Playing with the Internet Daemons

      Author:       Voyager[TNO]

      Date:         15. June 1996

      HTML-Version: Markus Hübner

Internet hosts communicate with each other using either TCP (Transmission
Control Protocol) or UDP (User Datagram Protocol) on top of IP (Internet
Protocol). Other protocols are used on top of IP, but TCP and UDP are the
ones that are of interest to us. On a Unix system, the file /etc/protocols
will list the available protocols on your machine

On the Session Layer (OSI model) or the Internet Layer (DOD Protocol Model)
data is moved between hosts by using ports. Each data communication will
have a source port number and a destination port number. Port numbers can
be divided into two types, well-known ports and dynamically allocated
ports. Under Unix, well-known ports are defined in the file /etc/services.
In addition, RFC (Request For Comments) 1700 "Assigned Numbers" provides a
complete listing of all well-known ports. Dynamically allocated port
numbers are assigned as needed by the system.

Unix provides the ability to connect programs called daemons to well-known
ports. The remote computer will connect to the well-known port on the host
computer, and be connected to the daemon program.

Daemon programs are traditionally started by inetd (The Internet Daemon).
Daemon programs to be executed are defined in the inetd configuration file,
/etc/inetd.conf.

Most of these daemons run as a priveledged user, often as root. Many of
these programs have vulnerabilities which can be exploited to gain access
to remote systems.

The daemons we are interested in are:

        Service          Port Number    Description

        ~~~~~~~~~~~~~    ~~~~~~~~~~~    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

        ftp              21             File Transfer [Control]

        smtp             25             Simple Mail Transfer Protocol

        tftp             69             Trivial File Transfer Protocol

        finger           79             Finger

        www-http         80             World Wide Web HTTP

        sunrpc          111             SUN Remote Procedure Call

        fln-spx         221             Berkeley rlogind with SPX auth

        rsh-spx         222             Berkeley rshd with SPX auth

        netinfo         716-719         NetInfo

        ibm-res         1405            IBM Remote Execution Starter

        nfs             2049            Network File System

        x11             6000-6063       X Window System

        rcp/rshd                        Remote Copy/Remote Shell Daemon

        nis                             Network Information Services

The next part of this article will focus on specific daemons and their
known vulnerabilities. The vulnerabilities with brief explanations will be
explained here. For the more complicated exploits, which are beyond the
scope of a concise article, more research will be required on the part of
the reader.

* ftp 21 File Transfer [Control]

FTP is the File Transfer Protocol. FTP requests are answered by the FTP
daemon, ftpd. wuarchive's ftpd versions below 2.2 have a vulnerability
where you can execute any binary you can see with the 'site exec' command
by calling it with a relative pathname with "../" at the beginning. Here is
a sample exploit:

Login to the system via ftp:

        220 uswest.com FTP server (Version wu-2.1(1) ready.

        Name (uswest.com:waltman): waltman

        331 Password required for waltman.

        Password: jim

        230 User waltman logged in.

        Remote system type is UNIX.

        Using binary mode to transfer files.

        ftp> quote "site exec cp /bin/sh /tmp/.tno"

        200-cp /bin/sh /tmp/tno

        ftp> quote "site exec chmod 6755 /tmp/.tno"

        200-chmod 6755 /tmp/tno

        ftp> quit

        221 Goodbye.

* smtp 25 Simple Mail Transfer Protocol

Mail attacks are one of the oldest known methods of attacking Internet
hosts. The most common mail daemon, and least secure, is sendmail. Other
mail daemons include smail, MMDF,and IDA sendmail. Sendmail has had too
many vulnerabilities to list them all. There is an entire FAQ written
specifically on sendmail vulnerabilities, therefore we will not cover them
heavily here.

One well known vulnerability, useful only for historical purposes, is
"Wizard Mode." In Wizard mode you could request a shell via Port 25 (The
SMTP port). No modern system will be vulnerable to this attack. To exploit
this vulnerability, you telnetted to port 25, typed WIZ to enter Wizard
mode, and entered the password. The problem related to the way the
encrypted password was stored. There was a bug that caused the system to
believe that no password was as good as the real password.

To quote Steven Bellovin:

     The intended behavior of wizard mode was that if you supplied the
     right password, some other non-standard SMTP commands were enabled,
     notably one to give you a shell. The hashed password -- one-way
     encrypted exactly as per /etc/passwd -- was stored in the sendmail
     configuration file. But there was this bug; to explain it, I need to
     discuss some arcana relating to sendmail and the C compiler.

     In order to save the expense of reading and parsing the configuration
     file each time, sendmail has what's known as a ``frozen configuration
     file''. The concept is fine; the implementation isn't. To freeze the
     configuration file, sendmail just wrote out to disk the entire dynamic
     memory area (used by malloc) and the `bss' area -- the area that took
     up no space in the executable file, but was initialized to all zeros
     by the UNIX kernel when the program was executed. The bss area held
     all variables that were not given explicit initial values by the C
     source. Naturally, when delivering mail, sendmail just read these
     whole chunks back in, in two giant reads. It was therefore necessary
     to store all configuration file information in the bss or malloc
     areas, which demanded a fair amount of care in coding.

     The wizard mode password was stored in malloc'ed memory, so it was
     frozen properly. But the pointer to it was explicitly set to NULL in
     the source:

             char    *wiz = NULL;

     That meant that it was in the initialized data area, *not* the bss.
     And it was therefore *not* saved with the frozen configuration. So --
     when the configuration file is parsed and frozen, the password is
     read, and written out. The next time sendmail is run, though, the
     pointer will be reset to NULL. (The password is present, of course,
     but there's no way to find it.) And the code stupidly believed in the
     concept of no password for the back door.

