubo drew it or not.

>>34381159
Her ability looks blue because damage prevention, flying, and unstable mutation. Though honestly u/w/b or just u/w would probably be a better color combination.

>>34381275

Talking about the final one, which is very Black, but then Genetic Magia Erebea is black so.....

Glasses

>>34380737

Dispite my Desire to finish the whole A-2 class tonight, i feel we should move into fresh water, I'll try making cards for Luffy/Naruto/Ichigo/Gon/Killua

and we'll take it from there.

>>34381378


on it.

>>34381466

If you could find this in Color it would be the best.

>>34381378
Not bad, but a background would help a lot since plain white looks weird in the image box. Any idea what to use for the abilities?

>>34381498
Something Shield Dancer-ish popped into my head as I said that.

Let's see...

Set keywords:
Pactio <cost> (When CARDNAME comes into play, you may pay <cost> and choose another creature that you control. If you do, this card comes into play pacted with that creature.)

Magister <param1> (Creatures pacted with this card gain +<param1>/+<param1>.)

Prodigal Magician 2U
Creature - Wizard
T: Deal one damage to target creature or player.
When five or more creatures are pacted with Prodigal Magicial, flip it.
1/2

Negi Springfield
Flying, Trample
Negi Springfield has Magister X, where X is the number of creatures pacted with it.
U,T: Negi Springfield deals 1 damage to target creature or player for each creature pacted with it.
6/4

I'd have placed it out of Blue, but I though the Prodigal Sorcerer reference was cute.

>>34381498

My current Plan is Flying First Strike

"Once a turn you may redirect any spells or damage targeting Aizen to another target.

>>34381567
Once per turn abilities aren't that common in MtG, unless you're handling it like the glasskites or Kira, Great Glass-Spinner. Also, drop flying - it's technically correct but doesn't really add much to the card and is generally awkward on humans/humanoids.

Whenever Aizen dies, the opponent has to sacrifice a creature.
Mana cost: ressurect Aizen
Something like that

>>34381667

I think it's just the wording that's awkward. Try

>The first time a spell or ability would target CARDNAME in a turn, you may pay blah. If you do, change the target of the spell or ability with a single target.

>>34381855
Or, just use Quicksilver Dragon's ability with "Activate this ability only once per turn." added to it.

>>34381855

Changing it to

1B: Redirect all combat damage dealt to Aizen this turn to target creature.
2BB: Aizen gains Shroud until end of turn.

Okay, here's my first try at this. Hope these aren't too terrible/terribly overpowered/terribly templated.

>>34382018


Could use a better pitcture if anyone has one, neither of these look good.

>>34382150
Main thing I noticed is that "does" should be "deals"

>>34382154
>>34382018


How is This?

>>34382295

Picture's better than the others.

He should be U/B
Drop a line down before the start, spaces better.
Make the first ability cost UB and the second cost 2UB.
Dunno, he feels a bit awkward but it's not that bad.

Well, I'll be doing work for a bit. If someone drops me a list of characters with half-decent pictures I'll see about whipping up and posting cards when I take breaks.

34382295
Very nice,but i imagined him white for some reason

>>34382422

See

>>34380904

>>34382422

That's what it was!
Replace the B with W in my previous post.

>>34382418

I'll be working on the Main Stream Shonen cards, i'll need you to balance check them when i finish them and post.

>>34382472

Legacy Aizen is not white, at all.

>>34382512

Why not? He believes in laying down laws and having everyone adhere to them, to the extreme. He's not quite the kind of power-hungry cutthroat bastard that black would have.

>>34382558

>>34380904

"Parasatism - Selfishness at the expense of others"

"Amorality - Selfishness above all else"

Both match Aizen perfectly.

>>34382618

Well, he's not a parasite in the typical sense. As I said earlier - he needs to be blue. White or Black is up to you, but I could see cases made for both. Remember that it's possible to have white villains.

>>34382689

I agree about Blue, but not white, so here is the fixed version

>>34382757
First strike is kind of unusual in blue/black, and is redundant with his ability. Drop it.

Change the cost to 4UB. Easier to look at.

I think I'm fine with it after that.

