And replacements can be made if a better candidate is found.

needs moar QUALITY VAN

Why put Higurashi in shit house? the art gets better and there are more episodes with better art than episodes with the bad art of the first season. Beck had more QUALITY than Higurashi fuck sake. Not the mention the QUALITY cabbage anime.

>>32703891
No Higurashi should fill every spot

Seriously needs the original Kanon (amikawaiiuguu) and Musashi Gundoh in shithouse.

As much as I hate to say it, Kamichama Karin's anime was pretty atrocious too. The manga was adorable - the anime, well...

>>32703958
That's why it isn't kai or rei, just higurashi, and that part is from later episodes

watch trapaze then add it to the list

>use of 3d
>no gits
haha made my day /a/

for mech's having a VF-01 is a must

>>32703958
Fuck off you gigantic faggot.

Higurashi belongs to shit house, deal with it.

>>32704109
>GITS: Innocence

Are you blind? Faggot.

Code Geass for costume designs

As crappy as the show is, the costume designs are particular

whoever got zoids on there - you are a fucking bro

you could add HELLSING for stylistic fights or monster design

>>32704138
oh my oh my, you ruined my day. shitty pic btw

>>32703958
why not remember the last episode of higurashi s1 with rena hitting Mion, that was impressive QUALITY
we're talking about the s1 here

>>32704109
We -are- looking at the same chart, aren't we?

>chart shit

>Manly
>TTGL
>No Berserk

>>32704186
>namefag
>butthurt over his own FAIL
>snarling dog in a corner

You mad

>>32704186
That was one of the most memorable 3D pieces from the movie.

>>32704226
We already agreed on not putting one series in more than one category.

Do Medabots count as mechs?

Still no Karas in 3D?

>>32704256
This

>>32703968
and akikan?
and polyphonica?
btw OP still /r/ing image of those for the shithouse

I vote Fireball for 3D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMyZ07QgTP4

>>32704226
Berserk got a spot for both monster design AND horror in the first chart. It's doing pretty well really.

Why is TTGL in Manly when its art and designs were based of various other manly series?

>>32704256
look for an image yourself and help

This needs to be used as Gundam's pic for the chart.

Needs Mazinger Z

Soul Eater also fits for Animated Choreography.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDvhLR-GOMY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AkocAvbooH0

>>32704127

The animation isn't all quality, you shouldn't take in between frames of ragefaces as QUALITY. It should be an overall scene in real time where QUALITY is present, and I seriously wouldn't include ragefaces as a sign of QUALITY because you normally make ragefaces out of QUALITY frames on purpose, look for series that utterly make horrible QUALITY moments and they are apart of an overall scene not just one frame, opinions I know.

The Big O needs to go in mecha design.

Added Musashi Gundoh and Karas.

can we use this for akikan QUALITY?
can't find any better, THOUGH there's a lot more

>>32704362
>BAWWW BAWWWW I DON'T WANT PEOPLE TO THINK HIGURASHIT HAS SHIT ANIMATION, WHICH IT DOES

Higurashi = Shit house

End of story

Noien must go under Choreography, but it also fits under Use of 3D.

>>32704305

Cromartie should have been in Manly.

I'd put Birdy the Mighty Decode in the shithouse category. The end of season 1 made me want to claw my eyes out.

>>32704362
>>32704403

I love Higurashi but you gota admit it got shitty QUALITY animation. or rather, its animated by DEEN.

this chart is complete shit

>>32704373

FUCK YES FUCK YES FUCK YES

God damn Megadeii are all stylish as hell

>>32704403
Enjoy having the mental age of a 12 year old, forever.

>>32704387
Awesome, thanks.

I add my support to those who think that there are better examples of manly than TTGL.

FLCL needs to be in animated choreography.

>>32704424
yeah, Bakemonogatari also works for shit house.

I know you've already got a bones anime for mecha, but Rahxephon also had spectacular mecha design.

I haven't finished it, but from what I've seen Casshern had pretty damn fluid animation.

