Please, be argumentative and try to raise valid points. Quotes are welcome, if you're gonna suggest someone.

the Editor returned

>>32589307

fuck off

Get Shirou off the list.

Add Sakura Kinomoto.

>>32589843
isn't there a better pic for Kenji? B&W kinda sucks ,theres colored pages for 20th CB.

Yeah, put the characters names down for people that don't know them.

>enter thread
>see Ippo

>>32590111
Alright, gonna this later, in the final version.

Why do they all sound like fags?

Get Shinji&Ippo off the list. Then all shall be well.

>>32590101
> isn't there a better pic for Kenji?
care to provide it?

>>32590072
she had lots of support last thread, competing against Nanoha!

Yeah, Sakura needs to be on this list.

>>32590156
> Get Shinji&Ippo off the list

Well Shinji is a hero and does have a lot of support.

If may I ask, why Ippo?

By the way, I'm still waiting on quotes from Alita. I do wanna add her, because she's quite popular amongst manga readers and frankly it's a good manga, but... need them quotes!

Needs moar Archer.

Now for the quote.

"Drown in your ideals and die!"

>>32590202

Ippo is a Mary Sue. Had to be said.

>>32590293
2 characters from the same series?
And it's not like he's the main character... which is what this list is about.

yeah, I know he actually is, but you get the point

>>32590293
Archer = anti-hero
get it right bro.

sage for OP faggotry

>>32590293
not the Hero

HATERS GONNA HATE

Ippo is awesome. You've gotta punch him harder, boy!

If we're doing anime AND manga heroes, why not add this guy?

>>32590405
I'm all for it. Just let's get a little support, and a noteworthy quote.

Mx0 is underrated anyways.

>>32590202
Nothing about Shinji is 'heroic'. That's not who his character was supposed to be.

Ippo, as stated before, is a Mary Sue that only loses fights when people get sick of him winning.

dark schneider?

anyone?

best hero ever, fights satan and doesnt afraid of anything.

sure is samefag here

>>32590433
> Nothing about Shinji is 'heroic'.

except, you know, saving the world. He's the most unlikely hero, but a hero as well.

>>32590438
DS is awesome but is not a hero in any way.

>>32590254
"I dont know who you are............ Nor do I care, you are scum, and now your dead"
Thats one, I'm still looking.

>>32590479
He DESTROYS the world. Because supposedly nobody loves him.

>>32590309
>Ippo is a Mary Sue

I don't like Ippo, but no.

>>32590478
>sure is one piece faggotry in here

fixed

>>32590346
No it's not. It doesn't have to be a protagonist. It's a heroes chart.

>>32589307
Link leads to real thread.

If you want One Piece off, present a logical argument.

>>32590479

To add to this, Shinji is the kind of guy that, while he certainly didn't want to fight or kill the angels, he chose to do so in the end because it was the right thing to do.

If doing something you don't want to do for the greater good isn't heroic, I don't know what is.

Wasn't Tenmas quote said by Dieter?

>>32590438
I don't think Dark Schneider is exactly a hero, even if he's awesome. But if I had to nominate a quote myself:

> Burning in the depths of the pits of darkness, let the fires of hell take you! Let the fires become my sword and strike you down! Venom!

>>32590513
>I didn't read the thread so I'll just try to shit it up with reverse-trolling

>>32589843
ARE YOU A TROLL!? OR JUST PLAIN RETARDED!?
WHY THE FUCKING HELL IS LUFFY STILL ON THAT!!?

>>32590567
Because you are obviously samefagging and haven't provided a good argument for him NOT to be there.

>>32590479
Well, I was under the assumption that we were looking at the character personality traits.
And so what if he saves the world? Under that logic, any character that saves the world can be on this list.

Kenshiro is the only cool quote. And Kaneda.

>JPG ARTIFAAAAAAAAAAAAACTS

God fucking dammit OP.

>>32590509
> Sendō Takeshi, Naniwa‮!‫‬‭‮‪‫‬‭‮ ‪‪‪ Tiger
> I don't like Ippo

SEEEENDOOOOOU-SAAAAAAAAAAAAN

Kazuki Muto is saddened.

>>32589843
Luffy there is bound to cause huge shitstorms.

I still support replacing Shirou with Archer...Yeah yeah, anti-hero, not the main character etc. but still.

And I suggest adding Adam Blade there.

>zero
>luffy
>rock
>lupin
>spike
>HERO chart
>opisretarded.exe

>>32590539
Wasn't he fighting because he wanted his father to look at him?

>>32590543
> Wasn't Tenmas quote said by Dieter?

It was said by Tenma to Dieter, and Dieter later in the series repeats it to Nina.