>>34382812
Needs some balancing.

4 mana for a 4/4 with first strike and a 0 cost +4/+4 begging to be abused.

dude alot of these cards rly suk. Do any of u actually play magic?

>>34382862

Well he needs something to tie into his not minor combat skills, that is why i had First Strike.

He needs something maybe Bushido.

anyone make any darker than black cards?

Redirecting combat damage is a white ability.

>>34382911
Durr I forgot power/toughness XD

>>34382867

She's a blocker. 4/4 may be a bit OP though, I agree.

>>34382920

How do you tap it for mana when it has no ability to?

>>34382962

>Legenary Land - Swamp

its a swamp.

>>34382962
It's a Swamp. Overpowered as hell, but mechanically there are no problems.

See: Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth and how it allows things like Maze of Ith to tap for mana.

>>34382911
>>34382943
Also gave her trample haste, she really should be red, but is just blue cause that what color her hair is.

>>34383032

Yeah i gave a suggestion to the person who made it last night to make it

2T: Sacrifice a Creature and put a spirit token on Tartarus.

and then the second ability.

>>34383046
Definitely doesn't make sense in blue.

Haste is red at any rarity
Destroying artifacts is red at any rarity
Trample is red mostly in uncommons and up
And none are blue in any possible way lol

>>34383046
>she really should be red, but is just blue cause that what color her hair is.
= Make her red.
Problem solv'd.

DESU

>>34383180
That ain't no Vengevine.

>>34382757


here is the first of my Main Stream Battle Shonen, I need suggestions for Artifacts/Lands/Enchantments/Instants/Sorceries.

>>34383154
If it's red her P/T should go up to 5/5. Legendary plus cost = P/T is not unheard in red; green and red creatures are be upper end in combat.

>>34383203
At least you saw what I did there, with Suiseiseki working with vines in the anime/manga and all.

>>34383180
>>34383203
Oh shit Suiseki is gonna be one helluva expensive card.

Shouldn't she be red/green though? I mean, DESU

READ SOME ACTUAL CARDS BEFORE MAKING THESE

you wording is way off

Guys it may look fun to just post super OP cards, but to us who play the game it just looks stupid, we value a balanced card over a HERP DURR SUPER GODLY CARD!

>>34383313
>>34383341

This. You niggers are fucking horrible. These cards are an eyesore.

Screwed up one minor detail, sorry.

>>34379146
Let's try that again

I've done what I can with templating, but it really takes some time to learn.

The Persona ones aren't atrocious, though they're a bit off. Overpowered, though - I'm sure MC would see play in a ridiculous combo somewhere, and Adachi is just strong. Plus his first ability makes no sense.

>>34383341

Hurr durr Baneslayer Angel

>>34383419

Yeah no.

>>34383491

This one is pretty damn good.

>>34383341
>>34383313
>>34383366
>NO FUN ALLOWED HERP DERP
Sure, samefag.

>>34383518

Get a new Same fag Detector, Trying to balance a card to make it so it is playable is half the fun.

>>34383470
While incredibly powerful, not impossible to play around. Some of the cards posted here are too "lol I play this and win" Chuck Norris level stuff.

>>34383341
>>34383313
>>34383366
Unglued and Unhinged would like to talk to you.

>>34383518

You'd best be joking nigger. I enjoy making gayass anime magic cards as much as the next fag, but these just suck ass.

Fixed / Nerfed Tao. Still adorable.

>>34383313
Even if samefagging, half-decent point. Guys?

>>34383491
I like it. Even if it would have been crazy in Kamigawa limited.

>>34383215
Ungodly broken with a sac outlet. Persist, if anything.

Hmmmmm Trying to template Luffy.....

He has Rampage 2 Trample.....

Needs something else, I'm thinking

2 R/G R/G: Gains First Strike and +2/+0 until end of turn.

4 R/G R/G: Gains +4/+4 until end of Turn.

BEST CARD EVAR

Also, mandatory flashy bomb.

>>34383595
Shit happens. To an extent, it's obvious which are good and which suck.

Plain, but I like the in-joke here.

>>34383603

YOu are right, Changing ti to

"If this Creature would be put into the graveyard from play due to Direct or Combat Damage return it to play with a +1/+ counter."