>>32704362
This chart is about art and artstyles. Higurashi looks like fucking garbage.

shamo for stylistic fights isn't good?

Jojo should totally be in Manly too.

what is it with you faggots and charts lately.

Cowboy Bebop deserves to be in animated choreography.

>>32704464
+1

Can it have chibi renji as "special guest" in shithouse ?

Bleach is not too much shit, but that pic just deserve it.

Astro Fighter Sunred for Monster Designs.

>>32704480
they get guaranteed replies, let people feel important

Can we add Princess Tutu for coreography?
the dances were really well done

>>32704439
I would love to add The Big O, but I didn't want another Sunrise production after just getting rid of Code Geass off the list.

Reckon I should put it on there anyway, or should we look for a fantasy-mech to fill the spot?

Costume Design - Last Exile if you like pseudo-Nazi uniforms.

>>32704474

More like manly.
In the beginning Shamo didn't wanted to be that stylish IMO.

I nominate Haibane Renmei for costume design.

Simple, yet perfect for the atmosphere of the show. Also very fitting of the characters and their personalities.

>>32704464

Agreed. Something new is always shit. At the same time lump SZS in shithouse art as well.

>>32703891
/r/ing quality van please.

Nanoha StrikerS for shithouse?

>>32704510
a few bad parts aren't really QUALITY
Higurashi with a REALLY inconsistent animation with heads that got bigger or smaller throughoout an episode is, for example

You guys are forgetting the most essential monster designer. Seriously, Go Nagai got his name in so many anime just because he did the monster design.

>>32704362
>The animation isn't all quality,
So, the majority of the animation sucks but one is not allowed to mention that because it's not 100% shit in every scene? That's a bullshit standard.
>It should be an overall scene in real time where QUALITY is present,
Higurashi had plenty of those, don't you remember the ladder scene for one?
>I seriously wouldn't include ragefaces as a sign of QUALITY because you normally make ragefaces out of QUALITY frames on purpose,
Oh wait, you just have NO idea what you are talking about and you are only making shit up because someone said something negative about a favorite show of yours.

>>32704536
Eh, fair enough.

Maybe Full Metal Panic?

>>32704557

>>32704524
You know what... yes, yes I do think it should go on there.

>>32704536
PUT IN MEDABOTS

>>32704524
agreed. IMO Tutu would fit choreography well.

Macross Frontier belongs in shit.

I liked the show, but the art was really bad.

>>32704553
SHAFT has QUALITY as a trademark, so it's more of an asrtstyle than real QUALITY, they should be in something like 'minimalistic', QUALITY affects series with studios that can make good animation but are lazy

>>32704576

I approve of this post.

Seriously, Silen is in everybody's mind when thinking of anime monsters.

I don't care that the costumes weren't that innovative. They all looked cool as fuck.

>>32704647
BUT they weeren't innovative, just looked cool

>>32704663

WAIT.
If this list is about innovation, then just scrap TTGL from there.
It's an awesome show but has really nothing innovating.

Throw Umineko in Shithouse as well.

Braves series for mechanical design.

Added Akikan and Princess Tutu. Nice suggestion with Tutu.

Still looking for QUALITY VAN. =/ And as retro-awesome The Big O's mecha are, it was already decided that Sunrise/Gainax shouldn't get a second spot on the list.

>>32704544
he is cocky, not manly.

>>32704693
we already have DEEN, and overall it didn't had THAT MUCH QUALITY compared, typical head problems, still, we already have one

Think of the MANLY category as like the opposite of Shoujo style guiz.

>>32704647

I do wish I could find a girl that would look good in Chane's dress. Or someone who could fill out Lua's

>>32704688
I also think TTGL should be removed.

Hellsing for monster or costume design, plz

>>32704703

Yeah the protagonist is a gigantic dick but I was speaking about the tone of the manga.

Princess Tutu is good, but animation is pretty average. I'd swap that with Sword of the Stranger or Seirei no Moribito.

How about Naruto fillers for Shithouse?