     One more point is worth noting -- during testing, sendmail did the
     right thing with wizard mode. That is, it did check the password --
     because if you didn't happen to do the wizard mode test with a frozen
     configuration file -- and most testing would not be done that way,
     since you have to refreeze after each compilation -- the pointer would
     be correct.

* tftp 69 Trivial File Transfer Protocol

tftp is the Trivial File Transfer Protocol. tftp is most often used to
attempt to grab password files from remote systems. tftp attacks are so
simple and repetitive that scripts are written to automate the process of
attacking entire domains. Here is one such script: Already published in the
first book of Matic!

* finger 79 Finger

The finger command displays information about another user, such as login
name, full name, terminal name, idle time, login time, and location if
known. finger requests are answered by the fingerd daemon.

Robert Tappan Morris's Internet Worm used the finger daemon. The finger
daemon allowed up to 512 bytes from the remote machine as part of the
finger request. fingerd, however, suffered from a buffer overflow bug
caused by a lack proper bounds checking. Anything over 512 got interpreted
by the machine being fingered as an instruction to be executed locally,
with whatever privileges the finger daemon had.

* www-http 80 World Wide Web HTTP

HTML (HyperText Markup Language) allows web page user to execute programs
on the host system. If the web page designer allows the web page user to
enter arguments to the commands, the system is vulnerable to the usual
problems associated with system() type calls. In addition, there is a
vulnerability that under some circumstances will give you an X-Term using
the UID that the WWW server is running under.

* sunrpc 111 SUN Remote Procedure Call

Sun RPC (Remote Procedure Call) allows users to execute procedures on
remote hosts. RPC has suffered from a lack of secure authentification. To
exploit RPC vulnerabilities, you should have a program called "ont" which
is not terribly difficult to find.

* login 513 Remote login

Some versions of AIX and Linux suffer from a bug in the way that rlogind
reads arguments. To exploit this vulnerability, issue this command from a
remote system:

rlogin host -l -froot

Where host is the name of the target machine and username is the username
you would like to rlogin as (usully root). If this bug exists on the hosts
system, you will be logged in, without being asked for a password.

* rsh-spx 222 Berkeley rshd with SPX auth

Some versions of Dynix and Irix have a bug in rshd that allows you to run
commands as root. To exploit this vulnerability, issue this command from
the remote system:

rsh host -l "" /bin/sh

* netinfo 716-719 NetInfo

NeXT has implemented a protocol known as NetInfo so that one NeXT machine
can query another NeXT machine for information. A NetInfo server will by
default allow unrestricted access to system databases. This can be fixed by
the System Administrator. One of the pieces of information netinfo will
give up is the password file.

* ibm-res 1405 IBM Remote Execution Starter

rexd (the remote execution daemon) allows you to execute a program on
another Unix machine. AIX, NeXT and HPUX versions of rexd have suffered
from a vulnerability allowing unintended remote execution. The rexd daemon
checks your uid on the machine you are coming from, therefore you must be
root on the machine you are mounting the rexd attack from. To determine if
your target machine is running rexd, use the 'rcp -p ' command. You will
also need the exploit program known as 'on' which is available on fine H/P
boards everywhere.

* nfs 2049 Network File System

NFS, the Network File System, from Sun Microsystems has suffered from
multiple security vulnerabilities. In addition, many system administrators
configure NFS incorrectly, allowing unintended remote access.

Using the command 'showmount -e ' you can view what file systems are
exported from a machine. Many administrators allow read access to the /etc
directory, allowing you to copy the password file. Other administrators
allow write access to user directories, allowing you to create .rhosts
files and gain access to the machine via rlogin or rsh.

In addition to configuration issues, NFS is vulnerable to attacks using a
uid masking bug, a mknod bug, and a general file handle guessing attack.
Several hacked versions of the mount command have been written to exploit
known vulnerabilities.

* x11 6000-6063 X Window System

X-Windows has suffered and currently suffers from numerous vulnerabilities.
One vulnerability allows you to access another users display, another
allows you to view another users keystrokes. Another vulnerability allows a
remote attacker to run every program that the root user starts in his or
her .xsession file. Yet another X-Windows vulnerability allows a local user
to create a root entry in the /etc/passwd file.

* rcp

The SunOS 4.0.x rcp utility can be exploited by any trusted host listed in
/etc/hosts.equiv or /.rhosts. To exploit this hole you must be running NFS
(Network File System) on a Unix system or PC/NFS on a DOS system.

* NIS

Sun's NIS (Network Information Service) also known as yp (Yellow Pages) has
a vulnerability where you can request an NIS map from another NIS domain if
you know the NIS domain name of the target system. There is no way to query
a remote system for it's NIS domainname, but many NIS domain names are
easily guessable. The most popular NIS map to request is passwd.byname, the
NIS implementation of /etc/passwd. In addition, if you have access to a
diskless Unix workstation, you can determine the NIS domain name of the
server it boots from.

         +--------------------------------------------------------+

         + Do not confuse NIS domain names with DNS domain names! +

         +--------------------------------------------------------+

* Other attacks

In addition to these daemon based attacks, many other methods can be used
to gain access to a remote computer. These include, but are not limited to:
default accounts, password guessing, sniffing, source routing, DNS routing
attacks, tcp sequence prediction and uucp configuration exploits.

This should give you an idea on how daemon based attacks function. By no
means is this a complete list of security vulnerabilities in privileged
internet daemons. To discover more information about how these daemons
operate, and how to exploit their vulnerabilities, I highly recommend
reading source code, man pages and RFC's.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Any comments are appreciated: Markus Hübner

                         Back to the Security-Page