It is ment to capture if he gets his ass kicked he comes back stronger.

>>34383674

Luffy seems mono-red to me.

>>34383702
>Dub quote

>>34383745
Ignore that, since you'd be putting it on pretty much everybody. Unfortunately. It's a very common trait.

>>34383796
>>34383761

No, Just Ichigo, no one else gets their chest blown out and comes back to life.

>>34383761
He is.

I made this card for fun, but now that I think about it, if you let your opponent get to the point where they can play this, you deserve to die so its not overpowered. TURN 1 WINS ARE TOO SLOW.

>>34383313
>>34383341
for reals, /a/. if ya don't gots the balance down, just change the picture, like so.

>>34383761

Going split G/R since half of Green is Natural instinct.

>>34383765

sub actually.

Instinct is red, though. Natural instinct is connection with nature, which isn't super-important for Luffy.

>>34383829
It would get cheated out somehow. Jhoira EDH?

>>34383835
That's the easy way out, though...

>>34383912

Fancy, but really weak unless you're playing against Voltron.

>>34383930

I'm using YOUR color Wheel Legacy that you left my yesterday.

He is 75% red 25% green.

>>34383419
decided to remake him

Made a few more... Hope they don't suck.

>>34384020

I know. But instinct is connection with nature. What Luffy has falls under Impulse.

There's no reason to clutter the card by adding an extra color like that.

>>34383829
this card already exists, its called time stretch... well not always you, but SOMEONE wins after one resolves

>>34383829
>>34383829
How about Turn Zero wins?

>>34384030
obligitory

>>34384102
Not since Flash was restricted. Good luck with that god hand :s

>>34384126
Should be just on attacking, and should only hit other creatures (so it's not suicide).

Though, to be fair, doesn't the angel arm not actually kill people? I remember it wiping out the city but leaving everyone alive...or was it the other way around.

>>34384071

Because you hate my Fun Legacy.

>>34384030
Should be -Plant Gunman-

Otherwise, great.

>>34384174

But then everyone starved to death and died anyway.

He also blew Knives in half with it.

>>34384174
if you fire that thing, even in defense, it's still gonna kill a lot of people

>>34384200

Try Angel Nomad, since Gunman and Plant don't go together.

>>34384208
>>34384210

Well, yeah. Thing is, it doesn't make sense for it to be dealing damage if it doesn't actually directly hurt people.
Maybe I'm just overthinking it...and "destroy all lands" would be bull.

>>34384134
>>34384030
(T) Vash the Stampede deals 5 damage to target creature.

If a creature dealt damage by Vash the Stampede would be destroyed, regenerate it instead.

>>34384200
better?

>>34384275
I was gonna give it worldslayer's effect, only exile instead of destroy

Chose green/red because leaf village/fire country.

>>34384227
Why not?

Creature type is now Species/Class

>>34384351

Plant in Magic = Tree

There is no Gunman Class

So Plant Gunman = lolwut?

>>34384343
>land that gives ninjitsu

>>34384338
Been done, and been done better

>>34384376

yeah no those suck ass. not that the other one is any better.

>>34384371
Has Plant already been used?

Also, just because there hasn't been Gunman yet doesn't mean there won't be. As long as it isn't already used, it should be fine.

>>34384376

I know I'm guilty of it too, but still...
So many of these cards are so complicated. Blah.

>>34384396
They're rough, but they have some good ideas in 'em. The servent/Master mechanic needs to be hammered out but I think it could work.

And it's still better then the first one, as rough as it is.

>>34384412
Yeah, plant's been used.

Hmm. -Gunman- might just be the best bet then.

for angel arm maybe 'tap 2 opponet lands or one opposing creature. they can't be untapped untill your next turn.'?

>>34384396
Got suggestions on how to improve them?
While I don't have the files for them (I think those are pretty old, not sure who made them), they shouldn't be hard to rebuild.

>>34384546

Broken as Sin.

>>34384594
>>34384546
I'd go as far to add that if you do not win the game at the end of your turn you lose.

>>34384559
Can you send me that pic? I want to whip up something of my own. Also, try not to mix and match hybrid mana - it looks kind of ugly.