You can use the scene where Naruto is missing his head lol.

>>32704697

>>32704591

>>32704774
we agreed no movies allowed in that category.

DAT CHOREOGRAPHY

>>32704697

>still no Go Nagai in "monster design"
>still no Mazinger, or Getter or Goldrake etc.etc. in mecha

What ?

Shithouse this show is all about.

>>32704824
Aachi is awesome, you faggot.

>>32704822
please look for images and will be considered

>>32704772
well that karateka and chinese dude without one hand were awesome. really manly.

Musashi Gundoh should be the first one in the Shithouse category. I mean, it did everything on purpose to become king.

Why is Gankutsuou not in costume design? Because you already have something from Gonzo?

>>32704822
A good monster picture from Devilman would be great. I tried adding it before, but it's rather confusing since I don't know the series very well and there are so many collaborators in the overall series.

>>32704874
it doesn't follow an order, just when he recieves one, he puts it

>>32704663
That IS what >>32704647 said.

>>32704647
>I don't care that the costumes weren't that innovative.
I don't think it matters that they weren't innovative. Costume design doesn't have to be some "out-there" crazed monstrosity of fabric to be good, I believe that good costume design is based on designs that fit the characters individually as well as the tone of the show which Baccano!'s designs do.

>>32704688
It's not necessary for it to be "innovative" unless it is required by the category. I would say that execution matters more than what percentage of ideas have been attempted before.

>>32704818
seconded, it should be

>>32704895
It already got an 'artsy' award in the first chart. Also I'm not so sure of fashion design because of the styling.

>>32704896

bleach costume design

>>32704860

This for monsters design(couldn't find a proper Silen)

>>32704923
costume design and fashion design are different things.

I loved Summer Wars for the animations.

>>32704937
Got anything less... human I suppose?

Mobile suit Gundam for QUALITY

Monster for monster design lol.

This for Mecha.

Seriously, the choices for old mecha are unlimited but the most famous is probably this guy.

>>32704997

>>32704977
Trying, but maybe Devilman isn't the best. I mean, Go Nagai did SHITLOADS of manga. I think that to find his absolute best monster, it's better to ask /m/ or something.

>>32704991
That'll do :)

>>32704977

Just wait 'till I find the turtle whit people's heads engraved to its back.

Code Geass was pretty shithouse-y for being such a high profile, big budget show.

Go Nagai and QUALITY VAN added

...Bleach for costume design? I'm hearing that a lot lately.

>>32704997
Yay, bro. I've been posting puns on these threads alone.

>>32704907
I know that. It's just that Gundoh is... special.

>>32705116
the places left in shithouse are for quality van and uguu as soon as someone posts them

>>32705018

heheh

Code Geass for mecha?

Too much black and white going on here.

Blade of the Immortal for fights

>>32705144
Maybe move JoJo to costume design?
Damn, it's hard to classify it.

>>32705174
was posted, got took out

>>32705144
I would vote against that.

>>32705186
This. totally forgot about it because it got so shit later.

>>32705154

>>32705184
It's a little strange, but horror elements tend to do better in manga form. The horror category in the last chart had all manga as well.

no Macross in mecha section? you bastard

>>32705057

Jinmen you mean ?

That would be nice.

Green Green for shithouse.

>>32705144

Akikan pic make me lol

>>32705184
because we agreeded that stylistic fights were manga only and all the good monster designs are manga too

>>32705211
You should pick it up because it gets awesome again.

>>32705248
couldn't find any better, believe me there are BY FAR worst

>>32705186
Fuckin' added to the chart. That's poetic.

>>32705216

>>32705144
Bleach for Costume Design

Entering Hellsing for monster design.

>>32705237
>>32705057
Can't say he looks that special.

>>32705216

>>32705281
D: Holy crap...

Is that sort of thing consistent in the animation though?

>>32705284
>>32705284
>>32705284
>>32705284
>>32705284
>>32705284

Simoun

>>32705247
FUCKING THIS

I KNOW I'm going to get flamed for this, but what the hell: I nominate One Piece for stylistic fights.