>>32590602
There's nothing wrong with OP's image, I don't know what you are raging about.

>>32590587
> Implying I care enough to samefag.
> Implying you don't know the Big 3 is shit and has no place on any list that has /a/ or [a/ written on it.
BEST BE JOKING.

im curious why all the people raging are still bothering with this when the other editor also has a thread going

Oh wow, Tenshi is on this list? I mean, nothing against it, but I didn't know /a/ was that big a fan.

>>32590629
Luffy and Zero ARE heroes, and one could argue Spike.

>anime heroes
>not even got Kouji

the chart is almost done it's getting better then this

>>32590156

Shinji may not be a typical hero but he has heroic qualities about him. Its true he is a little whinging girly-boy, but he still manages to come through when he needs, despite of his shitty attitude and personality.

>>32590661
Right, like I thought you are just raging because it's the Big 3, not for any logical reason.

>>32590646
Not him but none of those guys >>32590629 listed are heroes except Zero.

>>32590671
> Oh wow, Tenshi
Yeah, he's got supporters... I personally find his quote average, but still.

>>32590646
Look closely at the goddamn text. Artifacting all over the place. This happened the last time /a/ made these goddamn hero/villain lists. Annoying as hell.

>>32590688
This is pure shit.

Shit crops, lol white text with generic font, etc. etc.

>>32590716
> Look closely at the goddamn text. Artifacting all over the place.
The hell you on about?

>>32590716
I'm looking at the text. It's clear and legible.

>>32590559

how is he not a hero? sure, he fucks everyone in sight but he is like the ultimate bro.

and he is trying his (lol) god damndest to stop all that plot spoiling from happening.

he literally ripped his own heart out to save his woman from a curse, whats not heroic about that?

I approve of this pic, mostly. Could do without a few VNfags and generic quotes, but still.

>>32590719
thats just the working copy from tuesday morning, we only made it for the sake of organization

>>32590719
that was the chart in its early stages

GARlock > Simon

>>32590620
Only sane person in this thread/

>>32590764
Alright, /a/, opinions on Dark Scheider?

Well, I for one, like OPs chart very much now.

In fact, I already saved it.

>>32590764
Well there's the whole bit where he's an evil sorcerer and just happens to be fighting guys more evil than he is.

If DS is a hero, Rance is.

>>32590072

Just wondering, how does Ippo qualify as a hero?

>>32590796
I can see why he is a hero, but he does have undeniable anti-hero qualities. Ripping out his heart was pretty cool, and I guess saving your girl qualifies as heroism, or 1/4 of the list would go down.

ITT people mistake plain protagonists as heroes

>>32590405
Taiga isn't a hero, he's just a badass.

I would have liked to see Yoh Asakura in the list, but I know [a/ won't go for it. Well, he'll always be a hero to me.

>>32590742
Compare the top to the bottom.

>Jacuzzi
I thought /a/ didn't care about anyone in Baccano except Issac/Miria, Ladd, and Claire.

>>32590837
Ippo is a hero of COURAGE! SPIRIT! WILL!

Come on, don't start denying Ippo, and sports (especially fightan' sports), aren't heroic.

Isn't standing up to Eiji's fists heroic?

>>32590796
i approve of DS

Awwww, I liked Ryougi's entry.
It was visually very interesting.

>>32590837
Go through the list and ask yourself that for each character.

You'll find surprisingly few, and a ton you aren't familiar with.

>>32590837
He doesn't. Then again at least 50% of OP's pic isn't even slightly heroic. Possibly because OP is a retard but also because of trolls. And badass characters being cooler than hero in general.

>>32590873
I like Yoh, but does he have any particular lines? Part of his character is that he doesn't take anything seriously.

This is why "hero" charts are a bad idea. Protagonist, Antagonist. Nice and clean, clear cut definitions.

I'm still surprised how, after being involved with chart threads and chart-making for 4 days, people have yet to provide a Gon (HxH) quote.

>>32590951
/a/, /co/ and /v/ tried that a while back.

It did not end well.

This one won't, either.

>>32590796
If Guts is on there Dark Schneider deserves a spot, Byronic hero mumbo jumbo or whatever. Also thanks for Alita, did you get my quote here>>32590484

So, Dark Scheider in place of Ippo would be more acceptable?

>>32590888
A .PNG of this size comes out to ~7 MB.

>>32590978
> Also thanks for Alita, did you get my quote here

Yeah I did, thanks for that. Already saved it.

Howdy.

I see alot of changes have been to made to the chart from last night. If everyone is happy with these changes I'll be glad to make them since the quality of this picture here isn't that great.