>>34384546
See
>>34384594

>>34384648
Way too good lategame. Without haste it'd be more tolerable, even then it should have 1 converted to R.

>>34384520

I'm a no fun stickler remember?

I tried to make a FSN set once but it just didn't work out due to restrictions I put on myself when making cards. I wanted it to be as true as possible to source material without inventing keywords or new mechanics.

So basically, I wanted the servant cards to
a.) Require a Master to be in play, and not just any Master to any Servant. Then there was the whole issue of maybe should I give Fading somehow to those Servants who can exist without a Master but only after they lose a Master etc?
b.) Require a mana cost every upkeep, in keeping with source material. Every Master card would then have a different amount of Mana somehow to pay for this.
c.) The whole issue of Command Spells and Noble Phantasms, the limited availability and use of them.

Basically I eventually figured out it would take a whole load of new keywords and mechanics or a wall of text, neither of which I was keen on doing.

>>34384692

>>34384648

here, i'd rather downgrade double strike to first strike if that's the case, and add 1 toughness.

One thing I'm noticing is that First Strike is being used way too much. First strike means that you're unusually skilled in combat and can take down opponents without ever being touched by them - Casshern is a great example of this. Note that this isn't dodging, it's simply being faster and more effective. It's a very white and red ability, and isn't all that common. Also, remember that, in general, first strike creatures have less toughness than they would otherwise. Similarly, creatures with lots of toughness rarely have first strike.

>>34384692
http://www.gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=440667

for command spells couldn't you just use 'When this character's Servant is in play, select and activate one of these effects'?

Tried making a blue Jotaro. I think I got the Stand ability down, maybe I should make the token legendary?

>>34384191


Next on my List is Gon, though i doubt i'll find a good picture for him

>>34384520
Not the same anon, but I feel all masters may fare better as Planeswalker cards due to their complexity.

For example Shirou could be something like this.

+2 Search your library for an equipment card, reveal it, and put it in your hand
-3 Search your library for a creature card named "Saber/Arturia" and put it into play. It gains haste.
-8 Search your library for any number of equipment cards and put them onto the battlefield. You may attach all equipment in the battlefield to target creature.

Loyalty 4

>>34384845
Zoro should be red / green, not black / green.

>>34384800
Oh god that would be aggravating to play against.

>>34384873
Key is interesting, if very, very strong. Thanks for the pic.

>>34384889

I had the command spell as an enchantment with activated abilities that you could play as an instant. everytime you used it, you put a depletion counter on the servant, 3 counters, you sack the servant etc. But in the end, with all the other stuff i was tying to fit in, like i said too much text or need to invent new mechanics/keywords. it went something like, remove a servant from combat, or call a servant from your hand or use a noble phantasm which in of itself was a different card. the things the command spells were used for.

>>34384956
Oops. Replace any "put it into play" with "put onto the battlefield" and Shirou's cost would be 2WW.

>>34384906
Hate to say it, but that card...isn't very good.
You can take damage during timestop, you just don't feel it until the end. As worded, you can take infinite turns and kill with lifeloss. Star Platinum isn't indestructible. Jotaro can still take damage.

>>34384710
Isn't b) solved by Cumulative upkeep?

Cumulative upkeep—Do something. (At the beginning of your upkeep, put an age counter on this permanent, then sacrifice it unless you pay its Do something for each age counter on it.)

the power of friendship is strong indeed

>>34384956

K see this is the shit that makes me nerdrage. It's obvious that people don't fucking understand the nature or the game or the source material. It doesn't make sense to me to make them a planeswalker or whatever simply because its easier. It doesn't fit the definition of either a planeswalker or a master. The only character I could see being a planeswalker would be the unknown old man who mastered that sorcery and came to Tohsaka's defense in the end of HF route. It's like people who make Haruhi a planeswalker. She isn't aware of her abilites so no. Servants aren't planeswalkers either because although they come from different times and realities, they can't do it at will and are more yanked out. Plus they are combat creatures.

>>34380412
But she has regeneratation and is nearly invulnerable to all damage, aside from the fact that she created ME.