....... OK, you can begin to raeg, troll and flame now.

I vote FLCL for animated choreography

>>32705281
That's the shoop.

>>32705271
maybe, lost interest during that long winded, crazy doctor, monster creation phase.

>>32705144
I don't think just colorspreads count. So no

>>32705349
I anger that "I'm cute?" was not kept in...

>>32705281
>>32705304

>>32705340
ok, let's start
it's already in wstern art, let's limit repetition as much as possible

>>32705247

Reference pictures?

>>32705320

No idea. I just downloaded Clannad and After Story and they are about 4th on my list of things to watch so far.

>>32705284
>>32705284
>>32705284

The OP hesitates, but wonders if Digimon could be considered for monster designs...?

>>32705340
But you are right

>>32705289

Well the crying kid is a nice touch.

GitS:SAC for Mech Design?

animated choreography, heres an FLCL shot

>>32705426
and you samefag

I'm thinkin escaflowne for mecha.

Air Gear for stylistic fights.

last spot should go to both naruto and bleach as a joint effort

Mecha section has no Macross?!

>>32705361
Yeah that arc was really long winded. I skipped most of it as well.

>>32705340

Eeeeeh, I dunno, bro.

Huge One Piece fag over here, but compare it to the stuff in that category already.
There's no comparison.

>>32705420
If digimon, why not pokemon then?

>>32705439
It was on there before but dropped for whatever reasons.

>>32705392
only way for me to find them would be to watch that shit again and I cannot bring myself to do this. I don't mind if it doesn't make the list. I was just hoping that [a/ would be able to back me up about its shittyness.

>>32705420
I will fight you.

>>32705320
No.

The first Anime had pretty atrocious art though.

>>32705446
I absolutely hate Air Gear but it totally deserves the spot.

>>32705481
Tough choice between the two really. =/

Use of 3D, Macross Zero

>>32705443
Sorry to disappoint you, bro

>>32705446
I have to agree

>>32705533
it made Macross Frontier looks like shit

>>32705454

Wait, Naruto had some surprising standards for its category some time ago.

Rock Lee fight against Gaara is still incredible for mainstream shit like that, not to mention some animation for the Naruto vs Sasuke fight either.

Still shit though.

>>32705546
>>32705507
>>32705446
Hm... well, I filled the last spot with Blade of the Immortal already.

>>32705507

Oh wow.

Someone not only basing an an aspect of the quality of something based only on personal opinion.

I salute you sir.

is this fine for Kanon 2002 QUALITY?

>>32705446

Absolutely.
Some of the best looking fights ever despite nothing that happens in that series makeing any fucking sense at all.

>>32705573

I think it would be hard to be more stylistic than Air Gear without being super abstract.

>>32705581
BTW, It's a cover, not real animation, that's how they ADVERTISED it

Add Bleach to "animated choreography." This is why: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kqFHALbnvO0

Blame or Dorohedoro for Monster design

Small update

>>32705492

Pokemon for monster design

<--- proof

lol shithouse

>>32704818
Definitely this, its fight choreography was probably some of the best ever. Much better than KnK's for sure.

>>32705581
THOSE EYES

Alright, Air Gear might be able to replace something on the list, but what? =/

For the shithouse, how about that anime with the uguu, goldfish eye girl

>>32705653
Move JJBA to costume design. It makes more sense to put it there.

>>32705653
soul eater or Alita?

>>32705667
already posted, now waiting

Fucking 2002 Kanon.

>Costume designs
>No Bleach
Oh you guys....

Definitely needs Tutu in animated choreography

>>32705686
check this promo image>>32705581

>>32705669
>Alita
Fuck no.

>>32705686
Her name is Uguu~.

JUST PUT "FILLERS" IN ONE OF THE SHITHOUSE SLOTS

>>32705616
agree on both counts. Emphasis on Dorohedoro.

>>32705709
then should we change something for Air Gear or not?

what about macross frontier for 3D?

