>>32636186

can you make a version with not luffy on it

put clare or the guy that he replaced

thanks and looks great

>>32636186
Kaiji's is Itou, not Ito.

Other than that I can't spot anything.

Change Munsu's title to Shin Angyo Onshi.

I don't understand why we decided to drop Nausicaa

Good job /a/

>>32636288
Did we decide on Claire or Rock?

>>32636324
What? Nausicaa is there. Her position just changed.

>>32636340

well more people wanted Claire, at least on the last thread

there was a pic and quote too for her

Also a joke version.

>>32636353
My bad. I'm just blind.

>>32636388

my god

I really don't see why we can't just cut the bottom half of Shiki's body off in order to make the picture look ebtter.

>>32636340

More people wanted Clare
Some wanted the guy Luffy replaced

I'd go with Rock myself

>>32636388
actually, i think this is a good idea. keeps the chart the same while shutting up the haters lol

>>32636383

Don't be so quick to throw away your life. No matter how disgraceful or embarrassing it may be, you need to keep struggling to find your way out until the very end.

Clare (Claymore)

>>32636388
Oh my god, I love you so much.

Akiha would, too.

Clare isn't a hero.

>>32636467
And pissing off the the OP fans.

Caving into the haters would be retarded.

>>32636444
Knife and handcuffs.

>>32636519

>>32636186
Theres a typo in Black Jacks quote.
>I'll help you under on condition

>>32636519

youre the guy that asked for light and L to be inn right?

Where the fuck is Alucard from Hellsing?

I feel motivated after reading those lines.

Fuck i will try harder...tomorrow.

>>32636186
Typo column two, row four. Black Jack I think? Never watched it. "one condition" not "on condition. Unless he actually says that.

L should of been in there also.

>>32636535
You don't see me complaining about not getting in Ed's metal legs or about missing Kenji's guitar.

Seems like a dumb reason just to throw off the balance of the picture.

>>32636569

alucard is a magnificent bastard

badass but not really heroic, same for guts

>>32636186
>Any issues, problems?

yes, luffy is in, and no big 3 alowed

>>32636572
>tomorrow.

enjoy never doing anything

>>32636444
Then it'd look something like this.

>>32636609
Integra then.

>>32636186
>>32636186
>>32636186

Fucking awesome. Saved, endorsed.

Adam Blade is more of an hero

>>32636496

+1

>>32636666
Thank you.

>>32636666
>6666]

The get gods have spoken.

>>32636677
Pip is already on there to rep Hellsing.

everythingwentbetterthanexpected.jpg

>>32636565

No. I wanted Onizuka and Youko to be inside.

Original PLEASEluffy poster from 3 days ago here.

>>32636388
Fucking lol. Saved as well.

Yoh being in is kind've annoying but this is about as close too good as we're going to get I suppose.

>>32636702
This. Drop Luffy, add Blade and use the quote about being able to kill Arclight without his friends help or whatever.

It's great.
I still feel Mikado should be on, but to quote someone in the chart, c'est la vie

And Jacuzzi for Isaac would be doable as well

>>32636765

onizuka is good too then

It's awesome. Well styled, good choice of quotes and images, and characters were picked for actual heroic qualities instead of bullshit /a/ politics and whining.

Er, no Naruto or Ichigo or Tenchi or Rock? And you put Clare on? Clare's really not a hero...

>>32636186
>>32636388
>>32636666

All three are great, and the middle one is hilarious. Personally, my favorite is the one with chopped Shiki. Looks nicer.

>>32636956
> no Naruto or Ichigo
imokaywiththis.jpg

current list is fine really.

>>32636765
Onizuka isn't a hero.

>>32636967

But we still need to fix Black Jack's quote

Needs this

"Just watch! I'll break this petty fate with my own hands"

what's the point of that anyway you should have put all that effort in the anime or manga chart

>>32636186
Theres a bunch of better quotes for Shiki Tohno. The current one really lacks impact.

>>32637021

yeah he is a good choise too

agreed, we need K1 in there

kinda surprised he's not, but I don't know who take out.

>>32637021
This.

Requesting that you cut off the "and I will make my way to him" bit of Guts' quote. It has no relevance to the impact of his statement and if anything detracts from it. When someone finishes reading that quote, the "I am what I am" should be ringing in their mind, not thoughts of Griffith (or for the uninitiated, thoughts of what the hell Guts means). It just seems messy and unneeded.

where is adam and his I AM THE KING OF THE WORLD

>>32636956
> Er, no Naruto or Ichigo or Tenchi or Rock? And you put Clare on? Clare's really not a hero...

>>32637021

make it happen

needs this

"I am nobodies marionette ,I will no longer cower before fate, what ever it takes i will guard him"
spoken by tutu and fakir

>>32636826
This except to a higher degree.

Yoh being on their is pretty bad.

editor are you still around?

pick someone already please for the second chart

>>32637085
I agree with this. I'll make that change.

Also fixed that Black Jack typo. You guys decided on a character yet?

>>32637216
> You guys decided on a character yet?

Onizuka. Or Kurono even.

>>32637216

clare, onizuka or k1

or the one with more votes

>>32637264
>Kurono

YES

>>32636519
And extremely bland.

>>32637264

Onizuka quotes:
"From now on I'm gonna live life with a fighting spirit!"
"What do you think about having more faith in you yourself?"
"The word 'impossible' isn't in my dictionary... but I don't really have a dictionary you know? "

>>32637216

K1 or Clare

Personal vote goes to K1 (btw, his name is Maebara Keiichi from Higurashi no nako koro ni/When the Cicadas Cry)

Can someone make a villains chart?