>>34385168

Thought of that but no. Didn't work out. These 3 are just the main mechanics too, when you work in abilites like trample or anything else you might want them to have specific to your character, then you really get cramped text.

>>34385204

Remove last one, Add the Damage prevention to the first abilities and make the Blue Black or Red, he isn't Blue

Don't know much about magic or how useful this would be but I decided it had to be done.

Blah. People butchering those planeswalkers.

Planeswalkers are ALLIES who have the same powers as the player - the ability to move between dimensions freely and mastery of powerful magic. You pay mana to help them come to your aid and then ask them to do things - if you ask them to do easy things they get more loyal, if you ask them to do hard things they like you less. If their loyalty hits zero, they leave (and go to the graveyard in the card game). Planeswalkers are NEVER front-line fighters, and anyone who can or would attack is not a planeswalker.

>>34385178
No no, planeswalkers stopped being as powerful or dedicated to what you say as you think they are. They are more like powerful mages now, not reality warpers and jumpers like in the old days. Just look at Chandra or Garruk.

Which is why I feel a master is exactly like a planeswalker: A Mage with hax abilities. They play like spellshapers in a way.

Also Servants are obviously creatures d'oh...

>>34385320

Nope they still WALK PLANES.

>>34385301
>Planeswalkers are NEVER front-line fighters, and anyone who can or would attack is not a planeswalker.

But they can.
Gideon Jura
http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=192218

>>34385320

A planeswalker is a mage who can walk the planes. Since this is so hard to do (you need the spark and a way to have it awaken), it's no big deal for them to learn most magic since it comes naturally. Planeswalker cards are rare allies, and by nature they're wanderers who want nothing to do with the events going on.

>>34385301
so I guess hayate would've made a better walker, still like my nanoha though

Is this mana cost too cheap for her stats?

>>34385390
As represented by the fact that he turns into a creature. Even though people like Sarkhan or Garruk would still probably rock shit in straight combat, Gideon is the only one actually capable of bringing himself straight to attack. This is notable - anyone who would straight-up fight should generally not be a planeswalker.

>>34380412
>>34379995
>>34378714
>>34378481
What you all seem to forget that Eva is basically the gamebreaker of the Negivers, with all her abillitys and powers, that is why the plotline restricts her.
She would pe rather OP, but maybe as a two sided card Sealed Eva, Eva Magia Nosferatu or something like this with a hellish hard to achive flip.

>>34385423
She's fine. Give her Vigilance, actually.

>>34385423

5 mana for a vanilla 4/5 is too weak for a legendary, you should add some abilities at least.

>>34385425
>Gideon Jura becomes a 6/6 Human Soldier creature that's still a planeswalker.
>that's still a planeswalker

Lol. I mean these have only existed for so long, and you are already debatting from a wrong point of view.

Also Shirou IS a reality warper/walker with UBW.

>>34385436

No, it is called Balance and i've tried to achieve that, if you want to make LOLOP cards go make your own thread.

>>34385475
Um...of course he's still a planeswalker. It's not like putting on armor, picking up a sword, and charging into battle makes the spark disappear. It's just that planeswalkers generally aren't combat-based and are almost always allies: he's the only one so far that's willing to actually get in and fight for you rather than throw spells your way.

>>34385475

No, being able to move to a single plane and only that plane for a limited amount of time a Planeswalker does not make.

>>34385178
I agree with you almost 100% except on the fact that Haruhi shouldn't be one.

Just because she isn't aware of her powers doesn't mean that she isn't using them constantly. She's a perfect fit for one, considering her abilities.

>>34385449
Not familiar with that. What does Vigilance do?

>>34385103
Hey, you think this is any better. I know Jotaro doesn't have any protection against creature removal, and I think he'll die pretty easily if they target either the Stand or him. Then again, if they're running a classic Blue counter deck I think they should be able to deal with it.
The timestop thing is tricky. I'm trying not to make it broken.

Any HxH people i her who can give me some Help with Gon/Killua? their abilities are hard as fuck to template and i'm not sure on colors at all.

THinking GOn is Green Red and Killua is Blue/ Something.

>>34385623
Attacking doesn't cause CARDNAME to tap.