>>32705668
First good example I could find.

>>32705772
3d is full already

>>32705761
Tough choice... I can't decide. But then, I might just be a little biased towards Soul Eater. =/

>>32705616
Another example

Holy fuck
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNeOkwQyWkE

>>32705761
yes either soul eater or deadman

>>32705622

That picture of Tsubasa was edited. Original is nowhere as awesome.

>>32705782
ah, didn't see the update.

then how about another line.

also, minami ke season 2 and/or 3 for shithouse?

>>32705786
so, should we ask the editor for change?
Soul eater for Air Gear?

>>32705779

>>32705686
No.

A personal dislike of the art style in a show is NOT poor production standards.

>>32705813
shithouse should be completed with Kanon 2002 I believe
check the images, THAT's QUALITY

"Welcome to NHK" in shithouse

Art was classic horribad - If you dont put it then this list really is circle jerk pandering nonsense

>>32705790
25 seconds into the Anime.

I'd say get higurahi out of shithouse, it wasn't that bad. I nominate the cabbage series.

>>32704895
That piece of shit doesn't even belong in artsy. That's not costume design, it's a fucking photoshop pattern filler over an empty layer, that when animated, it looks like everyone is fucking moving through their clothes and sometimes their hair like they're being projected onto them, and the designs are all random abstract bullshit that is literally painful to look at. It looks fucking retarded and is absolutely exemplary of GONZO QUALITY, but faggots for some reason think it's amazing because everything looks shiny I guess. Gankutsuou is to The Count of Monte Cristo what Twilight is to the vampire mythos.

Darker than Black S1 had some pretty awesome choreography.

>>32705856
we already went through that, HIgurashi had QUALITY printed all over it, nominate Saigar with it, there's a free spot

>>32705856
It so goddamn was, watch it again if you have to.

>>32705189
i agree with this

>>32705845
i've never seen the 2002 version, is really worse than minami ke?

Blame gets the last spot on Monster Design then.

Still not sure what to do with Air Gear...

Put Nazca on the costume design list.

>>32705897
its usual artstyle
>>32705854
>>32705686
>>32705628
>>32705581

>>32705696
Nothing stylish about black/white hakama with slight variations, bro.

>>32705852
lol nah. not when compared to the other trainwrecks that are in that category. when compared to those NHK looks like Trust and Betrayal.

PUT DEAD LEAVES IN ANIMATED CHOREOGRAPHY NAO

jojo into costume design and fill stylistic fights with air gear.

>>32705904
people are biased towards soul eater, so if everyone is okay, then it should be
also add either Kanon 2002 or Saigar and the cabbage in the shithouse

>>32705930
this is a GREAT option

How about Macross Zero for 3D
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atbdDXRen_o

>>32705905
you are a horrible person

>>32705897
No, it's not. Fags are just throwing a fit because a goddamn Cartoon has characters with large eyes, like that isn't the usual practice when it comes to animated works.

>>32705904
Do >>32705189 and put Air Gear in its place.

>>32705926
oh fuk off - NHK looks like "King of the hill" and is way worse then the samefags pushing for lol wideeyes derp

>>32705897
Yes. Every single shot looks like crap. I've been watching for a few minutes and my god what the hell is this shit I drew like this in Middle School.

>>32705653
Either Deadman Wonderland or Soul Eater.
I like DW more, so Soul.

>>32705948
wait nvm, just noticed the updated list

Needs more Winland

>>32705969
This, Except DW goes out and Soul eater stays.

>>32705987
Agreed. Ether get rid of TTGL, or move it to Animated Choreography and put Vinland in Manly.

>>32705968
That's just the style, dumbass.

>>32705950
I'd accept your argument if the guy who has smaller eyes didn't look ridiculous too.

>>32706025
and higurashi also had that style
the same with NHK, a loose and a bit high done art

heres a dead leaves shot

>>32706021
you can't replace TTGL and it doesn't really fit in choreography.

also, why is yukikaze in 3D? compared to the newer macross animes it's animations are quite old fashioned.