>>32637360
I approve of this.

>>32637360

Oh...oh shit...

>>32637345
Voting no for Keiichi. Higurashi really doesn't deserve a spot there, and he's more of a situational hero than anything.

Where's my goddamn Yui? I see shitty characters such as Balsa, Nausicaa, and Alita, but no Yui? Fucking bullshit. Saging this.

Guess what, side characters can also be heroric

>>32637345
+2

keiichi has badass lines

>>32637382

>>32637382
Fuck off

>>32637360
It'd be pretty hard as the definition of "villain" would be even vaguer then Hero.

We'd be arguing big time over some of the placements.

>>32637216
You, sir, are a gentleman and a scholar. Thank you.

thors
kurono
clare
keichi
onizuka

any is good to me

Why is Shiki in there? I'm not saying this because "lol Tsukihime animu doesn't exist" but seriously, he is more /jp/ or /v/ than /a/. Shitty animu + decentwhilepanderingtothefanbase manga doesn't justify him.

>>32636984
>Implying "5 ambulances" isn't better than any of the shit that says luffy

>>32637379

>doesn't deserve a spot

I don't follow why?

>is more of a situational hero

How so? He fits for what's right. Sure, he doesn't go around saving the world, but he does everything he must, because he can

>>32637360
Already been done.

K1 for the last spot

>>32636388

Off topic. But I watched Birdy the Mighty when I was way younger. And later on I was reminded of it because they had remade it. I really don't like the character designs for the new version of it. I haven't watched it yet. But I just LOVED the characters for it before, and how dark it was. This one seems so... fluffy.

>>32637549

I think he meant one using this font

And it'd be very hard. We'd have to go with pure evil without morally gray

The heroes chart is already filled with gray

higurashi is a good adition to this

go for it

>>32637549
FUCK YEAH! I saw this ages ago and forgot to save.

>>32637531
> but he does everything he must, because he can

He did so ONE TIME, because he had to, being in pretty deep shit and all, not because he chose to.

Alright I'm just making a snap decision here and saying Keichi gets final spot. We have plenty of female heroines for now. Quotes and pics please.

>>32637052
This has been said before and I'm fine with changing the quote with someone provides another.

Hey Editor, just putting this out there, but the start of Kaiji's quote "You told me this remember?" seems unneeded.
Why not take it out?

This chart is faggots

Keiichi is a subpar hero and there's already too many VN-original characters. I say Kazuma with his old line or Claire.

>>32637635
if someone*

>>32637635
see
>>32637021

Reinhard over Yang?
This isn't a villains list.

Yeah, I went there.

>>32637635

>Alright I'm just making a snap decision here and saying Keichi gets final spot.

Are you even reading the thread?

Oh wow.

Keiichi taking Onizuka's spot.

Real classy /a/, keep it that way.

>>32637691
You have no idea how long of a debate there was last night over that.

>>32637587

1st season of decode is kinda fluffy

2nd season is FUCK YEAR and awesomeness. Watch it

SPOILER: If you haven't noticed by now, Editor is a novelfag.

>>32637629

One time?
Every time he was given awareness of what was to come, he fought for his friends and for the right cause.
against Rena, he put his life on the line
when the shit hit the fan when Saoko was taken by her uncle. Both times he tried to help (one ended badly because of crazyshit disease)
in the final reality, he went up against armed and trained soldiers without a hint of fear or hesitation.

He broke fate. Just because he lost it in some of the realities and did bad shit doesn't take away from his heroics

>>32637703
Onizuka was brought numerous times and refused each time. He'd probably have taken Kazuma's spot earlier if so.

>>32637693
I just want to finish this.

Quotes are overly long and some parts don't make sense outside of context. I fixed them.

>>32637670

better picture

>>32637724

This.

>>32637771
>Pip's death quote shortened.

No you le don't.

>>32637724
No not really.

>>32637710

Alright, have you seen the original though?

All of these are total failures since they don't include brokama and his awesome speech vs hina

Seems Luffy's chart will actually be the superior one. Didn't see that coming.

This isn't a hero list. This is a favorite character list. Try harder next time.

>>32637771

I agree with:
Guts
Kaiji
Reinhard

Everything else is faggoty, especially François's and Pip's fix

It's rather annoying how characters are fine one day and then not the next.

>>32637815
Yes I le did. And it is superior.

Also some of these need to be totally removed but I don't want to create a shitstorm. Still needs moar Ryo Saeba though.

>>32637848

yeah but I prefer Decode. Just my opinion, the OVAs were still good though

>>32637919

Yoh was never fine.

>>32637416

>>32637919
It's never the same people complaining, d'oh.

That said, why is Shiki Tohno there?

Replace jotaro with any other fucking Jo Jo protagonist because he is the fucking worst

>>32637931
> Ryo Saeba
Actually agreed. First time I see his name mentioned. Classic, badass, memorable western-style hero.

>>32637919

The characters picked are fine

We are discussing fixing some quotes, mostly for convenience in the look department.

Quote wise, they are all godly. Maybe shortening some will help.

>>32637919

can't please everyone, and there's no point in pandering to a few people, otherwise this really wouldn't be a group effort

concessions have to be made, just add the final person and be done with it

>>32637919
People wear themselves out typing one day, and then their opponents appear the next. Just make a version that YOU are happy with and let anyone who wants to edit it do so.

>>32636186
OVA Kenshin said better shit than the one posted

>>32637947
Lol. But the third row is misaligned, fix that, repost.