>>34385500
i can nderstand balancing as i played mgic, yugioh, pokemon, behind and some other ard games, thouh you distanced her too far from her abillitys reffering too her sealed form and unsealed form, which is why i meant you should instead make her a two sided card or how hey are called and mak it hard to change her into the unsealed form

>>34385628
shit, forgot image.

Guys! I love this thread. Could we try for another tomorrow or the next day? I'd love to help out! We could try a Raildex theme! The Negima one was great!

If I may, though, could I suggest a few things? Like, less legendary creatures (eventhough they may be to us), more Plainswalkers, and artifacts/spells/etc. I normally play YuGiOh, so you guys can teach me a bit more about MTG. It's been a long time since I've actually played. Haha.

>>34385645
Huh. Funny that it's the perfect counter to the one I just posted right after it.

>>34385694

The problem with Anime is Items and Spells are down played and Character up played so it is hard to make those.

>>34385694
The problem is that most of these are individual people, meaning that they'd be legendary. It's kind of a shame, but it's what happens - cards with names are generally legends.

But yeah, successful thread is successful. I'll try to keep running these and helping out, since people need the design help and it's an interesting pastime.

>>34385588
I think Kyon is a better fit for Planeswalker, since he is a Slider.

I feel the discussion of Planeswalking and how it has evolved from being impossible to represent in the game to actually being cards by depowering the concept of planeswalking is pointless in Time Spiral. My main point is that in general planeswalker cards have been depicted as powerful wizards and mages since their creation, which masters fit completely. Their traveling through different dimensions isn't acknowledged in the game, in fact it is completely ignored besides their "unkillability".

Wanted to make a colorless destroy fucking everything spell that had a lot of [x]'s in it.

>>34385769
Is that right? Well, I did not know. Neat! Like I said, I'll have to read a bit and I'd love to help sometime! These are very cool, I think.

>>34385783
>by depowering the concept of planeswalking in Time Spiral is pointless

Whoops that's what I wanted to say

>>34385783
The mages in Nasuverse aren't even THAT powerful.

Maybe the 7 sorceress, but there's no way Shirou and Rin should be Plansewalkers.

>>34385746
Ah. Well, if any items/spells/whatever stand out, I may make those. Like, for Red, a Master Ball -Permanent Control of ........ See?

>>34385877

See

>>34379027

>>34385898
Oh, I get it! Yeah! I can do that. No problem. I'll chime in tomorrow when/if I see this thread. Goodnight till then, /a/. Keep at it!

And here's another 4. Interestingly enough, little to no decent fan art of Ronove/Virgilia exists.

To be fair, though, in MtG spells aren't so much castings as actions. A particular event can count as something, while a particular trick is a fine instant to mess with combat. Even something standard like "uncontrollable rage" or "combat training" is totally functional.

The trick is finding the right ones. Also, mooks are tricky since anime doesn't focus much on them.

>>34385842
I guess if you start making cards for the whole Nasuverse it indeed wouldn't work. Was thinking of a FSN standalone actually.

ORT could be like the Eldrazi Lol.

>>34385170
Speaking of friendship...from the last thread.

I bet there's some way to exploit this one, maybe I should turn his stats down to something normal.

>>34384594
>>34384660
>>34384692
When I was making the card, I thought about several considerations. First, the card is expensive as fuck to play. Sure, you can combo into it, but that is the same with dragonstorm, and dragonstorm is a much better card IMO. The fact that it is only for one turn, and it targets the creature makes it very dangerous. If that one creature gets hit by a path or terror, it's all over, and the spell fizzles. Hell, a rogue fog ruins the alpha strike. Sure, it is damn powerful for an effect, but for the cost, I would not say that it is too bad. Maybe I should bump the cost to nine, though. That might be more reasonable.

>>34385983

Rivalry 2RR

Enchantment Aura

Enchanted Creature has

2: Put a Rivalry counter on target Creature, any time enchanted creature is blocking or blocked by a creature with a Rivalry counter it gets +2+2 until end of turn, only one counter can be in effect at a time.

>>34386162

A deck built around getting that in play would be RETARDED, you could make a Creature 30/30 with every ability in the game and unblockable, it is beyond stupid.