>>32590980
Sure.

>>32591011
>Everyone happy
>[a/

>>32590888
see >>32590984

Exactly. I'm making sacrifices already, to keep this image below the 3 MB allowed on 4chan.

>>32591011
The chart we had last night is fine, just continue from it.

>>32590980
Unfortunately I haven't read that series though i want too, but this is Dark fucking Schneider.

there been some version i dont which to save i cant believe i started this

>>32591037
this. Do not suffer Red Herring's Faggotry. If there were good changes to this chart then I am sure the same changes will be suggested for the real one.

>>32591011
Pretty happy. Especially about Luffy, since it's you I'm talking to.

>>32590962

B-but Gon isn't much of a hero.

I like this chart, it's a good chart. My only complaint is that Kaneda's quote should be TETSSUUUUUUUUUUUUOOOOOO.

>>32589843
why do we have ANOTHER chart now

jesus christ we're going to be editing 20 different charts for months

You guys know we can always add more rows right?

>>32590685

Agreed. This bro has been around for 40 years being a hero. Time for some recognition.

So far:

1) got Alita's quote
2) considering removing Ippo
3) considering adding Dark Scheider

I'm guessing everyone is okay with Touma being replaced by Kurono, and Ryougi by Tenchi, huh?

>>32590984
I wasn't saying to make it a png. The problem is that idiots like the OP constantly save over an image in progress, increasing artifacting, when they could just have a psd to work on and have a finished product with minimal artifacting. Something like this at least.

>>32591011

Those changes were made by one guy. Your version is superior.

You wanna know about heart? This guy got his fcking destroyed pushing a total stranger out of the way of an attack of a giant snake monster. After that, his hero work really started, saving EVERYONE. Even when he died, he only came back stronger.

>>32591142
got any available quotes? I'm not really familiar with him...

>>32591147

Do not fucking remove Ippo

Anyone else think "Only those who are prepared to fire should be fired at" is a better quote for Lelouch/Zero? or is it just me

>>32591076

there's a much more constructive version of this thread
>>32589202

>>32591197
Either works, as does "The King must move first."

>>32591164
>BAWW I DON'T LIKE LUFFY ON THE LIST AND I'M SAMEFAGGING THESE THREADS FOR ABOUT 8 HOURS NOW

sand in your vagina much?

>>32591011

I like the editions made.

>>32589843
good chart.

>>32591142
THIS.

>>32591179
Yes! He or captain Bravo or Papillon.

>>32591158

Well just recreate the finished product. I see no problem here.

>>32591304
>Papillon

>>32589843
i think this version is simply perfect as it gets.

Luffy is still on the list but you took out Kazuma? Really?

>>32591224
Because only one person feels that Luffy doesn't deserve to be on the list, right? You're delusional.

So, no more major suggestions?

>>32591179
Would consider.

I thought Kurosawa was /a/'s hero : (

>>32591343
>>32590802

Thank you, good sirs

>>32591369
Another row would be a good idea.

>>32591147

Why are we considering removing Ippo again? Also, I suggested it before and I'll suggest it again: Please change Goku's quote to the original one. Though it's 'cool', but "ally to good, nightmare to you" speech is a dub line. Ed's as well.

>>32591439
Yeah, I'm not a fan of the "dub line" either, as awesome as it might sounds. Got a quote of the original one?

>>32591439
ctrl+f Ippo
apparently he's got some real opposition, as well as an equal amount of supporters
> Why are we considering removing Ippo again?

The people getting mad in this thread are being completely stupid.

When the original thread was ongoing, the dude making it literally said "Dont like it? Go and make your own" which is what Herring did.

Stop flaming.

>>32591483
reason people are flaming is because herring did not do his own he hijacked the existing one and added one character that had only troll support.

That wasn't the Editor-san that was from the first chart.

>>32591530
> only troll support.
> Luffy

I see your blatant lie and I raise you a reverse-troll.

>>32591363

s-CRY-ed is a generic sub-par series, only Cougar was memorable. I remember /a/ used to consider him one of the manliest character.

Dark Scheider or Ippo, guise?

Should Tenchi stay?

Kouji? Kazuki?

quotes?

>removed big 3 because bawwwwww

really? oh [a/ fags... all of you


come back at night and this might work... on MONDAY

weekend and kids out of school, this will never work

>>32591558
sorry my friend, last night there was only spam support for Luffy. See for youreslf.
http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/a/thread/32573107#p32573107

>>32591623

It was the fags so vehemently flaming Luffy's inclusion that facilitated that spam.

See, the way trolls work is they find out what annoys a large group of people, then go to great lengths to annoy them further.