>>32705986
switch out TTGL and replace with Vinland saga +1

>>32706053
I watched all of those shows. It wasn't THIS bad THIS consistently.

Gintama for choreography

>>32706053
NHK - fuken shit

>>32706106
Expand the list? Or is OP anal about symmetry

Alright, changed!

Initial D for choreography?

>>32706132
The guy in the blue shirt is an amputee waving to his friend. It's not that bad.

>>32706053
One, no it didn't, and two the reasons Higurashi is on there have already been explained. Sudden drops in framerate, characters going off model, colors being changed from the standard in individual scenes, body proportions changing through the episode, etc. It's nothing to do with style in the first placv.

>>32706150
let's not please, it's already taken a lot

>>32706085
wow, i have to watch this anime, just for the QUALITY

>>32706150
Considering the chart was actually half this size when I first started...

Also, I used to be a design student so maybe a little of column A and column B.

>>327061767
don't, both seasons are shit, if you want just search the worst car polyphonica on youtube

Casshern Sins for Animated Choregraphy

>no dead leaves in stylistic fights

This chart needs a Fanservice category. Then just shove Ikki Tousen and whatnot in there.

>>32706171
i think he agreed with you (although you can never be sure about irony on teh internet)

>>32706217
It's Manga only.

>>32706053

Exactly, only some parts of Higurashi was genuine QUALITY.

>>32706150
No, just stick to a handful of relevant examples. This should not be expanded to idiotically huge proportions to try and fit every single series on it.

Macross for mecha

>>32706156

I prefer Jojo in stylistic fighting :(

>>32706232
this sorry, why doesn't have the internet an irony button?

>>32706212
Great suggestion if the OP doesn't want to do >>32706021

>>32706258
we had to make place and was the better option, two birds with one stone, now costumes is finished

>>32706258
Tough luck. It's MUCH better this way.

>>32706250
no sorry, I was being sarcastic
this is the reason>>32706171

>>32706021
I support this.

>>32706167
CAR CHOREOGRAPHY?! U MAD?

there really needs to be an anime version of this chart and a separate manga version.

As anyone mentioned Cowboy Bebop for choreography?

>>32706370
we already separated two categories, it wouldn't be fair sometimes and this kinda works
for example, some categories are ruled by anime and others by manga, no one complains

>>32706370
The chart is going pretty damn well, so there's no need for that.

>>32706382
been mentioned

btw, new thread?

>>32706451

And it was not accepted why?

Vinland Saga wins over TTGL

...Punching horses always inspires a "FUCK YEAH!" moment in me.

>>32706459
no one pushed it

I acually want to nominate G-On Riders for shithouse, but I just watch it until mid season

>>32706212

I second that.

Birdy: Decode for Choreography

So it's between Cowboy Bebop and Casshern Sins for choreography then?

>>32706489
>>32706212
tough decission

>>32706489

And that too...

>>32706461
Now, for the last spot in the animated choreography section, I recommend either TTGL back in, or Casshern Sins.

>>32706503
we've bashed CAsshern too much, I believe it deserves the spot

Shouldn't we ask /m/ for mecha designs?

>>32706503

I vote for Bebop

>>32706489
Old Birdy has better choreography and animation.

Noein for stylistic fights. Or really just about anything that had Norio Matsumoto involved. Even early Naruto

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q17OTH0nIQQ

>>32706547
FULL, and even changed once

Either TTGL or Cowboy Bebop on animated choreography
I vote for CB

vote for Bebop

bump

Gintama for choreography
http://www.youtube.com/watch#!v=tai2r_YRwAo

Casshern is good too

>>32706642
bump limit reached, thread on autosage
please make another

>>32706660

new thread please

>>32706660

dude theirs tons of fights along the eps with awesome choreography
but whatever, it's cool

QUALITY

>>32706721
learn2 stillshots
also, we already have DEEN in QUALITY

>>32706757

New thread done

Bebop needs to be on this list. :P