>>34386151
Lol Pandemonium.

>>34385877
good idea

>>34386226
Hmm, maybe it should include the cost, Pay all but one life. That would make it even riskier.

>>34386151
>>34386151

>>34386226
At that cost, there are tons of cards that do retarded things (like the previously mentioned Dragonstorm).

The card is weak to disruption (kill the creature through any means, prevent damage), I think it's at the right cost and specifications.

>>34386151

>>34386231
Wow. Yeah, turning down his stats.

>>34386379
so many things wrong with that I don't know where to begin

>>34386349

No, the only disruption for it is a Counter spell, and since it is blue you may have counters of your own to over write their counters.

Once it is played it is game over, period.

>>34386379
LOL

>>34386151
<---

>>34385974
I like the Siestas, mostly because I was thinking about making some cards based around Imperishable Night. They'd fit well with Reisen and Tewi.

>>34386423
Goes right back into the graveyard if you do that...

Pandemonium is the way to go.

Gon Done, for the HxH set i added a new keyword, Tactics.

>>34386423
Huh. I thought the wording prevented that from taking effect, as it would have to come into play, triggering his ability again.

>>34386456
the point is to have
>>34386380
>>34386314
either or both of those enchantments in play.

>>34386490
oohhhhhhhhh

>>34386490
Why? +30 life is already ridiculous, getting 30 more is just pointless.

>>34386422
True if it resolves, with both swords, fireshrieker, and the Kaldras it should be a joke to finish the opponent. But they can kill the creature in response to the spell, and since a shrouded creature would be untargetable...you've gotta have some vulnerability.

>>34386490
pandemonium/stalking vengeance work better

>>34386422
Well if you are a good player of course you can protect it. It still costs 8 mana.

There are so many ways to disrupt it:

To start with, any removal to the creature in response to the spell will do.
Second, most artifact removal will hinder the effect.
Third, any prevent all damage effect will make the card pointless.

Even a creature with first strike and death touch will do.

There is a lot of stuff that's "play and win" ie Insurrection (which even has the same converted cost!) that exists so I feel it's fair.

>>34386559
I'm a defensive player at heart. the environment I played in was big multiplayer matches.

>>34386559

Wispersilk Cloak?

>>34386659
In response. As in, they kill it before the spell goes off.
With the swords you have protection from white, black, blue, and red - so that pretty much cancels out any removal they might have.

>>34386659
In response I kill the creature.
Or destroy the artifact.
Or prevent all damage.

Same liabilities. The card is fine, it has it's strengths and it's weakness too.

I just got in here, any cards here that have a burn ability? even if it's just a ping?

Speaking of silly things.

>>34386758
see
>>34386508

>>34386758
Lots. One /a/non in particular puts it on most of his cards.
Plus the thing I just posted.

Ok, last one. Kinda shitty. Time for bed.

>>34386758
>>34386470
>>34384339
>>34380020
>>34379146

Like these?

>>34386830

Only because it is the only way to represent ranged combat.

>>34386833
Lol in reanimator shenanigans.

>>34386794
yikes that's expensive.

anyone here make a furnace of rath & repercussion deck? I played a pyroclasm using forbidden orchards, shit was so cash man.

I do this all the time on /tg/ Why not?

Well, then. I am off to bed - saved the things that were worth saving, etc. Once again, successful thread!

See you people tomorrow night. Adieu, /a/!

I'm going to bed as well, either myself or Legacy will make a thread same place around the same time, Theme is Shonen Jump, and from there who knows.

>>34387079
Blade doesn't have to kill to copy, though the flavor is cool.

remade to be /a/worthy

also, good thread guys, see ya tomorrow

>>34387175
Generally he has to hold them down to copy, and Imprint is the easiest tech to do this with. Thanks though, top down design is my favorite.

:3

>>34387269
Fuck that shit. Should be

Legendary Creature - Tripfag Troll

who should I do next?

I'm thinking of starting at the top of the easymodo post counts and working my way down, only doing the active tripfriends.

that should be good :3

And here's some more Umineko.

I don't think I have an active enough presence to warrant a card yet.